├── Rivera ├── Rivera1 │ ├── readme.md │ ├── Rivera1.png │ ├── Rivera_shapefile.zip │ ├── rivera1_nodes.txt │ ├── rivera1_links.txt │ └── rivera1_demand.txt ├── Rivera.png ├── Rivera2 │ ├── readme.md │ ├── rivera2_nodes.txt │ ├── rivera2_links.txt │ └── rivera2_demand.txt └── readme.md ├── Mumford ├── Mumford0 │ ├── readme.md │ ├── Mumford0.png │ ├── mumford0_nodes.txt │ ├── mumford0_links.txt │ └── mumford0_demand.txt ├── Mumford1 │ ├── readme.md │ ├── Mumford1.png │ ├── mumford1_nodes.txt │ └── mumford1_links.txt ├── Mumford2 │ ├── readme.md │ ├── Mumford2.png │ ├── mumford2_nodes.txt │ └── mumford2_links.txt ├── Mumford3 │ ├── readme.md │ ├── Mumford3.png │ ├── mumford3_nodes.txt │ └── mumford3_links.txt ├── Suggestion.png └── readme.md ├── Mandl ├── Mandl.png ├── Mandl2 │ ├── Mandl2.png │ ├── Mandl2_shapefile.zip │ ├── readme.md │ ├── mandl2_nodes.txt │ ├── mandl2_links.txt │ └── mandl2_demand.txt ├── Mandl_demand_matrix.PNG ├── Mandl_desire_lines.PNG ├── Mandl1 │ ├── Mandl1_shapefile.zip │ ├── mandl1_nodes.txt │ ├── mandl1_links.txt │ ├── mandl1_demand.txt │ ├── readme.md │ └── literature_solutions_for_mandl1_20181025.txt └── readme.md ├── Ceder ├── Ceder1 │ ├── ceder1.png │ ├── ceder1 shapefile.zip │ ├── ceder1_links.txt │ ├── ceder1_nodes.txt │ ├── ceder1_demand.txt │ └── readme.md ├── Ceder2 │ ├── ceder2.png │ ├── ceder2_demand.png │ ├── ceder2_nodes.txt │ ├── readme.md │ ├── ceder2_links.txt │ └── ceder2_demand.txt └── README.md ├── LICENSE └── README.md /Rivera/Rivera1/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Rivera1 Instance 2 | 3 | ![](Rivera1.png) 4 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford0/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mumford0 Instance 2 | 3 | ![](Mumford0.png) 4 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford1/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mumford1 Instance 2 | 3 | ![](Mumford1.png) 4 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford2/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mumford2 Instance 2 | 3 | ![](Mumford2.png) 4 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford3/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mumford3 Instance 2 | 3 | ![](Mumford3.png) 4 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mandl/Mandl.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Rivera/Rivera.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Suggestion.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mumford/Suggestion.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder1/ceder1.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Ceder/Ceder1/ceder1.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder2/ceder2.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Ceder/Ceder2/ceder2.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl2/Mandl2.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mandl/Mandl2/Mandl2.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera2/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Rivera2 Instance 2 | 3 | TODO 4 | - Add map with suggested terminal location nodes 5 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera1/Rivera1.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Rivera/Rivera1/Rivera1.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder2/ceder2_demand.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Ceder/Ceder2/ceder2_demand.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl_demand_matrix.PNG: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mandl/Mandl_demand_matrix.PNG -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl_desire_lines.PNG: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mandl/Mandl_desire_lines.PNG -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford0/Mumford0.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mumford/Mumford0/Mumford0.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford1/Mumford1.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mumford/Mumford1/Mumford1.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford2/Mumford2.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mumford/Mumford2/Mumford2.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford3/Mumford3.png: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mumford/Mumford3/Mumford3.png -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder1/ceder1 shapefile.zip: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Ceder/Ceder1/ceder1 shapefile.zip -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl1/Mandl1_shapefile.zip: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mandl/Mandl1/Mandl1_shapefile.zip -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl2/Mandl2_shapefile.zip: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Mandl/Mandl2/Mandl2_shapefile.zip -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera1/Rivera_shapefile.zip: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- https://raw.githubusercontent.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign/HEAD/Rivera/Rivera1/Rivera_shapefile.zip -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder1/ceder1_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,2,5 3 | 1,3,10 4 | 2,3,25 5 | 3,4,16 6 | 2,1,5 7 | 3,1,10 8 | 3,2,25 9 | 4,3,16 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder1/ceder1_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,-46.509261,-25.011154,1 3 | 2,-46.42773,-25.011974,0 4 | 3,-46.42814,-25.089817,0 5 | 4,-46.347838,-25.011154,0 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder1/ceder1_demand.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,demand 2 | 1,2,200 3 | 1,3,350 4 | 1,4,100 5 | 2,1,200 6 | 2,3,150 7 | 2,4,80 8 | 3,1,350 9 | 3,2,150 10 | 3,4,120 11 | 4,1,100 12 | 4,2,80 13 | 4,3,120 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder2/ceder2_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,-25.417782,-46.360744,1 3 | 2,-25.452197,-46.244389,0 4 | 3,-25.503,-46.506597,0 5 | 4,-25.537415,-46.041177,1 6 | 5,-25.557081,-46.327148,0 7 | 6,-25.701296,-46.574608,0 8 | 7,-25.679991,-46.292734,0 9 | 8,-25.767667,-46.345995,0 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder2/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Ceder 2 2 | 3 | This instance has two terminal nodes, one at Node ID 1 and another at Node ID 4, which means routes can only start from those nodes, but may end on other nodes before returning the terminal. 4 | 5 | ![](ceder2.png) 6 | 7 | ![](ceder2_demand.png) 8 | 9 | *Solutions:* 10 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl2/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mandl2 Instance 2 | 3 | This Mandl instance adaptation has only 10 nodes that can start routes. Other nodes must be passing nodes only. 4 | 5 | ![](Mandl2.png) 6 | 7 | *Solutions:* 8 | 9 | A subset of solutions of Mandl1 applies to Mandl2. 10 | 11 | One of the advantages of restricting nodes to real-world conditions is that processing time is also reduced. 12 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder2/ceder2_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,2,5 3 | 1,3,15 4 | 2,1,5 5 | 2,3,20 6 | 2,5,10 7 | 2,4,20 8 | 3,1,15 9 | 3,2,20 10 | 3,5,20 11 | 3,6,30 12 | 4,2,20 13 | 4,5,25 14 | 4,7,25 15 | 5,2,10 16 | 5,3,20 17 | 5,4,25 18 | 5,6,35 19 | 5,7,10 20 | 5,8,25 21 | 6,3,30 22 | 6,5,35 23 | 6,8,30 24 | 7,4,25 25 | 7,5,10 26 | 7,8,5 27 | 8,5,25 28 | 8,6,30 29 | 8,7,5 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl1/mandl1_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,-25.874734,-46.449444,1 3 | 2,-25.973882,-46.350297,1 4 | 3,-25.977159,-46.216734,1 5 | 4,-26.083682,-46.349477,1 6 | 5,-26.083682,-46.506802,1 7 | 6,-26.08614,-46.217553,1 8 | 7,-26.218064,-45.884057,1 9 | 8,-26.218883,-46.09956,1 10 | 9,-26.08532,-45.836531,1 11 | 10,-26.376208,-45.978288,1 12 | 11,-26.461426,-46.04466,1 13 | 12,-26.331961,-46.38635,1 14 | 13,-26.504035,-45.936499,1 15 | 14,-26.439302,-45.855378,1 16 | 15,-26.084501,-45.987301,1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl2/mandl2_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,-25.874734,-46.449444,1 3 | 2,-25.973882,-46.350297,1 4 | 3,-25.977159,-46.216734,0 5 | 4,-26.083682,-46.349477,1 6 | 5,-26.083682,-46.506802,1 7 | 6,-26.08614,-46.217553,0 8 | 7,-26.218064,-45.884057,1 9 | 8,-26.218883,-46.09956,0 10 | 9,-26.08532,-45.836531,1 11 | 10,-26.376208,-45.978288,0 12 | 11,-26.461426,-46.04466,1 13 | 12,-26.331961,-46.38635,1 14 | 13,-26.504035,-45.936499,1 15 | 14,-26.439302,-45.855378,1 16 | 15,-26.084501,-45.987301,0 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford0/mumford0_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,13,14,1 3 | 2,1,16,1 4 | 3,5,3,1 5 | 4,1,16,1 6 | 5,2,11,1 7 | 6,14,2,1 8 | 7,12,5,1 9 | 8,6,10,1 10 | 9,17,17,1 11 | 10,1,17,1 12 | 11,8,3,1 13 | 12,7,17,1 14 | 13,14,17,1 15 | 14,14,9,1 16 | 15,4,14,1 17 | 16,9,3,1 18 | 17,8,8,1 19 | 18,11,16,1 20 | 19,13,14,1 21 | 20,13,17,1 22 | 21,5,12,1 23 | 22,12,1,1 24 | 23,12,15,1 25 | 24,3,16,1 26 | 25,3,12,1 27 | 26,9,13,1 28 | 27,17,13,1 29 | 28,6,7,1 30 | 29,10,12,1 31 | 30,4,3,1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl1/mandl1_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,2,8 3 | 2,1,8 4 | 2,3,2 5 | 2,4,3 6 | 2,5,6 7 | 3,2,2 8 | 3,6,3 9 | 4,2,3 10 | 4,5,4 11 | 4,6,4 12 | 4,12,10 13 | 5,2,6 14 | 5,4,4 15 | 6,3,3 16 | 6,4,4 17 | 6,8,2 18 | 6,15,3 19 | 7,10,7 20 | 7,15,2 21 | 8,6,2 22 | 8,10,8 23 | 8,15,2 24 | 9,15,8 25 | 10,7,7 26 | 10,8,8 27 | 10,11,5 28 | 10,13,10 29 | 10,14,8 30 | 11,10,5 31 | 11,12,10 32 | 11,13,5 33 | 12,4,10 34 | 12,11,10 35 | 13,10,10 36 | 13,11,5 37 | 13,14,2 38 | 14,10,8 39 | 14,13,2 40 | 15,6,3 41 | 15,7,2 42 | 15,8,2 43 | 15,9,8 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl2/mandl2_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,2,8 3 | 2,1,8 4 | 2,3,2 5 | 2,4,3 6 | 2,5,6 7 | 3,2,2 8 | 3,6,3 9 | 4,2,3 10 | 4,5,4 11 | 4,6,4 12 | 4,12,10 13 | 5,2,6 14 | 5,4,4 15 | 6,3,3 16 | 6,4,4 17 | 6,8,2 18 | 6,15,3 19 | 7,10,7 20 | 7,15,2 21 | 8,6,2 22 | 8,10,8 23 | 8,15,2 24 | 9,15,8 25 | 10,7,7 26 | 10,8,8 27 | 10,11,5 28 | 10,13,10 29 | 10,14,8 30 | 11,10,5 31 | 11,12,10 32 | 11,13,5 33 | 12,4,10 34 | 12,11,10 35 | 13,10,10 36 | 13,11,5 37 | 13,14,2 38 | 14,10,8 39 | 14,13,2 40 | 15,6,3 41 | 15,7,2 42 | 15,8,2 43 | 15,9,8 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder1/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Ceder1 Instance 2 | 3 | This instance has one terminal node at Node ID 1, which means routes can only start from this node, but may end on other nodes before returning to terminal at node 1. 4 | 5 | ![](ceder1.png) 6 | 7 | *Solutions:* 8 | Two suggested possible solutions are: 9 | 10 | ``` 11 | ceder1 solution1 12 | 2 13 | 1-2 14 | 1-3-4 15 | 16 | ceder1 solution2 17 | 3 18 | 1-2 19 | 1-3-4 20 | 1-3 21 | ``` 22 | 23 | While the first one minimizes average user generalized cost, the second one enables operation with lower fleet size as the extra 1-3 line will lower required frequency for route 1-3-4, thus reducing empty-space hours on the network. 24 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/README.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Ceder Instances 2 | 3 | | Network | Source | Nodes | Links | Terminal Nodes | 4 | |---------- |------------------------- |------- |------- |---------------- | 5 | | Ceder1 | Ceder (2016) Chapter 15 | 4 | 4 | 1 | 6 | | Ceder2 | Ceder (2016) Chapter 15 | 8 | 14 | 2 | 7 | 8 | Ceder, A. (2016). *Public transit planning and operation: Modeling, Practice and Behavior*. 2nd Edition. CRC press. 9 | 10 | Ceder instances are small instances that are great to start from and evaluate some concepts. Avishai Ceder uses those instances to explain Network Design in the above mentioned book, a great resource to understand the problem with a compendium of recent literature methods. 11 | 12 | 13 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Ceder/Ceder2/ceder2_demand.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,demand 2 | 1,2,80 3 | 1,3,70 4 | 1,4,160 5 | 1,5,50 6 | 1,6,200 7 | 1,7,120 8 | 1,8,60 9 | 2,1,80 10 | 2,3,120 11 | 2,4,90 12 | 2,5,100 13 | 2,6,70 14 | 2,7,250 15 | 2,8,70 16 | 3,1,70 17 | 3,2,120 18 | 3,4,180 19 | 3,5,150 20 | 3,6,120 21 | 3,7,30 22 | 3,8,250 23 | 4,1,160 24 | 4,2,90 25 | 4,3,180 26 | 4,5,80 27 | 4,6,210 28 | 4,7,170 29 | 4,8,230 30 | 5,1,50 31 | 5,2,100 32 | 5,3,150 33 | 5,4,80 34 | 5,6,250 35 | 5,7,40 36 | 5,8,130 37 | 6,1,200 38 | 6,2,70 39 | 6,3,120 40 | 6,4,210 41 | 6,5,250 42 | 6,7,130 43 | 6,8,120 44 | 7,1,120 45 | 7,2,250 46 | 7,3,30 47 | 7,4,170 48 | 7,5,40 49 | 7,6,130 50 | 7,8,70 51 | 8,1,60 52 | 8,2,70 53 | 8,3,250 54 | 8,4,230 55 | 8,5,130 56 | 8,6,120 57 | 8,7,70 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Rivera Instances 2 | | Network | Source | Nodes | Links | Terminal Nodes | 3 | |---------- |------------------------- |------- |------- |---------------- | 4 | | Rivera1 | Mauttone (2005) | 84 | 143 | All | 5 | | Rivera2 | Mauttone (2005) adapted | 84 | 143 | 12 | 6 | 7 | Instances general comments: 8 | 9 | Total demand in this instance is quite low. 10 | 11 | Rivera instance node location was chosen after superposing the network with an aerial view, thus might bring some differences from real inicial locations. 12 | 13 | A Rivera2 instance is proposed considering only a subset of possible terminal nodes. 14 | 15 | Solutions will be presented inside each instance folder. 16 | 17 | Instance image: 18 | ![](Rivera.png) 19 | 20 | TODO 21 | - Gather solutions route sets and objective functions 22 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mumford Instances 2 | 3 | | Network | Source | Nodes | Links | Terminal Nodes | 4 | |---------- |------------------------- |------- |------- |---------------- | 5 | | Mumford0 | Mumford (2013) | 30 | 90 | All | 6 | | Mumford1 | Mumford (2013) | 70 | 210 | All | 7 | | Mumford2 | Mumford (2013) | 110 | 385 | All | 8 | | Mumford3 | Mumford (2013) | 127 | 425 | All | 9 | 10 | Instances general comments: 11 | 12 | Mumford suggests a fixed number of routes per instance and a range of number of routes per route. 13 | 14 | ![](Suggestion.png) 15 | 16 | As Mumford instances node location don't represent a real world exact location (as Mandl), node coordinates are used in place of latitudes and longitudes. 17 | 18 | TODO 19 | - Gather and Include proposed route sets for all instances (best and Pareto frontier) as well as objective functions and addicional data and considerations from authors. 20 | 21 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /LICENSE: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | MIT License 2 | 3 | Copyright (c) 2018 Renato Arbex 4 | 5 | Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy 6 | of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal 7 | in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights 8 | to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell 9 | copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is 10 | furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions: 11 | 12 | The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all 13 | copies or substantial portions of the Software. 14 | 15 | THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR 16 | IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, 17 | FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE 18 | AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER 19 | LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, 20 | OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE 21 | SOFTWARE. 22 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford1/mumford1_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,25,12,1 3 | 2,8,5,1 4 | 3,25,9,1 5 | 4,24,18,1 6 | 5,6,25,1 7 | 6,20,25,1 8 | 7,5,16,1 9 | 8,3,25,1 10 | 9,9,11,1 11 | 10,10,2,1 12 | 11,11,8,1 13 | 12,8,1,1 14 | 13,9,23,1 15 | 14,19,12,1 16 | 15,25,3,1 17 | 16,3,4,1 18 | 17,8,7,1 19 | 18,16,6,1 20 | 19,22,23,1 21 | 20,21,20,1 22 | 21,15,9,1 23 | 22,1,11,1 24 | 23,18,16,1 25 | 24,23,14,1 26 | 25,2,9,1 27 | 26,10,23,1 28 | 27,7,7,1 29 | 28,12,25,1 30 | 29,8,11,1 31 | 30,26,18,1 32 | 31,4,8,1 33 | 32,6,1,1 34 | 33,24,25,1 35 | 34,17,14,1 36 | 35,11,18,1 37 | 36,10,16,1 38 | 37,17,20,1 39 | 38,20,26,1 40 | 39,20,19,1 41 | 40,25,23,1 42 | 41,2,26,1 43 | 42,12,20,1 44 | 43,1,4,1 45 | 44,19,9,1 46 | 45,21,1,1 47 | 46,15,19,1 48 | 47,1,25,1 49 | 48,1,19,1 50 | 49,26,20,1 51 | 50,6,5,1 52 | 51,22,10,1 53 | 52,10,15,1 54 | 53,12,12,1 55 | 54,3,22,1 56 | 55,21,22,1 57 | 56,12,9,1 58 | 57,8,13,1 59 | 58,10,18,1 60 | 59,13,16,1 61 | 60,12,4,1 62 | 61,19,1,1 63 | 62,18,4,1 64 | 63,1,6,1 65 | 64,3,12,1 66 | 65,12,14,1 67 | 66,21,26,1 68 | 67,22,19,1 69 | 68,17,26,1 70 | 69,10,2,1 71 | 70,24,17,1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mandl Instances 2 | 3 | | Network | Source | Nodes | Links | Terminal Nodes | 4 | |---------- |------------------------- |------- |------- |---------------- | 5 | | Mandl1 | Mandl (1979) | 15 | 21 | All | 6 | | Mandl2 | Mandl (1979) adapted | 15 | 21 | 10 | 7 | 8 | Instances general comments: 9 | 10 | Mandl instance is a very known instance in the field. It comprises 15 nodes and 21 links, with a symmetrical demand of 15.570 trips total. 11 | 12 | In this folder an additional instance is suggested for testing. Mandl2 is an adapted instance where only a subset of 10 nodes are terminal ones. Some nodes are then not allowed to start or end routes. This aims to represent real-world scenarios of congested central areas where only passing through lines are allowed and is proposed for testing methodologies that takes terminal locations into consideration. 13 | 14 | Solutions are presented inside each instance folder. 15 | 16 | Instance images: 17 | 18 | Values along links are travel times in minutes. 19 | ![](Mandl.png) 20 | 21 | ![](Mandl_demand_matrix.PNG) 22 | 23 | ![](Mandl_desire_lines.PNG) 24 | 25 | The above mentioned visualizations were donated by Renato Arbex, as presented in Arbex and Cunha [(2015)](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191261515001435) 26 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford2/mumford2_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,3,7,1 3 | 2,1,6,1 4 | 3,12,14,1 5 | 4,19,15,1 6 | 5,28,33,1 7 | 6,21,31,1 8 | 7,20,11,1 9 | 8,7,29,1 10 | 9,9,19,1 11 | 10,22,18,1 12 | 11,11,28,1 13 | 12,18,27,1 14 | 13,5,18,1 15 | 14,15,1,1 16 | 15,33,13,1 17 | 16,14,15,1 18 | 17,3,21,1 19 | 18,10,5,1 20 | 19,19,19,1 21 | 20,25,14,1 22 | 21,11,2,1 23 | 22,17,5,1 24 | 23,21,13,1 25 | 24,25,16,1 26 | 25,23,11,1 27 | 26,5,29,1 28 | 27,30,21,1 29 | 28,13,7,1 30 | 29,18,5,1 31 | 30,33,26,1 32 | 31,32,22,1 33 | 32,27,12,1 34 | 33,14,2,1 35 | 34,27,14,1 36 | 35,15,16,1 37 | 36,13,18,1 38 | 37,24,28,1 39 | 38,8,33,1 40 | 39,6,13,1 41 | 40,8,7,1 42 | 41,10,33,1 43 | 42,2,23,1 44 | 43,19,31,1 45 | 44,32,22,1 46 | 45,26,22,1 47 | 46,8,13,1 48 | 47,23,1,1 49 | 48,1,20,1 50 | 49,26,25,1 51 | 50,11,22,1 52 | 51,11,3,1 53 | 52,26,6,1 54 | 53,13,25,1 55 | 54,8,17,1 56 | 55,19,13,1 57 | 56,8,10,1 58 | 57,6,7,1 59 | 58,14,32,1 60 | 59,1,14,1 61 | 60,14,5,1 62 | 61,1,18,1 63 | 62,2,2,1 64 | 63,7,19,1 65 | 64,7,14,1 66 | 65,20,26,1 67 | 66,8,6,1 68 | 67,19,16,1 69 | 68,19,20,1 70 | 69,12,3,1 71 | 70,33,17,1 72 | 71,5,26,1 73 | 72,29,5,1 74 | 73,26,24,1 75 | 74,18,28,1 76 | 75,1,17,1 77 | 76,9,1,1 78 | 77,33,12,1 79 | 78,24,33,1 80 | 79,8,5,1 81 | 80,22,26,1 82 | 81,4,12,1 83 | 82,19,10,1 84 | 83,27,18,1 85 | 84,14,14,1 86 | 85,3,31,1 87 | 86,20,12,1 88 | 87,22,4,1 89 | 88,5,9,1 90 | 89,29,6,1 91 | 90,17,27,1 92 | 91,10,21,1 93 | 92,11,22,1 94 | 93,22,22,1 95 | 94,17,19,1 96 | 95,15,10,1 97 | 96,11,4,1 98 | 97,19,28,1 99 | 98,1,11,1 100 | 99,19,20,1 101 | 100,31,16,1 102 | 101,16,22,1 103 | 102,11,9,1 104 | 103,27,10,1 105 | 104,5,23,1 106 | 105,3,33,1 107 | 106,15,10,1 108 | 107,16,29,1 109 | 108,25,30,1 110 | 109,24,28,1 111 | 110,18,25,1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford3/mumford3_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,23,16,1 3 | 2,19,19,1 4 | 3,18,13,1 5 | 4,9,5,1 6 | 5,3,29,1 7 | 6,7,18,1 8 | 7,24,6,1 9 | 8,26,18,1 10 | 9,31,33,1 11 | 10,10,16,1 12 | 11,1,24,1 13 | 12,21,17,1 14 | 13,8,5,1 15 | 14,34,13,1 16 | 15,10,11,1 17 | 16,9,1,1 18 | 17,19,6,1 19 | 18,10,32,1 20 | 19,1,27,1 21 | 20,36,3,1 22 | 21,33,6,1 23 | 22,35,34,1 24 | 23,31,32,1 25 | 24,14,12,1 26 | 25,4,17,1 27 | 26,27,26,1 28 | 27,25,16,1 29 | 28,16,20,1 30 | 29,6,35,1 31 | 30,12,18,1 32 | 31,25,30,1 33 | 32,19,27,1 34 | 33,27,6,1 35 | 34,24,29,1 36 | 35,3,1,1 37 | 36,36,27,1 38 | 37,7,18,1 39 | 38,17,13,1 40 | 39,21,28,1 41 | 40,24,26,1 42 | 41,30,16,1 43 | 42,28,30,1 44 | 43,11,30,1 45 | 44,7,30,1 46 | 45,31,19,1 47 | 46,24,6,1 48 | 47,22,22,1 49 | 48,18,33,1 50 | 49,23,11,1 51 | 50,14,13,1 52 | 51,32,12,1 53 | 52,18,27,1 54 | 53,17,26,1 55 | 54,11,11,1 56 | 55,20,32,1 57 | 56,21,4,1 58 | 57,6,3,1 59 | 58,26,35,1 60 | 59,8,23,1 61 | 60,11,28,1 62 | 61,26,6,1 63 | 62,7,12,1 64 | 63,16,1,1 65 | 64,8,21,1 66 | 65,5,34,1 67 | 66,30,17,1 68 | 67,12,13,1 69 | 68,18,19,1 70 | 69,3,4,1 71 | 70,3,28,1 72 | 71,12,14,1 73 | 72,12,6,1 74 | 73,13,14,1 75 | 74,24,10,1 76 | 75,16,11,1 77 | 76,30,1,1 78 | 77,32,9,1 79 | 78,20,17,1 80 | 79,13,6,1 81 | 80,20,14,1 82 | 81,10,17,1 83 | 82,14,19,1 84 | 83,31,20,1 85 | 84,32,12,1 86 | 85,3,8,1 87 | 86,35,6,1 88 | 87,1,21,1 89 | 88,3,12,1 90 | 89,28,24,1 91 | 90,14,29,1 92 | 91,8,30,1 93 | 92,31,25,1 94 | 93,31,11,1 95 | 94,28,19,1 96 | 95,13,20,1 97 | 96,35,18,1 98 | 97,12,6,1 99 | 98,21,13,1 100 | 99,8,32,1 101 | 100,22,9,1 102 | 101,12,7,1 103 | 102,26,19,1 104 | 103,3,14,1 105 | 104,4,31,1 106 | 105,7,26,1 107 | 106,7,25,1 108 | 107,6,12,1 109 | 108,10,1,1 110 | 109,7,12,1 111 | 110,2,27,1 112 | 111,3,9,1 113 | 112,1,35,1 114 | 113,23,1,1 115 | 114,10,30,1 116 | 115,17,8,1 117 | 116,7,10,1 118 | 117,30,17,1 119 | 118,1,21,1 120 | 119,19,22,1 121 | 120,34,35,1 122 | 121,27,18,1 123 | 122,29,23,1 124 | 123,14,23,1 125 | 124,35,23,1 126 | 125,13,14,1 127 | 126,32,26,1 128 | 127,27,11,1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl1/mandl1_demand.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,demand 2 | 1,2,400 3 | 1,3,200 4 | 1,4,60 5 | 1,5,80 6 | 1,6,150 7 | 1,7,75 8 | 1,8,75 9 | 1,9,30 10 | 1,10,160 11 | 1,11,30 12 | 1,12,25 13 | 1,13,35 14 | 2,1,400 15 | 2,3,50 16 | 2,4,120 17 | 2,5,20 18 | 2,6,180 19 | 2,7,90 20 | 2,8,90 21 | 2,9,15 22 | 2,10,130 23 | 2,11,20 24 | 2,12,10 25 | 2,13,10 26 | 2,14,5 27 | 3,1,200 28 | 3,2,50 29 | 3,4,40 30 | 3,5,60 31 | 3,6,180 32 | 3,7,90 33 | 3,8,90 34 | 3,9,15 35 | 3,10,45 36 | 3,11,20 37 | 3,12,10 38 | 3,13,10 39 | 3,14,5 40 | 4,1,60 41 | 4,2,120 42 | 4,3,40 43 | 4,5,50 44 | 4,6,100 45 | 4,7,50 46 | 4,8,50 47 | 4,9,15 48 | 4,10,240 49 | 4,11,40 50 | 4,12,25 51 | 4,13,10 52 | 4,14,5 53 | 5,1,80 54 | 5,2,20 55 | 5,3,60 56 | 5,4,50 57 | 5,6,50 58 | 5,7,25 59 | 5,8,25 60 | 5,9,10 61 | 5,10,120 62 | 5,11,20 63 | 5,12,15 64 | 5,13,5 65 | 6,1,150 66 | 6,2,180 67 | 6,3,180 68 | 6,4,100 69 | 6,5,50 70 | 6,7,100 71 | 6,8,100 72 | 6,9,30 73 | 6,10,880 74 | 6,11,60 75 | 6,12,15 76 | 6,13,15 77 | 6,14,10 78 | 7,1,75 79 | 7,2,90 80 | 7,3,90 81 | 7,4,50 82 | 7,5,25 83 | 7,6,100 84 | 7,8,50 85 | 7,9,15 86 | 7,10,440 87 | 7,11,35 88 | 7,12,10 89 | 7,13,10 90 | 7,14,5 91 | 8,1,75 92 | 8,2,90 93 | 8,3,90 94 | 8,4,50 95 | 8,5,25 96 | 8,6,100 97 | 8,7,50 98 | 8,9,15 99 | 8,10,440 100 | 8,11,35 101 | 8,12,10 102 | 8,13,10 103 | 8,14,5 104 | 9,1,30 105 | 9,2,15 106 | 9,3,15 107 | 9,4,15 108 | 9,5,10 109 | 9,6,30 110 | 9,7,15 111 | 9,8,15 112 | 9,10,140 113 | 9,11,20 114 | 9,12,5 115 | 10,1,160 116 | 10,2,130 117 | 10,3,45 118 | 10,4,240 119 | 10,5,120 120 | 10,6,880 121 | 10,7,440 122 | 10,8,440 123 | 10,9,140 124 | 10,11,600 125 | 10,12,250 126 | 10,13,500 127 | 10,14,200 128 | 11,1,30 129 | 11,2,20 130 | 11,3,20 131 | 11,4,40 132 | 11,5,20 133 | 11,6,60 134 | 11,7,35 135 | 11,8,35 136 | 11,9,20 137 | 11,10,600 138 | 11,12,75 139 | 11,13,95 140 | 11,14,15 141 | 12,1,25 142 | 12,2,10 143 | 12,3,10 144 | 12,4,25 145 | 12,5,15 146 | 12,6,15 147 | 12,7,10 148 | 12,8,10 149 | 12,9,5 150 | 12,10,250 151 | 12,11,75 152 | 12,13,70 153 | 13,1,35 154 | 13,2,10 155 | 13,3,10 156 | 13,4,10 157 | 13,5,5 158 | 13,6,15 159 | 13,7,10 160 | 13,8,10 161 | 13,10,500 162 | 13,11,95 163 | 13,12,70 164 | 13,14,45 165 | 14,2,5 166 | 14,3,5 167 | 14,4,5 168 | 14,6,10 169 | 14,7,5 170 | 14,8,5 171 | 14,10,200 172 | 14,11,15 173 | 14,13,45 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl2/mandl2_demand.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,demand 2 | 1,2,400 3 | 1,3,200 4 | 1,4,60 5 | 1,5,80 6 | 1,6,150 7 | 1,7,75 8 | 1,8,75 9 | 1,9,30 10 | 1,10,160 11 | 1,11,30 12 | 1,12,25 13 | 1,13,35 14 | 2,1,400 15 | 2,3,50 16 | 2,4,120 17 | 2,5,20 18 | 2,6,180 19 | 2,7,90 20 | 2,8,90 21 | 2,9,15 22 | 2,10,130 23 | 2,11,20 24 | 2,12,10 25 | 2,13,10 26 | 2,14,5 27 | 3,1,200 28 | 3,2,50 29 | 3,4,40 30 | 3,5,60 31 | 3,6,180 32 | 3,7,90 33 | 3,8,90 34 | 3,9,15 35 | 3,10,45 36 | 3,11,20 37 | 3,12,10 38 | 3,13,10 39 | 3,14,5 40 | 4,1,60 41 | 4,2,120 42 | 4,3,40 43 | 4,5,50 44 | 4,6,100 45 | 4,7,50 46 | 4,8,50 47 | 4,9,15 48 | 4,10,240 49 | 4,11,40 50 | 4,12,25 51 | 4,13,10 52 | 4,14,5 53 | 5,1,80 54 | 5,2,20 55 | 5,3,60 56 | 5,4,50 57 | 5,6,50 58 | 5,7,25 59 | 5,8,25 60 | 5,9,10 61 | 5,10,120 62 | 5,11,20 63 | 5,12,15 64 | 5,13,5 65 | 6,1,150 66 | 6,2,180 67 | 6,3,180 68 | 6,4,100 69 | 6,5,50 70 | 6,7,100 71 | 6,8,100 72 | 6,9,30 73 | 6,10,880 74 | 6,11,60 75 | 6,12,15 76 | 6,13,15 77 | 6,14,10 78 | 7,1,75 79 | 7,2,90 80 | 7,3,90 81 | 7,4,50 82 | 7,5,25 83 | 7,6,100 84 | 7,8,50 85 | 7,9,15 86 | 7,10,440 87 | 7,11,35 88 | 7,12,10 89 | 7,13,10 90 | 7,14,5 91 | 8,1,75 92 | 8,2,90 93 | 8,3,90 94 | 8,4,50 95 | 8,5,25 96 | 8,6,100 97 | 8,7,50 98 | 8,9,15 99 | 8,10,440 100 | 8,11,35 101 | 8,12,10 102 | 8,13,10 103 | 8,14,5 104 | 9,1,30 105 | 9,2,15 106 | 9,3,15 107 | 9,4,15 108 | 9,5,10 109 | 9,6,30 110 | 9,7,15 111 | 9,8,15 112 | 9,10,140 113 | 9,11,20 114 | 9,12,5 115 | 10,1,160 116 | 10,2,130 117 | 10,3,45 118 | 10,4,240 119 | 10,5,120 120 | 10,6,880 121 | 10,7,440 122 | 10,8,440 123 | 10,9,140 124 | 10,11,600 125 | 10,12,250 126 | 10,13,500 127 | 10,14,200 128 | 11,1,30 129 | 11,2,20 130 | 11,3,20 131 | 11,4,40 132 | 11,5,20 133 | 11,6,60 134 | 11,7,35 135 | 11,8,35 136 | 11,9,20 137 | 11,10,600 138 | 11,12,75 139 | 11,13,95 140 | 11,14,15 141 | 12,1,25 142 | 12,2,10 143 | 12,3,10 144 | 12,4,25 145 | 12,5,15 146 | 12,6,15 147 | 12,7,10 148 | 12,8,10 149 | 12,9,5 150 | 12,10,250 151 | 12,11,75 152 | 12,13,70 153 | 13,1,35 154 | 13,2,10 155 | 13,3,10 156 | 13,4,10 157 | 13,5,5 158 | 13,6,15 159 | 13,7,10 160 | 13,8,10 161 | 13,10,500 162 | 13,11,95 163 | 13,12,70 164 | 13,14,45 165 | 14,2,5 166 | 14,3,5 167 | 14,4,5 168 | 14,6,10 169 | 14,7,5 170 | 14,8,5 171 | 14,10,200 172 | 14,11,15 173 | 14,13,45 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford0/mumford0_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,13,4 3 | 1,14,6 4 | 1,18,4 5 | 1,19,1 6 | 1,20,4 7 | 1,23,2 8 | 1,26,5 9 | 1,27,5 10 | 1,29,5 11 | 2,4,1 12 | 2,5,6 13 | 2,10,2 14 | 2,15,5 15 | 2,24,3 16 | 2,25,5 17 | 3,7,8 18 | 3,8,8 19 | 3,11,4 20 | 3,16,5 21 | 3,17,7 22 | 3,22,8 23 | 3,28,5 24 | 3,30,2 25 | 4,2,1 26 | 4,5,6 27 | 4,10,2 28 | 4,12,7 29 | 4,15,5 30 | 4,24,3 31 | 4,25,5 32 | 5,2,6 33 | 5,4,6 34 | 5,8,5 35 | 5,15,5 36 | 5,21,4 37 | 5,24,6 38 | 5,25,2 39 | 6,7,5 40 | 6,16,6 41 | 6,22,3 42 | 7,3,8 43 | 7,6,5 44 | 7,11,5 45 | 7,14,5 46 | 7,16,5 47 | 7,17,6 48 | 7,22,5 49 | 8,3,8 50 | 8,5,5 51 | 8,11,8 52 | 8,15,5 53 | 8,17,4 54 | 8,21,3 55 | 8,25,5 56 | 8,26,5 57 | 8,28,4 58 | 8,29,5 59 | 9,13,4 60 | 9,20,5 61 | 9,27,5 62 | 10,2,2 63 | 10,4,2 64 | 10,15,5 65 | 10,24,3 66 | 11,3,4 67 | 11,7,5 68 | 11,8,8 69 | 11,16,2 70 | 11,17,6 71 | 11,22,5 72 | 11,28,5 73 | 11,30,5 74 | 12,4,7 75 | 12,15,5 76 | 12,18,5 77 | 12,26,5 78 | 13,1,4 79 | 13,9,4 80 | 13,18,4 81 | 13,19,4 82 | 13,20,2 83 | 13,23,4 84 | 14,1,6 85 | 14,7,5 86 | 14,19,6 87 | 15,2,5 88 | 15,4,5 89 | 15,5,5 90 | 15,8,5 91 | 15,10,5 92 | 15,12,5 93 | 15,21,3 94 | 15,24,3 95 | 15,25,3 96 | 16,3,5 97 | 16,6,6 98 | 16,7,5 99 | 16,11,2 100 | 16,17,6 101 | 16,22,5 102 | 16,28,6 103 | 16,30,6 104 | 17,3,7 105 | 17,7,6 106 | 17,8,4 107 | 17,11,6 108 | 17,16,6 109 | 17,28,3 110 | 17,29,5 111 | 18,1,4 112 | 18,12,5 113 | 18,13,4 114 | 18,19,4 115 | 18,20,3 116 | 18,23,2 117 | 18,29,5 118 | 19,1,1 119 | 19,13,4 120 | 19,14,6 121 | 19,18,4 122 | 19,20,4 123 | 19,23,2 124 | 20,1,4 125 | 20,9,5 126 | 20,13,2 127 | 20,18,3 128 | 20,19,4 129 | 20,23,3 130 | 21,5,4 131 | 21,8,3 132 | 21,15,3 133 | 21,24,5 134 | 21,25,3 135 | 22,3,8 136 | 22,6,3 137 | 22,7,5 138 | 22,11,5 139 | 22,16,5 140 | 23,1,2 141 | 23,13,4 142 | 23,18,2 143 | 23,19,2 144 | 23,20,3 145 | 23,26,5 146 | 24,2,3 147 | 24,4,3 148 | 24,5,6 149 | 24,10,3 150 | 24,15,3 151 | 24,21,5 152 | 24,25,5 153 | 25,2,5 154 | 25,4,5 155 | 25,5,2 156 | 25,8,5 157 | 25,15,3 158 | 25,21,3 159 | 25,24,5 160 | 26,1,5 161 | 26,8,5 162 | 26,12,5 163 | 26,23,5 164 | 26,29,2 165 | 27,1,5 166 | 27,9,5 167 | 28,3,5 168 | 28,8,4 169 | 28,11,5 170 | 28,16,6 171 | 28,17,3 172 | 28,30,5 173 | 29,1,5 174 | 29,8,5 175 | 29,17,5 176 | 29,18,5 177 | 29,26,2 178 | 30,3,2 179 | 30,11,5 180 | 30,16,6 181 | 30,28,5 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera1/rivera1_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,-30.875393,-55.60165,1 3 | 2,-30.876683,-55.591102,1 4 | 3,-30.889253,-55.586219,1 5 | 4,-30.885728,-55.577737,1 6 | 5,-30.872179,-55.574653,1 7 | 6,-30.879339,-55.567823,1 8 | 7,-30.888482,-55.570687,1 9 | 8,-30.892227,-55.580711,1 10 | 9,-30.898065,-55.584456,1 11 | 10,-30.896853,-55.577406,1 12 | 11,-30.896302,-55.57256,1 13 | 12,-30.882423,-55.562206,1 14 | 13,-30.884461,-55.563693,1 15 | 14,-30.886719,-55.56507,1 16 | 15,-30.890079,-55.567548,1 17 | 16,-30.896688,-55.569365,1 18 | 17,-30.883855,-55.560058,1 19 | 18,-30.889031,-55.55915,1 20 | 19,-30.890935,-55.561864,1 21 | 20,-30.892723,-55.563032,1 22 | 21,-30.895506,-55.564959,1 23 | 22,-30.897941,-55.566421,1 24 | 23,-30.900743,-55.568407,1 25 | 24,-30.903056,-55.564692,1 26 | 25,-30.900046,-55.562477,1 27 | 26,-30.897609,-55.561217,1 28 | 27,-30.89465,-55.559232,1 29 | 28,-30.891628,-55.556933,1 30 | 29,-30.896358,-55.555872,1 31 | 30,-30.899342,-55.558088,1 32 | 31,-30.9015,-55.559985,1 33 | 32,-30.904626,-55.561783,1 34 | 33,-30.905875,-55.559157,1 35 | 34,-30.903015,-55.556896,1 36 | 35,-30.900909,-55.555252,1 37 | 36,-30.902636,-55.551851,1 38 | 37,-30.899882,-55.549208,1 39 | 38,-30.901039,-55.547721,1 40 | 39,-30.902691,-55.544581,1 41 | 40,-30.902912,-55.547556,1 42 | 41,-30.904288,-55.548767,1 43 | 42,-30.904288,-55.553779,1 44 | 43,-30.90572,-55.554936,1 45 | 44,-30.907641,-55.556882,1 46 | 45,-30.910842,-55.563803,1 47 | 46,-30.911724,-55.571458,1 48 | 47,-30.913321,-55.577792,1 49 | 48,-30.91602,-55.581813,1 50 | 49,-30.919985,-55.581978,1 51 | 50,-30.907042,-55.551851,1 52 | 51,-30.909576,-55.55455,1 53 | 52,-30.90561,-55.546179,1 54 | 53,-30.907979,-55.550309,1 55 | 54,-30.908034,-55.546564,1 56 | 55,-30.909291,-55.54826,1 57 | 56,-30.910071,-55.550805,1 58 | 57,-30.911503,-55.550695,1 59 | 58,-30.91266,-55.551796,1 60 | 59,-30.915524,-55.553283,1 61 | 60,-30.918939,-55.555211,1 62 | 61,-30.917782,-55.558791,1 63 | 62,-30.918443,-55.562811,1 64 | 63,-30.921197,-55.565565,1 65 | 64,-30.922574,-55.567273,1 66 | 65,-30.920729,-55.557359,1 67 | 66,-30.922375,-55.555472,1 68 | 67,-30.922656,-55.559176,1 69 | 68,-30.924694,-55.560003,1 70 | 69,-30.927062,-55.561545,1 71 | 70,-30.904949,-55.541456,1 72 | 71,-30.907648,-55.542392,1 73 | 72,-30.909392,-55.545986,1 74 | 73,-30.910237,-55.542447,1 75 | 74,-30.904454,-55.538151,1 76 | 75,-30.904399,-55.535232,1 77 | 76,-30.905335,-55.531432,1 78 | 77,-30.906822,-55.529615,1 79 | 78,-30.910732,-55.529151,1 80 | 79,-30.914448,-55.531025,1 81 | 80,-30.911797,-55.535012,1 82 | 81,-30.910555,-55.537114,1 83 | 82,-30.911724,-55.54421,1 84 | 83,-30.916075,-55.549497,1 85 | 84,-30.908441,-55.541085,1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera2/rivera2_nodes.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | id,lat,lon,terminal 2 | 1,-30.875393,-55.60165,1 3 | 2,-30.876683,-55.591102,0 4 | 3,-30.889253,-55.586219,0 5 | 4,-30.885728,-55.577737,0 6 | 5,-30.872179,-55.574653,0 7 | 6,-30.879339,-55.567823,1 8 | 7,-30.888482,-55.570687,0 9 | 8,-30.892227,-55.580711,0 10 | 9,-30.898065,-55.584456,0 11 | 10,-30.896853,-55.577406,0 12 | 11,-30.896302,-55.57256,0 13 | 12,-30.882423,-55.562206,0 14 | 13,-30.884461,-55.563693,0 15 | 14,-30.886719,-55.56507,0 16 | 15,-30.890079,-55.567548,0 17 | 16,-30.896688,-55.569365,0 18 | 17,-30.883855,-55.560058,0 19 | 18,-30.889031,-55.55915,0 20 | 19,-30.890935,-55.561864,0 21 | 20,-30.892723,-55.563032,0 22 | 21,-30.895506,-55.564959,0 23 | 22,-30.897941,-55.566421,0 24 | 23,-30.900743,-55.568407,0 25 | 24,-30.903056,-55.564692,0 26 | 25,-30.900046,-55.562477,0 27 | 26,-30.897609,-55.561217,1 28 | 27,-30.89465,-55.559232,0 29 | 28,-30.891628,-55.556933,0 30 | 29,-30.896358,-55.555872,0 31 | 30,-30.899342,-55.558088,0 32 | 31,-30.9015,-55.559985,0 33 | 32,-30.904626,-55.561783,0 34 | 33,-30.905875,-55.559157,0 35 | 34,-30.903015,-55.556896,0 36 | 35,-30.900909,-55.555252,0 37 | 36,-30.902636,-55.551851,0 38 | 37,-30.899882,-55.549208,0 39 | 38,-30.901039,-55.547721,0 40 | 39,-30.902691,-55.544581,1 41 | 40,-30.902912,-55.547556,0 42 | 41,-30.904288,-55.548767,0 43 | 42,-30.904288,-55.553779,0 44 | 43,-30.90572,-55.554936,0 45 | 44,-30.907641,-55.556882,1 46 | 45,-30.910842,-55.563803,1 47 | 46,-30.911724,-55.571458,0 48 | 47,-30.913321,-55.577792,0 49 | 48,-30.91602,-55.581813,0 50 | 49,-30.919985,-55.581978,1 51 | 50,-30.907042,-55.551851,1 52 | 51,-30.909576,-55.55455,0 53 | 52,-30.90561,-55.546179,0 54 | 53,-30.907979,-55.550309,0 55 | 54,-30.908034,-55.546564,1 56 | 55,-30.909291,-55.54826,0 57 | 56,-30.910071,-55.550805,0 58 | 57,-30.911503,-55.550695,0 59 | 58,-30.91266,-55.551796,0 60 | 59,-30.915524,-55.553283,0 61 | 60,-30.918939,-55.555211,0 62 | 61,-30.917782,-55.558791,0 63 | 62,-30.918443,-55.562811,0 64 | 63,-30.921197,-55.565565,0 65 | 64,-30.922574,-55.567273,0 66 | 65,-30.920729,-55.557359,0 67 | 66,-30.922375,-55.555472,0 68 | 67,-30.922656,-55.559176,0 69 | 68,-30.924694,-55.560003,0 70 | 69,-30.927062,-55.561545,1 71 | 70,-30.904949,-55.541456,0 72 | 71,-30.907648,-55.542392,0 73 | 72,-30.909392,-55.545986,0 74 | 73,-30.910237,-55.542447,0 75 | 74,-30.904454,-55.538151,0 76 | 75,-30.904399,-55.535232,0 77 | 76,-30.905335,-55.531432,0 78 | 77,-30.906822,-55.529615,0 79 | 78,-30.910732,-55.529151,1 80 | 79,-30.914448,-55.531025,0 81 | 80,-30.911797,-55.535012,0 82 | 81,-30.910555,-55.537114,0 83 | 82,-30.911724,-55.54421,0 84 | 83,-30.916075,-55.549497,0 85 | 84,-30.908441,-55.541085,1 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl1/readme.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Mandl1 Instance 2 | 3 | ![](../Mandl.png) 4 | 5 | *Solutions:* 6 | For now, all literature solutions (that I know of) are presented in a single file in this folder. Further organization of proposed solutions and addition of more solutions will be made. 7 | 8 | The following solutions are included in the txt file: 9 | ``` 10 | Arbex (2014) 61 solutions Pareto Set 11 | Arbex and Cunha (2015) 10 lines Best Compromising 12 | Baaj and Mahmassani (1991) 6 lines 13 | Baaj and Mahmassani (1991) 7 lines 14 | Baaj and Mahmassani (1991) 8 lines 15 | Bagloee and Ceder (2011) 12 routes 16 | Buba and Lee (2018) 12 routes 17 | Buba and Lee (2018) 4 routes 18 | Buba and Lee (2018) 6 routes 19 | Buba and Lee (2018) 7 routes 20 | Buba and Lee (2018) 8 routes 21 | Chakroborty (2002) 4 lines 22 | Chakroborty (2002) 6 lines 23 | Chakroborty (2002) 7 lines 24 | Chakroborty (2002) 8 lines 25 | Chew and Lee (2013) 4 routes operator 26 | Chew and Lee (2013) 4 routes passenger 27 | Chew and Lee (2013) 6 routes operator 28 | Chew and Lee (2013) 6 routes passenger 29 | Chew and Lee (2013) 7 routes operator 30 | Chew and Lee (2013) 7 routes passenger 31 | Chew and Lee (2013) 8 routes operator 32 | Chew and Lee (2013) 8 routes passenger 33 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 4 routes 34 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 6 routes 35 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 7 routes 36 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 8 routes 37 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 4 Lines HC 38 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 4 Lines TS 39 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 6 Lines HC 40 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 6 Lines TS 41 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 7 Lines HC 42 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 7 Lines TS 43 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 8 Lines HC 44 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 8 Lines TS 45 | Mandl (1980) 4 routes 46 | Mumford (2013) 4 best operator 47 | Mumford (2013) 4 best passenger 48 | Mumford (2013) 6 best operator 49 | Mumford (2013) 6 best passenger 50 | Mumford (2013) 7 best operator 51 | Mumford (2013) 7 best passenger 52 | Mumford (2013) 8 best operator 53 | Mumford (2013) 8 best passenger 54 | Nayeem et al (2014) 4 routes 55 | Nayeem et al (2014) 6 routes 56 | Nayeem et al (2014) 7 routes 57 | Nayeem et al (2014) 8 routes 58 | Nikolic (2013) 4 routes 59 | Nikolic (2013) 6 routes 60 | Nikolic (2013) 7 routes 61 | Nikolic (2013) 8 routes 62 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 12 best operator 63 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 12 best passengers 64 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 4 best operator 65 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 4 best passengers 66 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 6 best operator 67 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 6 best passengers 68 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 7 best operator 69 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 7 best passengers 70 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 8 best operator 71 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 8 best passengers 72 | ``` 73 | 74 | If I forgot to include yours please contact me. 75 | 76 | TODO: 77 | - Add references 78 | - Represent papers with 1 line per paper with descriptions 79 | - Organize objective functions and additional data (using EMME assignment/other) 80 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera1/rivera1_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,2,10.384615 3 | 2,1,10.384615 4 | 2,3,4.5 5 | 2,7,5.893847 6 | 2,11,7.901538 7 | 3,2,4.5 8 | 3,4,2.833846 9 | 3,7,3.992308 10 | 4,3,2.833846 11 | 4,5,2.593846 12 | 4,6,4.832308 13 | 4,7,4.786154 14 | 5,4,2.593846 15 | 5,6,4.015384 16 | 5,8,2.861539 17 | 6,4,4.832308 18 | 6,5,4.015384 19 | 7,2,5.893847 20 | 7,3,3.992308 21 | 7,4,4.786154 22 | 7,9,3.816923 23 | 8,5,2.861539 24 | 8,10,1.370769 25 | 9,7,3.816923 26 | 9,12,4.68 27 | 9,14,1.32923 28 | 9,16,3.267693 29 | 10,8,1.370769 30 | 10,14,3.687693 31 | 10,23,1.204616 32 | 11,2,7.901538 33 | 11,12,4.283077 34 | 12,9,4.68 35 | 12,11,4.283077 36 | 12,13,2.404615 37 | 13,12,2.404615 38 | 13,15,0.973846 39 | 13,17,1.033846 40 | 14,9,1.32923 41 | 14,10,3.687693 42 | 14,16,1.938461 43 | 14,18,2.28 44 | 14,19,3.18 45 | 15,13,0.973846 46 | 15,16,1.038461 47 | 15,17,2.003077 48 | 16,9,3.267693 49 | 16,14,1.938461 50 | 16,15,1.038461 51 | 16,17,3.041539 52 | 17,13,1.033846 53 | 17,15,2.003077 54 | 17,16,3.041539 55 | 17,21,2.436923 56 | 18,14,2.28 57 | 18,19,0.946154 58 | 18,22,1.943077 59 | 18,25,1.924615 60 | 19,14,3.18 61 | 19,18,0.946154 62 | 19,20,2.893847 63 | 19,21,1.98923 64 | 20,19,2.893847 65 | 20,21,1.993846 66 | 20,22,2.007693 67 | 21,17,2.436923 68 | 21,19,1.98923 69 | 21,20,1.993846 70 | 22,18,1.943077 71 | 22,20,2.007693 72 | 22,26,1.878462 73 | 22,27,1.896923 74 | 23,10,1.204616 75 | 23,24,2.007693 76 | 23,25,1.389231 77 | 23,35,2.473846 78 | 24,23,2.007693 79 | 24,27,1.435385 80 | 24,29,1.855385 81 | 24,36,2.450769 82 | 25,18,1.924615 83 | 25,23,1.389231 84 | 25,27,1.966154 85 | 26,22,1.878462 86 | 26,28,1.878462 87 | 26,34,3.886154 88 | 27,22,1.896923 89 | 27,24,1.435385 90 | 27,25,1.966154 91 | 27,28,1.855385 92 | 28,26,1.878462 93 | 28,27,1.855385 94 | 28,29,1.458461 95 | 28,31,1.901538 96 | 29,24,1.855385 97 | 29,28,1.458461 98 | 29,30,1.86 99 | 29,37,2.469231 100 | 30,29,1.86 101 | 30,31,1.416923 102 | 30,32,1.878462 103 | 30,38,2.427693 104 | 31,28,1.901538 105 | 31,30,1.416923 106 | 31,33,1.896923 107 | 32,30,1.878462 108 | 32,33,1.393846 109 | 32,62,1.015385 110 | 32,63,2.889231 111 | 32,66,3.30923 112 | 33,31,1.896923 113 | 33,32,1.393846 114 | 33,34,1.818462 115 | 33,66,1.943077 116 | 33,68,2.681538 117 | 34,26,3.886154 118 | 34,33,1.818462 119 | 34,67,0.90923 120 | 35,23,2.473846 121 | 35,36,2.044616 122 | 36,24,2.450769 123 | 36,35,2.044616 124 | 36,37,1.86 125 | 37,29,2.469231 126 | 37,36,1.86 127 | 37,38,1.836923 128 | 38,30,2.427693 129 | 38,37,1.836923 130 | 38,39,1.92 131 | 39,38,1.92 132 | 39,40,4.860001 133 | 39,59,2.644615 134 | 39,62,1.393846 135 | 40,39,4.860001 136 | 40,41,4.181538 137 | 41,40,4.181538 138 | 41,42,3.955384 139 | 42,41,3.955384 140 | 42,43,3.516923 141 | 43,42,3.516923 142 | 43,44,4.089231 143 | 44,43,4.089231 144 | 45,46,3.752308 145 | 46,45,3.752308 146 | 46,47,2.487692 147 | 47,46,2.487692 148 | 47,48,2.109231 149 | 47,49,3.678461 150 | 48,47,2.109231 151 | 48,49,1.878462 152 | 48,54,2.243077 153 | 49,47,3.678461 154 | 49,48,1.878462 155 | 50,51,1.961539 156 | 51,50,1.961539 157 | 51,52,3.336923 158 | 52,51,3.336923 159 | 52,53,3.350769 160 | 53,52,3.350769 161 | 53,54,2.566154 162 | 54,48,2.243077 163 | 54,53,2.566154 164 | 54,55,3.387692 165 | 55,54,3.387692 166 | 55,56,2.16 167 | 55,57,2.607693 168 | 56,55,2.16 169 | 56,81,7.98 170 | 56,83,14.653846 171 | 57,55,2.607693 172 | 57,58,1.001538 173 | 57,59,3.623077 174 | 58,57,1.001538 175 | 58,60,1.587693 176 | 58,61,2.284616 177 | 58,81,4.444616 178 | 59,39,2.644615 179 | 59,57,3.623077 180 | 59,60,2.570769 181 | 59,62,4.038462 182 | 59,63,2.22 183 | 60,58,1.587693 184 | 60,59,2.570769 185 | 60,61,2.127692 186 | 60,64,2.238462 187 | 61,58,2.284616 188 | 61,60,2.127692 189 | 61,64,1.583077 190 | 61,65,0.927693 191 | 61,80,1.352308 192 | 62,32,1.015385 193 | 62,39,1.393846 194 | 62,59,4.038462 195 | 62,63,1.943077 196 | 63,32,2.889231 197 | 63,59,2.22 198 | 63,62,1.943077 199 | 63,64,1.01077 200 | 63,66,2.363077 201 | 64,60,2.238462 202 | 64,61,1.583077 203 | 64,63,1.01077 204 | 64,65,2.510769 205 | 64,69,3.184616 206 | 65,61,0.927693 207 | 65,64,2.510769 208 | 65,69,2.173846 209 | 65,70,3.106154 210 | 65,80,1.223077 211 | 66,32,3.30923 212 | 66,33,1.943077 213 | 66,63,2.363077 214 | 66,68,0.932308 215 | 66,69,1.795384 216 | 67,34,0.90923 217 | 67,68,1.813847 218 | 67,71,1.896923 219 | 68,33,2.681538 220 | 68,66,0.932308 221 | 68,67,1.813847 222 | 68,69,2.727692 223 | 68,71,1.873846 224 | 69,64,3.184616 225 | 69,65,2.173846 226 | 69,66,1.795384 227 | 69,68,2.727692 228 | 69,70,2.552307 229 | 69,71,2.663077 230 | 69,74,3.226154 231 | 70,65,3.106154 232 | 70,69,2.552307 233 | 70,73,0.867692 234 | 70,74,2.487692 235 | 70,80,2.723077 236 | 70,82,2.681538 237 | 71,67,1.896923 238 | 71,68,1.873846 239 | 71,69,2.663077 240 | 71,74,3.438461 241 | 72,73,2.870769 242 | 72,77,4.14 243 | 72,82,3.72 244 | 72,83,1.393846 245 | 73,70,0.867692 246 | 73,72,2.870769 247 | 73,75,3.124616 248 | 73,76,3.932308 249 | 73,82,1.813847 250 | 74,69,3.226154 251 | 74,70,2.487692 252 | 74,71,3.438461 253 | 74,75,1.615384 254 | 75,73,3.124616 255 | 75,74,1.615384 256 | 75,76,1.467692 257 | 76,73,3.932308 258 | 76,75,1.467692 259 | 76,77,2.316923 260 | 77,72,4.14 261 | 77,76,2.316923 262 | 77,78,1.518461 263 | 78,77,1.518461 264 | 78,79,3.923077 265 | 78,83,3.923077 266 | 79,78,3.923077 267 | 79,84,3.503077 268 | 80,61,1.352308 269 | 80,65,1.223077 270 | 80,70,2.723077 271 | 80,81,2.607693 272 | 80,82,2.700001 273 | 81,56,7.98 274 | 81,58,4.444616 275 | 81,80,2.607693 276 | 81,82,1.56 277 | 82,70,2.681538 278 | 82,72,3.72 279 | 82,73,1.813847 280 | 82,80,2.700001 281 | 82,81,1.56 282 | 83,56,14.653846 283 | 83,72,1.393846 284 | 83,78,3.923077 285 | 83,84,4.970769 286 | 84,79,3.503077 287 | 84,83,4.970769 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera2/rivera2_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,2,10.384615 3 | 2,1,10.384615 4 | 2,3,4.5 5 | 2,7,5.893847 6 | 2,11,7.901538 7 | 3,2,4.5 8 | 3,4,2.833846 9 | 3,7,3.992308 10 | 4,3,2.833846 11 | 4,5,2.593846 12 | 4,6,4.832308 13 | 4,7,4.786154 14 | 5,4,2.593846 15 | 5,6,4.015384 16 | 5,8,2.861539 17 | 6,4,4.832308 18 | 6,5,4.015384 19 | 7,2,5.893847 20 | 7,3,3.992308 21 | 7,4,4.786154 22 | 7,9,3.816923 23 | 8,5,2.861539 24 | 8,10,1.370769 25 | 9,7,3.816923 26 | 9,12,4.68 27 | 9,14,1.32923 28 | 9,16,3.267693 29 | 10,8,1.370769 30 | 10,14,3.687693 31 | 10,23,1.204616 32 | 11,2,7.901538 33 | 11,12,4.283077 34 | 12,9,4.68 35 | 12,11,4.283077 36 | 12,13,2.404615 37 | 13,12,2.404615 38 | 13,15,0.973846 39 | 13,17,1.033846 40 | 14,9,1.32923 41 | 14,10,3.687693 42 | 14,16,1.938461 43 | 14,18,2.28 44 | 14,19,3.18 45 | 15,13,0.973846 46 | 15,16,1.038461 47 | 15,17,2.003077 48 | 16,9,3.267693 49 | 16,14,1.938461 50 | 16,15,1.038461 51 | 16,17,3.041539 52 | 17,13,1.033846 53 | 17,15,2.003077 54 | 17,16,3.041539 55 | 17,21,2.436923 56 | 18,14,2.28 57 | 18,19,0.946154 58 | 18,22,1.943077 59 | 18,25,1.924615 60 | 19,14,3.18 61 | 19,18,0.946154 62 | 19,20,2.893847 63 | 19,21,1.98923 64 | 20,19,2.893847 65 | 20,21,1.993846 66 | 20,22,2.007693 67 | 21,17,2.436923 68 | 21,19,1.98923 69 | 21,20,1.993846 70 | 22,18,1.943077 71 | 22,20,2.007693 72 | 22,26,1.878462 73 | 22,27,1.896923 74 | 23,10,1.204616 75 | 23,24,2.007693 76 | 23,25,1.389231 77 | 23,35,2.473846 78 | 24,23,2.007693 79 | 24,27,1.435385 80 | 24,29,1.855385 81 | 24,36,2.450769 82 | 25,18,1.924615 83 | 25,23,1.389231 84 | 25,27,1.966154 85 | 26,22,1.878462 86 | 26,28,1.878462 87 | 26,34,3.886154 88 | 27,22,1.896923 89 | 27,24,1.435385 90 | 27,25,1.966154 91 | 27,28,1.855385 92 | 28,26,1.878462 93 | 28,27,1.855385 94 | 28,29,1.458461 95 | 28,31,1.901538 96 | 29,24,1.855385 97 | 29,28,1.458461 98 | 29,30,1.86 99 | 29,37,2.469231 100 | 30,29,1.86 101 | 30,31,1.416923 102 | 30,32,1.878462 103 | 30,38,2.427693 104 | 31,28,1.901538 105 | 31,30,1.416923 106 | 31,33,1.896923 107 | 32,30,1.878462 108 | 32,33,1.393846 109 | 32,62,1.015385 110 | 32,63,2.889231 111 | 32,66,3.30923 112 | 33,31,1.896923 113 | 33,32,1.393846 114 | 33,34,1.818462 115 | 33,66,1.943077 116 | 33,68,2.681538 117 | 34,26,3.886154 118 | 34,33,1.818462 119 | 34,67,0.90923 120 | 35,23,2.473846 121 | 35,36,2.044616 122 | 36,24,2.450769 123 | 36,35,2.044616 124 | 36,37,1.86 125 | 37,29,2.469231 126 | 37,36,1.86 127 | 37,38,1.836923 128 | 38,30,2.427693 129 | 38,37,1.836923 130 | 38,39,1.92 131 | 39,38,1.92 132 | 39,40,4.860001 133 | 39,59,2.644615 134 | 39,62,1.393846 135 | 40,39,4.860001 136 | 40,41,4.181538 137 | 41,40,4.181538 138 | 41,42,3.955384 139 | 42,41,3.955384 140 | 42,43,3.516923 141 | 43,42,3.516923 142 | 43,44,4.089231 143 | 44,43,4.089231 144 | 45,46,3.752308 145 | 46,45,3.752308 146 | 46,47,2.487692 147 | 47,46,2.487692 148 | 47,48,2.109231 149 | 47,49,3.678461 150 | 48,47,2.109231 151 | 48,49,1.878462 152 | 48,54,2.243077 153 | 49,47,3.678461 154 | 49,48,1.878462 155 | 50,51,1.961539 156 | 51,50,1.961539 157 | 51,52,3.336923 158 | 52,51,3.336923 159 | 52,53,3.350769 160 | 53,52,3.350769 161 | 53,54,2.566154 162 | 54,48,2.243077 163 | 54,53,2.566154 164 | 54,55,3.387692 165 | 55,54,3.387692 166 | 55,56,2.16 167 | 55,57,2.607693 168 | 56,55,2.16 169 | 56,81,7.98 170 | 56,83,14.653846 171 | 57,55,2.607693 172 | 57,58,1.001538 173 | 57,59,3.623077 174 | 58,57,1.001538 175 | 58,60,1.587693 176 | 58,61,2.284616 177 | 58,81,4.444616 178 | 59,39,2.644615 179 | 59,57,3.623077 180 | 59,60,2.570769 181 | 59,62,4.038462 182 | 59,63,2.22 183 | 60,58,1.587693 184 | 60,59,2.570769 185 | 60,61,2.127692 186 | 60,64,2.238462 187 | 61,58,2.284616 188 | 61,60,2.127692 189 | 61,64,1.583077 190 | 61,65,0.927693 191 | 61,80,1.352308 192 | 62,32,1.015385 193 | 62,39,1.393846 194 | 62,59,4.038462 195 | 62,63,1.943077 196 | 63,32,2.889231 197 | 63,59,2.22 198 | 63,62,1.943077 199 | 63,64,1.01077 200 | 63,66,2.363077 201 | 64,60,2.238462 202 | 64,61,1.583077 203 | 64,63,1.01077 204 | 64,65,2.510769 205 | 64,69,3.184616 206 | 65,61,0.927693 207 | 65,64,2.510769 208 | 65,69,2.173846 209 | 65,70,3.106154 210 | 65,80,1.223077 211 | 66,32,3.30923 212 | 66,33,1.943077 213 | 66,63,2.363077 214 | 66,68,0.932308 215 | 66,69,1.795384 216 | 67,34,0.90923 217 | 67,68,1.813847 218 | 67,71,1.896923 219 | 68,33,2.681538 220 | 68,66,0.932308 221 | 68,67,1.813847 222 | 68,69,2.727692 223 | 68,71,1.873846 224 | 69,64,3.184616 225 | 69,65,2.173846 226 | 69,66,1.795384 227 | 69,68,2.727692 228 | 69,70,2.552307 229 | 69,71,2.663077 230 | 69,74,3.226154 231 | 70,65,3.106154 232 | 70,69,2.552307 233 | 70,73,0.867692 234 | 70,74,2.487692 235 | 70,80,2.723077 236 | 70,82,2.681538 237 | 71,67,1.896923 238 | 71,68,1.873846 239 | 71,69,2.663077 240 | 71,74,3.438461 241 | 72,73,2.870769 242 | 72,77,4.14 243 | 72,82,3.72 244 | 72,83,1.393846 245 | 73,70,0.867692 246 | 73,72,2.870769 247 | 73,75,3.124616 248 | 73,76,3.932308 249 | 73,82,1.813847 250 | 74,69,3.226154 251 | 74,70,2.487692 252 | 74,71,3.438461 253 | 74,75,1.615384 254 | 75,73,3.124616 255 | 75,74,1.615384 256 | 75,76,1.467692 257 | 76,73,3.932308 258 | 76,75,1.467692 259 | 76,77,2.316923 260 | 77,72,4.14 261 | 77,76,2.316923 262 | 77,78,1.518461 263 | 78,77,1.518461 264 | 78,79,3.923077 265 | 78,83,3.923077 266 | 79,78,3.923077 267 | 79,84,3.503077 268 | 80,61,1.352308 269 | 80,65,1.223077 270 | 80,70,2.723077 271 | 80,81,2.607693 272 | 80,82,2.700001 273 | 81,56,7.98 274 | 81,58,4.444616 275 | 81,80,2.607693 276 | 81,82,1.56 277 | 82,70,2.681538 278 | 82,72,3.72 279 | 82,73,1.813847 280 | 82,80,2.700001 281 | 82,81,1.56 282 | 83,56,14.653846 283 | 83,72,1.393846 284 | 83,78,3.923077 285 | 83,84,4.970769 286 | 84,79,3.503077 287 | 84,83,4.970769 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford1/mumford1_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,3,4 3 | 1,4,7 4 | 1,24,4 5 | 1,51,5 6 | 1,70,6 7 | 2,10,5 8 | 2,12,5 9 | 2,17,3 10 | 2,27,3 11 | 2,32,5 12 | 2,50,3 13 | 2,60,5 14 | 2,69,5 15 | 3,1,4 16 | 3,15,7 17 | 3,24,6 18 | 3,51,4 19 | 4,1,7 20 | 4,20,5 21 | 4,24,5 22 | 4,30,3 23 | 4,39,5 24 | 4,49,4 25 | 4,67,3 26 | 4,70,2 27 | 5,8,4 28 | 5,13,5 29 | 5,26,5 30 | 5,41,5 31 | 5,54,5 32 | 6,19,4 33 | 6,33,5 34 | 6,38,2 35 | 6,55,4 36 | 6,66,2 37 | 6,68,4 38 | 7,22,7 39 | 7,36,6 40 | 7,48,6 41 | 7,57,5 42 | 7,64,5 43 | 8,5,4 44 | 8,41,2 45 | 8,47,3 46 | 8,48,7 47 | 8,54,4 48 | 9,11,5 49 | 9,27,5 50 | 9,29,2 51 | 9,52,5 52 | 9,53,4 53 | 9,56,5 54 | 9,57,3 55 | 10,2,5 56 | 10,12,3 57 | 10,17,6 58 | 10,18,8 59 | 10,32,5 60 | 10,50,6 61 | 10,60,4 62 | 10,69,1 63 | 11,9,5 64 | 11,17,4 65 | 11,18,6 66 | 11,21,5 67 | 11,29,5 68 | 11,53,5 69 | 11,56,2 70 | 11,60,5 71 | 12,2,5 72 | 12,10,3 73 | 12,16,7 74 | 12,32,3 75 | 12,50,5 76 | 12,60,6 77 | 12,69,3 78 | 13,5,5 79 | 13,26,2 80 | 13,28,5 81 | 13,41,9 82 | 13,42,5 83 | 14,21,6 84 | 14,23,5 85 | 14,34,4 86 | 14,44,4 87 | 14,51,5 88 | 15,3,7 89 | 15,45,5 90 | 15,61,7 91 | 15,62,8 92 | 16,12,7 93 | 16,31,5 94 | 16,43,3 95 | 16,50,4 96 | 16,63,4 97 | 17,2,3 98 | 17,10,6 99 | 17,11,4 100 | 17,27,2 101 | 17,56,5 102 | 18,10,8 103 | 18,11,6 104 | 18,21,4 105 | 18,44,5 106 | 18,45,8 107 | 18,51,8 108 | 18,56,6 109 | 18,60,5 110 | 18,61,7 111 | 18,62,4 112 | 19,6,4 113 | 19,20,4 114 | 19,33,4 115 | 19,38,5 116 | 19,39,5 117 | 19,40,4 118 | 19,55,2 119 | 19,66,4 120 | 19,67,5 121 | 19,68,7 122 | 19,70,7 123 | 20,4,5 124 | 20,19,4 125 | 20,23,6 126 | 20,30,6 127 | 20,37,5 128 | 20,39,2 129 | 20,55,3 130 | 20,66,7 131 | 20,67,2 132 | 20,70,5 133 | 21,11,5 134 | 21,14,6 135 | 21,18,4 136 | 21,34,6 137 | 21,44,5 138 | 21,53,5 139 | 21,56,4 140 | 22,7,7 141 | 22,25,3 142 | 22,31,5 143 | 22,63,6 144 | 22,64,3 145 | 23,14,5 146 | 23,20,6 147 | 23,34,3 148 | 23,37,5 149 | 23,39,5 150 | 23,46,5 151 | 24,1,4 152 | 24,3,6 153 | 24,4,5 154 | 24,30,6 155 | 24,51,5 156 | 24,70,4 157 | 25,22,3 158 | 25,31,3 159 | 25,43,6 160 | 25,63,4 161 | 25,64,4 162 | 26,5,5 163 | 26,13,2 164 | 26,28,4 165 | 26,35,6 166 | 26,42,5 167 | 26,58,6 168 | 27,2,3 169 | 27,9,5 170 | 27,17,2 171 | 27,31,4 172 | 27,50,3 173 | 27,63,7 174 | 28,13,5 175 | 28,26,4 176 | 28,42,6 177 | 28,68,6 178 | 29,9,2 179 | 29,11,5 180 | 29,57,3 181 | 30,4,3 182 | 30,20,6 183 | 30,24,6 184 | 30,49,3 185 | 30,67,5 186 | 30,70,3 187 | 31,16,5 188 | 31,22,5 189 | 31,25,3 190 | 31,27,4 191 | 31,43,6 192 | 31,63,5 193 | 31,64,5 194 | 32,2,5 195 | 32,10,5 196 | 32,12,3 197 | 33,6,5 198 | 33,19,4 199 | 33,38,5 200 | 33,40,3 201 | 33,55,5 202 | 33,66,4 203 | 34,14,4 204 | 34,21,6 205 | 34,23,3 206 | 34,44,6 207 | 34,51,7 208 | 34,59,5 209 | 35,26,6 210 | 35,36,3 211 | 35,42,3 212 | 35,46,5 213 | 35,52,4 214 | 35,58,2 215 | 35,59,4 216 | 36,7,6 217 | 36,35,3 218 | 36,42,5 219 | 36,52,2 220 | 36,58,3 221 | 36,59,4 222 | 36,65,4 223 | 37,20,5 224 | 37,23,5 225 | 37,39,4 226 | 37,42,6 227 | 37,46,3 228 | 37,55,5 229 | 38,6,2 230 | 38,19,5 231 | 38,33,5 232 | 38,66,2 233 | 38,68,4 234 | 39,4,5 235 | 39,19,5 236 | 39,20,2 237 | 39,23,5 238 | 39,37,4 239 | 39,55,4 240 | 39,67,3 241 | 39,70,5 242 | 40,19,4 243 | 40,33,3 244 | 40,49,4 245 | 40,66,6 246 | 41,5,5 247 | 41,8,2 248 | 41,13,9 249 | 41,47,2 250 | 41,48,8 251 | 41,54,5 252 | 42,13,5 253 | 42,26,5 254 | 42,28,6 255 | 42,35,3 256 | 42,36,5 257 | 42,37,6 258 | 42,46,4 259 | 42,52,6 260 | 42,58,4 261 | 42,59,5 262 | 43,16,3 263 | 43,25,6 264 | 43,31,6 265 | 43,50,6 266 | 43,63,3 267 | 44,14,4 268 | 44,18,5 269 | 44,21,5 270 | 44,34,6 271 | 44,51,4 272 | 44,62,6 273 | 45,15,5 274 | 45,18,8 275 | 45,61,3 276 | 45,62,5 277 | 46,23,5 278 | 46,35,5 279 | 46,37,3 280 | 46,42,4 281 | 46,59,5 282 | 47,8,3 283 | 47,41,2 284 | 47,54,5 285 | 48,7,6 286 | 48,8,7 287 | 48,41,8 288 | 48,54,5 289 | 49,4,4 290 | 49,30,3 291 | 49,40,4 292 | 49,67,5 293 | 49,70,5 294 | 50,2,3 295 | 50,10,6 296 | 50,12,5 297 | 50,16,4 298 | 50,27,3 299 | 50,43,6 300 | 50,63,6 301 | 51,1,5 302 | 51,3,4 303 | 51,14,5 304 | 51,18,8 305 | 51,24,5 306 | 51,34,7 307 | 51,44,4 308 | 52,9,5 309 | 52,35,4 310 | 52,36,2 311 | 52,42,6 312 | 52,57,4 313 | 52,58,4 314 | 52,59,4 315 | 52,65,3 316 | 53,9,4 317 | 53,11,5 318 | 53,21,5 319 | 53,56,4 320 | 53,65,3 321 | 54,5,5 322 | 54,8,4 323 | 54,41,5 324 | 54,47,5 325 | 54,48,5 326 | 55,6,4 327 | 55,19,2 328 | 55,20,3 329 | 55,33,5 330 | 55,37,5 331 | 55,39,4 332 | 55,66,5 333 | 55,67,4 334 | 56,9,5 335 | 56,11,2 336 | 56,17,5 337 | 56,18,6 338 | 56,21,4 339 | 56,53,4 340 | 57,7,5 341 | 57,9,3 342 | 57,29,3 343 | 57,52,4 344 | 58,26,6 345 | 58,35,2 346 | 58,36,3 347 | 58,42,4 348 | 58,52,4 349 | 58,59,5 350 | 59,34,5 351 | 59,35,4 352 | 59,36,4 353 | 59,42,5 354 | 59,46,5 355 | 59,52,4 356 | 59,58,5 357 | 59,65,3 358 | 60,2,5 359 | 60,10,4 360 | 60,11,5 361 | 60,12,6 362 | 60,18,5 363 | 60,69,4 364 | 61,15,7 365 | 61,18,7 366 | 61,45,3 367 | 61,62,4 368 | 62,15,8 369 | 62,18,4 370 | 62,44,6 371 | 62,45,5 372 | 62,61,4 373 | 63,16,4 374 | 63,22,6 375 | 63,25,4 376 | 63,27,7 377 | 63,31,5 378 | 63,43,3 379 | 63,50,6 380 | 64,7,5 381 | 64,22,3 382 | 64,25,4 383 | 64,31,5 384 | 65,36,4 385 | 65,52,3 386 | 65,53,3 387 | 65,59,3 388 | 66,6,2 389 | 66,19,4 390 | 66,20,7 391 | 66,33,4 392 | 66,38,2 393 | 66,40,6 394 | 66,55,5 395 | 66,68,5 396 | 67,4,3 397 | 67,19,5 398 | 67,20,2 399 | 67,30,5 400 | 67,39,3 401 | 67,49,5 402 | 67,55,4 403 | 67,70,4 404 | 68,6,4 405 | 68,19,7 406 | 68,28,6 407 | 68,38,4 408 | 68,66,5 409 | 69,2,5 410 | 69,10,1 411 | 69,12,3 412 | 69,60,4 413 | 70,1,6 414 | 70,4,2 415 | 70,19,7 416 | 70,20,5 417 | 70,24,4 418 | 70,30,3 419 | 70,39,5 420 | 70,49,5 421 | 70,67,4 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera1/rivera1_demand.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,demand 2 | 1,3,4.90908 3 | 1,8,1.63638 4 | 1,18,1.27272 5 | 1,23,4.09092 6 | 1,31,2.8182 7 | 1,38,1.63638 8 | 1,39,3.2727 9 | 1,66,2.18184 10 | 1,67,6.90912 11 | 1,68,3.90912 12 | 2,1,1.18182 13 | 2,67,1.63638 14 | 3,1,2.18184 15 | 3,4,1.09092 16 | 3,8,1.09092 17 | 3,23,1.90908 18 | 3,39,1.36362 19 | 3,67,2.7273 20 | 3,68,1.36362 21 | 4,1,2.18184 22 | 4,23,1.63638 23 | 4,39,1.90908 24 | 4,67,1.36362 25 | 4,68,1.63638 26 | 5,68,1.63638 27 | 6,8,7.45452 28 | 6,23,2.7273 29 | 6,27,1.27272 30 | 6,28,1.45452 31 | 6,30,5.63634 32 | 6,32,2.54544 33 | 6,67,2.9091 34 | 7,67,1.18182 35 | 8,6,8.7273 36 | 8,23,1.27272 37 | 8,24,1.27272 38 | 8,30,4.72728 39 | 8,32,4.00002 40 | 8,66,2.36364 41 | 8,67,7.72728 42 | 8,68,2.54544 43 | 10,1,1.90908 44 | 12,22,1.45452 45 | 12,27,1.99998 46 | 12,31,1.99998 47 | 12,33,2.7273 48 | 12,59,6.1818 49 | 12,67,3.81816 50 | 12,68,1.27272 51 | 13,23,1.45452 52 | 13,24,1.09092 53 | 13,30,1.99998 54 | 13,31,1.45452 55 | 13,59,3.2727 56 | 13,67,1.45452 57 | 14,1,1.09092 58 | 14,32,1.27272 59 | 14,67,2.8182 60 | 15,19,1.09092 61 | 15,30,1.45452 62 | 15,67,1.81818 63 | 16,30,1.45452 64 | 16,67,1.81818 65 | 17,59,1.27272 66 | 17,67,1.27272 67 | 18,1,1.63638 68 | 18,23,1.27272 69 | 18,30,3.81816 70 | 18,32,3.63636 71 | 18,66,2.45454 72 | 18,67,3.63636 73 | 18,68,1.81818 74 | 19,13,1.45452 75 | 19,15,1.63638 76 | 21,12,1.27272 77 | 21,13,1.63638 78 | 21,59,1.27272 79 | 21,67,1.99998 80 | 22,31,1.90908 81 | 22,59,2.7273 82 | 22,67,1.90908 83 | 22,68,1.09092 84 | 23,1,4.90908 85 | 23,2,1.09092 86 | 23,4,1.63638 87 | 23,5,1.36362 88 | 23,13,1.81818 89 | 23,18,1.63638 90 | 23,19,1.27272 91 | 23,30,1.81818 92 | 23,32,2.54544 93 | 23,39,1.09092 94 | 23,66,1.00002 95 | 23,67,3.63636 96 | 23,68,1.63638 97 | 24,13,1.09092 98 | 24,30,1.45452 99 | 24,32,2.9091 100 | 24,67,6.36366 101 | 24,68,3.81816 102 | 25,30,1.27272 103 | 25,66,1.09092 104 | 27,8,1.09092 105 | 27,67,2.54544 106 | 28,67,1.63638 107 | 29,67,2.18184 108 | 30,23,1.45452 109 | 30,67,2.54544 110 | 31,8,1.27272 111 | 32,1,3.81816 112 | 32,2,1.09092 113 | 32,5,1.09092 114 | 32,15,1.99998 115 | 32,16,1.45452 116 | 32,18,4.54548 117 | 32,19,1.09092 118 | 32,23,4.54548 119 | 32,24,1.45452 120 | 32,25,1.81818 121 | 32,42,1.54548 122 | 32,44,1.00002 123 | 32,45,2.9091 124 | 32,48,1.81818 125 | 32,50,1.09092 126 | 32,51,2.18184 127 | 32,52,4.90908 128 | 32,55,1.72728 129 | 32,57,1.27272 130 | 32,59,1.27272 131 | 33,1,5.45454 132 | 33,3,1.36362 133 | 33,5,3.36366 134 | 33,6,5.09088 135 | 33,8,7.81818 136 | 33,12,4.18182 137 | 33,13,2.7273 138 | 33,14,2.9091 139 | 33,15,1.45452 140 | 33,16,1.63638 141 | 33,17,1.81818 142 | 33,18,5.8182 143 | 33,21,2.18184 144 | 33,22,1.45452 145 | 33,23,4.90908 146 | 33,24,2.18184 147 | 33,25,4.18182 148 | 33,27,3.45456 149 | 33,29,1.45452 150 | 33,32,1.09092 151 | 33,35,1.09092 152 | 33,36,1.36362 153 | 33,41,1.90908 154 | 33,42,1.63638 155 | 33,43,1.99998 156 | 33,44,1.54548 157 | 33,45,4.36362 158 | 33,48,3.54546 159 | 33,50,1.09092 160 | 33,51,3.54546 161 | 33,52,4.36362 162 | 33,53,1.63638 163 | 33,54,1.63638 164 | 33,55,2.36364 165 | 33,56,1.36362 166 | 33,57,1.81818 167 | 33,59,1.99998 168 | 33,60,1.45452 169 | 33,65,1.63638 170 | 33,70,1.63638 171 | 33,73,2.54544 172 | 33,75,1.27272 173 | 33,78,3.0909 174 | 34,1,4.27272 175 | 34,8,1.00002 176 | 34,14,1.45452 177 | 34,18,1.45452 178 | 34,23,2.8182 179 | 34,24,1.09092 180 | 34,51,1.09092 181 | 36,39,1.09092 182 | 36,66,1.36362 183 | 36,67,3.81816 184 | 36,68,1.36362 185 | 39,1,3.54546 186 | 39,5,1.09092 187 | 39,42,1.36362 188 | 39,43,1.00002 189 | 39,44,1.45452 190 | 40,43,1.63638 191 | 41,44,1.45452 192 | 41,67,2.54544 193 | 41,68,1.72728 194 | 42,44,1.63638 195 | 42,66,1.00002 196 | 42,67,3 197 | 42,68,4.63638 198 | 43,44,2.7273 199 | 43,59,1.63638 200 | 43,67,1.81818 201 | 43,68,1.09092 202 | 44,40,1.54548 203 | 44,43,3.1818 204 | 44,59,1.09092 205 | 44,67,2.09088 206 | 44,68,1.00002 207 | 45,67,1.45452 208 | 46,58,1.27272 209 | 46,60,1.45452 210 | 46,66,2.54544 211 | 46,67,1.81818 212 | 47,66,1.81818 213 | 47,67,1.36362 214 | 49,66,1.00002 215 | 50,51,1.36362 216 | 50,52,4.09092 217 | 50,55,1.09092 218 | 50,58,2.45454 219 | 50,66,1.63638 220 | 50,68,1.09092 221 | 51,50,1.90908 222 | 51,52,3.54546 223 | 51,55,1.09092 224 | 51,57,1.36362 225 | 51,58,6 226 | 51,59,2.18184 227 | 51,60,1.63638 228 | 51,63,1.36362 229 | 51,66,2.18184 230 | 51,67,5.18184 231 | 51,68,2.7273 232 | 52,50,3.81816 233 | 52,51,1.36362 234 | 52,58,4.09092 235 | 52,66,2.45454 236 | 52,67,1.90908 237 | 52,68,3 238 | 53,52,1.63638 239 | 53,55,1.63638 240 | 53,58,2.7273 241 | 53,59,1.09092 242 | 53,67,1.36362 243 | 54,45,1.09092 244 | 54,47,1.27272 245 | 54,50,1.09092 246 | 54,51,1.36362 247 | 54,52,1.36362 248 | 54,55,1.00002 249 | 54,58,1.90908 250 | 54,63,1.36362 251 | 54,66,2.45454 252 | 54,67,1.36362 253 | 55,50,1.09092 254 | 55,59,1.63638 255 | 55,60,1.45452 256 | 55,66,3.81816 257 | 55,67,5.09088 258 | 55,68,2.45454 259 | 55,71,1.09092 260 | 56,67,1.18182 261 | 57,45,2.36364 262 | 57,51,2.7273 263 | 57,52,1.90908 264 | 57,67,1.09092 265 | 58,45,1.45452 266 | 58,47,1.27272 267 | 58,51,2.45454 268 | 58,52,1.09092 269 | 58,53,1.90908 270 | 58,56,1.18182 271 | 58,66,1.99998 272 | 58,67,3.54546 273 | 59,12,4.00002 274 | 59,13,2.54544 275 | 59,17,1.45452 276 | 59,20,1.27272 277 | 59,22,2.54544 278 | 59,27,1.63638 279 | 59,45,1.45452 280 | 59,47,1.00002 281 | 59,48,1.27272 282 | 59,50,1.09092 283 | 59,51,1.63638 284 | 59,52,4.09092 285 | 59,54,1.09092 286 | 59,56,1.45452 287 | 59,60,1.00002 288 | 59,66,1.90908 289 | 59,67,8.45454 290 | 59,70,2.54544 291 | 59,73,1.09092 292 | 59,78,1.36362 293 | 60,47,1.45452 294 | 60,51,1.90908 295 | 60,52,3 296 | 60,55,1.09092 297 | 60,66,2.54544 298 | 60,67,5.8182 299 | 60,68,3.0909 300 | 62,52,1.63638 301 | 62,60,1.27272 302 | 65,59,1.54548 303 | 65,66,1.36362 304 | 65,67,2.54544 305 | 66,67,1.45452 306 | 67,1,3.63636 307 | 67,2,1.72728 308 | 67,3,1.90908 309 | 67,5,2.18184 310 | 67,6,1.99998 311 | 67,8,4.81818 312 | 67,10,1.45452 313 | 67,12,2.9091 314 | 67,13,2.36364 315 | 67,14,1.45452 316 | 67,16,1.09092 317 | 67,18,2.9091 318 | 67,19,1.09092 319 | 67,23,4.81818 320 | 67,24,1.63638 321 | 67,25,1.99998 322 | 67,27,3.63636 323 | 67,30,3.0909 324 | 67,32,1.36362 325 | 67,33,1.00002 326 | 67,35,1.36362 327 | 67,36,3.2727 328 | 67,39,1.00002 329 | 67,41,1.45452 330 | 67,42,1.81818 331 | 67,43,1.00002 332 | 67,44,1.81818 333 | 67,45,1.63638 334 | 67,47,1.36362 335 | 67,48,2.9091 336 | 67,49,1.72728 337 | 67,51,1.09092 338 | 67,52,5.18184 339 | 67,53,1.36362 340 | 67,54,5.09088 341 | 67,55,1.90908 342 | 67,56,2.09088 343 | 67,58,2.45454 344 | 67,59,3.54546 345 | 67,60,5.27274 346 | 67,62,1.54548 347 | 67,65,1.90908 348 | 67,70,2.54544 349 | 67,73,1.81818 350 | 67,75,1.27272 351 | 67,77,1.63638 352 | 67,78,2.8182 353 | 67,82,1.99998 354 | 68,67,1.27272 355 | 69,67,1.36362 356 | 70,66,3.36366 357 | 70,67,1.99998 358 | 70,68,1.45452 359 | 70,77,2.45454 360 | 71,1,1.45452 361 | 71,13,1.27272 362 | 71,45,2.18184 363 | 71,52,1.63638 364 | 71,67,1.27272 365 | 71,69,2.9091 366 | 72,67,1.00002 367 | 73,66,3.81816 368 | 73,67,2.36364 369 | 75,59,2.27274 370 | 75,66,2.18184 371 | 75,67,2.27274 372 | 75,73,1.45452 373 | 78,33,1.45452 374 | 78,67,2.63634 375 | 78,71,1.09092 376 | 80,67,1.18182 377 | 82,59,1.00002 378 | 82,66,1.09092 379 | 84,75,1.09092 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Rivera/Rivera2/rivera2_demand.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,demand 2 | 1,3,4.90908 3 | 1,8,1.63638 4 | 1,18,1.27272 5 | 1,23,4.09092 6 | 1,31,2.8182 7 | 1,38,1.63638 8 | 1,39,3.2727 9 | 1,66,2.18184 10 | 1,67,6.90912 11 | 1,68,3.90912 12 | 2,1,1.18182 13 | 2,67,1.63638 14 | 3,1,2.18184 15 | 3,4,1.09092 16 | 3,8,1.09092 17 | 3,23,1.90908 18 | 3,39,1.36362 19 | 3,67,2.7273 20 | 3,68,1.36362 21 | 4,1,2.18184 22 | 4,23,1.63638 23 | 4,39,1.90908 24 | 4,67,1.36362 25 | 4,68,1.63638 26 | 5,68,1.63638 27 | 6,8,7.45452 28 | 6,23,2.7273 29 | 6,27,1.27272 30 | 6,28,1.45452 31 | 6,30,5.63634 32 | 6,32,2.54544 33 | 6,67,2.9091 34 | 7,67,1.18182 35 | 8,6,8.7273 36 | 8,23,1.27272 37 | 8,24,1.27272 38 | 8,30,4.72728 39 | 8,32,4.00002 40 | 8,66,2.36364 41 | 8,67,7.72728 42 | 8,68,2.54544 43 | 10,1,1.90908 44 | 12,22,1.45452 45 | 12,27,1.99998 46 | 12,31,1.99998 47 | 12,33,2.7273 48 | 12,59,6.1818 49 | 12,67,3.81816 50 | 12,68,1.27272 51 | 13,23,1.45452 52 | 13,24,1.09092 53 | 13,30,1.99998 54 | 13,31,1.45452 55 | 13,59,3.2727 56 | 13,67,1.45452 57 | 14,1,1.09092 58 | 14,32,1.27272 59 | 14,67,2.8182 60 | 15,19,1.09092 61 | 15,30,1.45452 62 | 15,67,1.81818 63 | 16,30,1.45452 64 | 16,67,1.81818 65 | 17,59,1.27272 66 | 17,67,1.27272 67 | 18,1,1.63638 68 | 18,23,1.27272 69 | 18,30,3.81816 70 | 18,32,3.63636 71 | 18,66,2.45454 72 | 18,67,3.63636 73 | 18,68,1.81818 74 | 19,13,1.45452 75 | 19,15,1.63638 76 | 21,12,1.27272 77 | 21,13,1.63638 78 | 21,59,1.27272 79 | 21,67,1.99998 80 | 22,31,1.90908 81 | 22,59,2.7273 82 | 22,67,1.90908 83 | 22,68,1.09092 84 | 23,1,4.90908 85 | 23,2,1.09092 86 | 23,4,1.63638 87 | 23,5,1.36362 88 | 23,13,1.81818 89 | 23,18,1.63638 90 | 23,19,1.27272 91 | 23,30,1.81818 92 | 23,32,2.54544 93 | 23,39,1.09092 94 | 23,66,1.00002 95 | 23,67,3.63636 96 | 23,68,1.63638 97 | 24,13,1.09092 98 | 24,30,1.45452 99 | 24,32,2.9091 100 | 24,67,6.36366 101 | 24,68,3.81816 102 | 25,30,1.27272 103 | 25,66,1.09092 104 | 27,8,1.09092 105 | 27,67,2.54544 106 | 28,67,1.63638 107 | 29,67,2.18184 108 | 30,23,1.45452 109 | 30,67,2.54544 110 | 31,8,1.27272 111 | 32,1,3.81816 112 | 32,2,1.09092 113 | 32,5,1.09092 114 | 32,15,1.99998 115 | 32,16,1.45452 116 | 32,18,4.54548 117 | 32,19,1.09092 118 | 32,23,4.54548 119 | 32,24,1.45452 120 | 32,25,1.81818 121 | 32,42,1.54548 122 | 32,44,1.00002 123 | 32,45,2.9091 124 | 32,48,1.81818 125 | 32,50,1.09092 126 | 32,51,2.18184 127 | 32,52,4.90908 128 | 32,55,1.72728 129 | 32,57,1.27272 130 | 32,59,1.27272 131 | 33,1,5.45454 132 | 33,3,1.36362 133 | 33,5,3.36366 134 | 33,6,5.09088 135 | 33,8,7.81818 136 | 33,12,4.18182 137 | 33,13,2.7273 138 | 33,14,2.9091 139 | 33,15,1.45452 140 | 33,16,1.63638 141 | 33,17,1.81818 142 | 33,18,5.8182 143 | 33,21,2.18184 144 | 33,22,1.45452 145 | 33,23,4.90908 146 | 33,24,2.18184 147 | 33,25,4.18182 148 | 33,27,3.45456 149 | 33,29,1.45452 150 | 33,32,1.09092 151 | 33,35,1.09092 152 | 33,36,1.36362 153 | 33,41,1.90908 154 | 33,42,1.63638 155 | 33,43,1.99998 156 | 33,44,1.54548 157 | 33,45,4.36362 158 | 33,48,3.54546 159 | 33,50,1.09092 160 | 33,51,3.54546 161 | 33,52,4.36362 162 | 33,53,1.63638 163 | 33,54,1.63638 164 | 33,55,2.36364 165 | 33,56,1.36362 166 | 33,57,1.81818 167 | 33,59,1.99998 168 | 33,60,1.45452 169 | 33,65,1.63638 170 | 33,70,1.63638 171 | 33,73,2.54544 172 | 33,75,1.27272 173 | 33,78,3.0909 174 | 34,1,4.27272 175 | 34,8,1.00002 176 | 34,14,1.45452 177 | 34,18,1.45452 178 | 34,23,2.8182 179 | 34,24,1.09092 180 | 34,51,1.09092 181 | 36,39,1.09092 182 | 36,66,1.36362 183 | 36,67,3.81816 184 | 36,68,1.36362 185 | 39,1,3.54546 186 | 39,5,1.09092 187 | 39,42,1.36362 188 | 39,43,1.00002 189 | 39,44,1.45452 190 | 40,43,1.63638 191 | 41,44,1.45452 192 | 41,67,2.54544 193 | 41,68,1.72728 194 | 42,44,1.63638 195 | 42,66,1.00002 196 | 42,67,3 197 | 42,68,4.63638 198 | 43,44,2.7273 199 | 43,59,1.63638 200 | 43,67,1.81818 201 | 43,68,1.09092 202 | 44,40,1.54548 203 | 44,43,3.1818 204 | 44,59,1.09092 205 | 44,67,2.09088 206 | 44,68,1.00002 207 | 45,67,1.45452 208 | 46,58,1.27272 209 | 46,60,1.45452 210 | 46,66,2.54544 211 | 46,67,1.81818 212 | 47,66,1.81818 213 | 47,67,1.36362 214 | 49,66,1.00002 215 | 50,51,1.36362 216 | 50,52,4.09092 217 | 50,55,1.09092 218 | 50,58,2.45454 219 | 50,66,1.63638 220 | 50,68,1.09092 221 | 51,50,1.90908 222 | 51,52,3.54546 223 | 51,55,1.09092 224 | 51,57,1.36362 225 | 51,58,6 226 | 51,59,2.18184 227 | 51,60,1.63638 228 | 51,63,1.36362 229 | 51,66,2.18184 230 | 51,67,5.18184 231 | 51,68,2.7273 232 | 52,50,3.81816 233 | 52,51,1.36362 234 | 52,58,4.09092 235 | 52,66,2.45454 236 | 52,67,1.90908 237 | 52,68,3 238 | 53,52,1.63638 239 | 53,55,1.63638 240 | 53,58,2.7273 241 | 53,59,1.09092 242 | 53,67,1.36362 243 | 54,45,1.09092 244 | 54,47,1.27272 245 | 54,50,1.09092 246 | 54,51,1.36362 247 | 54,52,1.36362 248 | 54,55,1.00002 249 | 54,58,1.90908 250 | 54,63,1.36362 251 | 54,66,2.45454 252 | 54,67,1.36362 253 | 55,50,1.09092 254 | 55,59,1.63638 255 | 55,60,1.45452 256 | 55,66,3.81816 257 | 55,67,5.09088 258 | 55,68,2.45454 259 | 55,71,1.09092 260 | 56,67,1.18182 261 | 57,45,2.36364 262 | 57,51,2.7273 263 | 57,52,1.90908 264 | 57,67,1.09092 265 | 58,45,1.45452 266 | 58,47,1.27272 267 | 58,51,2.45454 268 | 58,52,1.09092 269 | 58,53,1.90908 270 | 58,56,1.18182 271 | 58,66,1.99998 272 | 58,67,3.54546 273 | 59,12,4.00002 274 | 59,13,2.54544 275 | 59,17,1.45452 276 | 59,20,1.27272 277 | 59,22,2.54544 278 | 59,27,1.63638 279 | 59,45,1.45452 280 | 59,47,1.00002 281 | 59,48,1.27272 282 | 59,50,1.09092 283 | 59,51,1.63638 284 | 59,52,4.09092 285 | 59,54,1.09092 286 | 59,56,1.45452 287 | 59,60,1.00002 288 | 59,66,1.90908 289 | 59,67,8.45454 290 | 59,70,2.54544 291 | 59,73,1.09092 292 | 59,78,1.36362 293 | 60,47,1.45452 294 | 60,51,1.90908 295 | 60,52,3 296 | 60,55,1.09092 297 | 60,66,2.54544 298 | 60,67,5.8182 299 | 60,68,3.0909 300 | 62,52,1.63638 301 | 62,60,1.27272 302 | 65,59,1.54548 303 | 65,66,1.36362 304 | 65,67,2.54544 305 | 66,67,1.45452 306 | 67,1,3.63636 307 | 67,2,1.72728 308 | 67,3,1.90908 309 | 67,5,2.18184 310 | 67,6,1.99998 311 | 67,8,4.81818 312 | 67,10,1.45452 313 | 67,12,2.9091 314 | 67,13,2.36364 315 | 67,14,1.45452 316 | 67,16,1.09092 317 | 67,18,2.9091 318 | 67,19,1.09092 319 | 67,23,4.81818 320 | 67,24,1.63638 321 | 67,25,1.99998 322 | 67,27,3.63636 323 | 67,30,3.0909 324 | 67,32,1.36362 325 | 67,33,1.00002 326 | 67,35,1.36362 327 | 67,36,3.2727 328 | 67,39,1.00002 329 | 67,41,1.45452 330 | 67,42,1.81818 331 | 67,43,1.00002 332 | 67,44,1.81818 333 | 67,45,1.63638 334 | 67,47,1.36362 335 | 67,48,2.9091 336 | 67,49,1.72728 337 | 67,51,1.09092 338 | 67,52,5.18184 339 | 67,53,1.36362 340 | 67,54,5.09088 341 | 67,55,1.90908 342 | 67,56,2.09088 343 | 67,58,2.45454 344 | 67,59,3.54546 345 | 67,60,5.27274 346 | 67,62,1.54548 347 | 67,65,1.90908 348 | 67,70,2.54544 349 | 67,73,1.81818 350 | 67,75,1.27272 351 | 67,77,1.63638 352 | 67,78,2.8182 353 | 67,82,1.99998 354 | 68,67,1.27272 355 | 69,67,1.36362 356 | 70,66,3.36366 357 | 70,67,1.99998 358 | 70,68,1.45452 359 | 70,77,2.45454 360 | 71,1,1.45452 361 | 71,13,1.27272 362 | 71,45,2.18184 363 | 71,52,1.63638 364 | 71,67,1.27272 365 | 71,69,2.9091 366 | 72,67,1.00002 367 | 73,66,3.81816 368 | 73,67,2.36364 369 | 75,59,2.27274 370 | 75,66,2.18184 371 | 75,67,2.27274 372 | 75,73,1.45452 373 | 78,33,1.45452 374 | 78,67,2.63634 375 | 78,71,1.09092 376 | 80,67,1.18182 377 | 82,59,1.00002 378 | 82,66,1.09092 379 | 84,75,1.09092 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford2/mumford2_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,2,3 3 | 1,40,6 4 | 1,57,4 5 | 1,62,6 6 | 1,66,6 7 | 1,79,6 8 | 1,81,6 9 | 1,88,4 10 | 1,98,5 11 | 2,1,3 12 | 2,57,6 13 | 2,62,5 14 | 2,88,6 15 | 2,98,6 16 | 3,16,3 17 | 3,35,5 18 | 3,36,5 19 | 3,46,5 20 | 3,64,6 21 | 3,84,3 22 | 3,95,6 23 | 4,7,5 24 | 4,10,5 25 | 4,16,6 26 | 4,19,5 27 | 4,20,7 28 | 4,23,4 29 | 4,35,5 30 | 4,55,3 31 | 4,67,2 32 | 4,68,6 33 | 4,82,6 34 | 4,84,6 35 | 4,86,4 36 | 4,94,5 37 | 4,99,6 38 | 5,37,7 39 | 5,78,5 40 | 5,108,5 41 | 5,109,7 42 | 6,12,6 43 | 6,37,5 44 | 6,43,3 45 | 6,78,5 46 | 6,108,5 47 | 6,109,5 48 | 7,4,5 49 | 7,23,3 50 | 7,25,4 51 | 7,55,3 52 | 7,67,6 53 | 7,82,2 54 | 7,86,2 55 | 7,87,8 56 | 7,95,6 57 | 8,11,5 58 | 8,26,3 59 | 8,38,5 60 | 8,41,6 61 | 8,42,9 62 | 8,50,9 63 | 8,53,8 64 | 8,58,9 65 | 8,71,5 66 | 8,85,5 67 | 8,104,7 68 | 8,105,7 69 | 9,13,5 70 | 9,36,5 71 | 9,50,5 72 | 9,54,3 73 | 9,63,3 74 | 9,64,6 75 | 9,91,3 76 | 9,92,5 77 | 10,4,5 78 | 10,19,4 79 | 10,20,6 80 | 10,24,5 81 | 10,67,5 82 | 10,93,5 83 | 10,94,6 84 | 11,8,5 85 | 11,26,7 86 | 11,38,7 87 | 11,41,6 88 | 11,53,5 89 | 11,58,6 90 | 11,71,7 91 | 11,105,10 92 | 12,6,6 93 | 12,43,5 94 | 12,65,3 95 | 12,74,2 96 | 12,80,5 97 | 12,90,2 98 | 12,97,2 99 | 12,107,4 100 | 12,110,3 101 | 13,9,5 102 | 13,17,5 103 | 13,39,6 104 | 13,42,7 105 | 13,48,5 106 | 13,54,4 107 | 13,61,5 108 | 13,63,3 109 | 13,64,5 110 | 13,75,5 111 | 13,104,6 112 | 14,22,5 113 | 14,29,6 114 | 14,33,2 115 | 14,51,5 116 | 14,69,5 117 | 15,32,7 118 | 15,34,7 119 | 15,70,5 120 | 15,77,2 121 | 15,100,5 122 | 15,103,8 123 | 16,3,3 124 | 16,4,6 125 | 16,19,7 126 | 16,35,2 127 | 16,36,4 128 | 16,55,6 129 | 16,67,6 130 | 16,84,2 131 | 17,13,5 132 | 17,42,3 133 | 17,48,3 134 | 17,61,5 135 | 17,71,6 136 | 17,75,5 137 | 17,104,4 138 | 18,21,4 139 | 18,28,5 140 | 18,33,6 141 | 18,40,4 142 | 18,51,3 143 | 18,57,5 144 | 18,66,3 145 | 18,69,4 146 | 18,76,5 147 | 18,79,3 148 | 18,96,2 149 | 19,4,5 150 | 19,10,4 151 | 19,16,7 152 | 19,35,6 153 | 19,67,4 154 | 19,68,2 155 | 19,93,5 156 | 19,94,3 157 | 19,99,2 158 | 19,101,5 159 | 20,4,7 160 | 20,10,6 161 | 20,23,5 162 | 20,24,3 163 | 20,25,5 164 | 20,32,4 165 | 20,34,3 166 | 20,83,5 167 | 20,86,6 168 | 20,103,5 169 | 21,18,4 170 | 21,33,4 171 | 21,51,2 172 | 21,69,2 173 | 21,76,3 174 | 21,96,3 175 | 22,14,5 176 | 22,28,5 177 | 22,29,2 178 | 22,33,5 179 | 22,47,8 180 | 22,60,4 181 | 22,69,6 182 | 22,87,6 183 | 23,4,4 184 | 23,7,3 185 | 23,20,5 186 | 23,25,4 187 | 23,32,7 188 | 23,55,3 189 | 23,67,5 190 | 23,86,2 191 | 24,10,5 192 | 24,20,3 193 | 24,32,5 194 | 24,34,4 195 | 24,83,4 196 | 25,7,4 197 | 25,20,5 198 | 25,23,4 199 | 25,32,5 200 | 25,55,5 201 | 25,86,4 202 | 25,87,8 203 | 25,103,5 204 | 26,8,3 205 | 26,11,7 206 | 26,38,6 207 | 26,41,7 208 | 26,71,4 209 | 26,85,4 210 | 26,105,5 211 | 27,30,7 212 | 27,31,3 213 | 27,44,3 214 | 27,45,5 215 | 27,73,6 216 | 27,83,5 217 | 28,18,5 218 | 28,22,5 219 | 28,33,6 220 | 28,60,3 221 | 28,95,5 222 | 28,96,5 223 | 28,102,4 224 | 28,106,5 225 | 29,14,6 226 | 29,22,2 227 | 29,47,7 228 | 29,60,5 229 | 29,87,5 230 | 30,27,7 231 | 30,31,5 232 | 30,44,5 233 | 31,27,3 234 | 31,30,5 235 | 31,44,1 236 | 31,45,7 237 | 31,70,6 238 | 32,15,7 239 | 32,20,4 240 | 32,23,7 241 | 32,24,5 242 | 32,25,5 243 | 32,34,3 244 | 32,52,7 245 | 32,72,8 246 | 32,77,7 247 | 32,89,7 248 | 32,103,3 249 | 33,14,2 250 | 33,18,6 251 | 33,21,4 252 | 33,22,5 253 | 33,28,6 254 | 33,51,4 255 | 33,60,4 256 | 33,69,3 257 | 33,96,5 258 | 34,15,7 259 | 34,20,3 260 | 34,24,4 261 | 34,32,3 262 | 34,77,7 263 | 34,83,5 264 | 34,100,5 265 | 34,103,5 266 | 35,3,5 267 | 35,4,5 268 | 35,16,2 269 | 35,19,6 270 | 35,36,4 271 | 35,55,6 272 | 35,67,5 273 | 35,84,3 274 | 35,94,5 275 | 36,3,5 276 | 36,9,5 277 | 36,16,4 278 | 36,35,4 279 | 36,50,5 280 | 36,84,5 281 | 36,91,5 282 | 36,92,5 283 | 36,94,5 284 | 37,5,7 285 | 37,6,5 286 | 37,49,5 287 | 37,65,5 288 | 37,73,5 289 | 37,80,4 290 | 37,108,3 291 | 37,109,1 292 | 38,8,5 293 | 38,11,7 294 | 38,26,6 295 | 38,41,3 296 | 38,58,7 297 | 38,85,6 298 | 38,105,6 299 | 39,13,6 300 | 39,46,3 301 | 39,54,5 302 | 39,56,5 303 | 39,59,6 304 | 39,64,2 305 | 39,75,7 306 | 39,81,3 307 | 39,88,5 308 | 40,1,6 309 | 40,18,4 310 | 40,56,4 311 | 40,57,3 312 | 40,66,2 313 | 40,79,3 314 | 40,88,5 315 | 41,8,6 316 | 41,11,6 317 | 41,26,7 318 | 41,38,3 319 | 41,58,5 320 | 41,105,8 321 | 42,8,9 322 | 42,13,7 323 | 42,17,3 324 | 42,48,4 325 | 42,61,6 326 | 42,71,5 327 | 42,75,7 328 | 42,104,4 329 | 42,105,11 330 | 43,6,3 331 | 43,12,5 332 | 43,58,6 333 | 43,74,4 334 | 43,90,5 335 | 43,97,4 336 | 43,107,5 337 | 44,27,3 338 | 44,30,5 339 | 44,31,1 340 | 44,45,7 341 | 44,70,6 342 | 44,73,7 343 | 45,27,5 344 | 45,31,7 345 | 45,44,7 346 | 45,49,4 347 | 45,73,3 348 | 45,83,5 349 | 45,93,5 350 | 46,3,5 351 | 46,39,3 352 | 46,54,5 353 | 46,56,4 354 | 46,64,2 355 | 46,81,5 356 | 46,88,6 357 | 47,22,8 358 | 47,29,7 359 | 47,52,7 360 | 47,87,4 361 | 48,13,5 362 | 48,17,3 363 | 48,42,4 364 | 48,59,7 365 | 48,61,3 366 | 48,63,7 367 | 48,75,4 368 | 48,104,6 369 | 49,37,5 370 | 49,45,4 371 | 49,73,2 372 | 49,80,5 373 | 49,93,6 374 | 49,108,6 375 | 49,109,5 376 | 50,8,9 377 | 50,9,5 378 | 50,36,5 379 | 50,53,5 380 | 50,91,2 381 | 50,92,1 382 | 51,14,5 383 | 51,18,3 384 | 51,21,2 385 | 51,33,4 386 | 51,66,5 387 | 51,69,2 388 | 51,76,4 389 | 51,96,2 390 | 52,32,7 391 | 52,47,7 392 | 52,72,4 393 | 52,87,5 394 | 52,89,4 395 | 52,103,5 396 | 53,8,8 397 | 53,11,5 398 | 53,50,5 399 | 53,90,5 400 | 53,92,5 401 | 53,101,5 402 | 54,9,3 403 | 54,13,4 404 | 54,39,5 405 | 54,46,5 406 | 54,63,3 407 | 54,64,4 408 | 54,91,5 409 | 55,4,3 410 | 55,7,3 411 | 55,16,6 412 | 55,23,3 413 | 55,25,5 414 | 55,35,6 415 | 55,67,4 416 | 55,86,2 417 | 56,39,5 418 | 56,40,4 419 | 56,46,4 420 | 56,64,5 421 | 56,81,5 422 | 56,88,4 423 | 56,102,4 424 | 57,1,4 425 | 57,2,6 426 | 57,18,5 427 | 57,40,3 428 | 57,62,7 429 | 57,66,3 430 | 57,88,3 431 | 58,8,9 432 | 58,11,6 433 | 58,38,7 434 | 58,41,5 435 | 58,43,6 436 | 58,107,5 437 | 59,39,6 438 | 59,48,7 439 | 59,61,5 440 | 59,75,4 441 | 59,81,5 442 | 59,98,4 443 | 60,22,4 444 | 60,28,3 445 | 60,29,5 446 | 60,33,4 447 | 60,69,4 448 | 60,96,4 449 | 61,13,5 450 | 61,17,5 451 | 61,42,6 452 | 61,48,3 453 | 61,59,5 454 | 61,75,2 455 | 62,1,6 456 | 62,2,5 457 | 62,57,7 458 | 62,66,8 459 | 63,9,3 460 | 63,13,3 461 | 63,48,7 462 | 63,54,3 463 | 63,91,5 464 | 63,92,6 465 | 63,104,5 466 | 64,3,6 467 | 64,9,6 468 | 64,13,5 469 | 64,39,2 470 | 64,46,2 471 | 64,54,4 472 | 64,56,5 473 | 64,81,5 474 | 65,12,3 475 | 65,37,5 476 | 65,74,4 477 | 65,80,3 478 | 65,90,4 479 | 65,93,5 480 | 65,97,3 481 | 65,110,3 482 | 66,1,6 483 | 66,18,3 484 | 66,40,2 485 | 66,51,5 486 | 66,57,3 487 | 66,62,8 488 | 66,79,2 489 | 67,4,2 490 | 67,7,6 491 | 67,10,5 492 | 67,16,6 493 | 67,19,4 494 | 67,23,5 495 | 67,35,5 496 | 67,55,4 497 | 67,86,5 498 | 67,94,5 499 | 68,4,6 500 | 68,19,2 501 | 68,93,5 502 | 68,94,3 503 | 68,99,1 504 | 68,101,5 505 | 69,14,5 506 | 69,18,4 507 | 69,21,2 508 | 69,22,6 509 | 69,33,3 510 | 69,51,2 511 | 69,60,4 512 | 69,76,5 513 | 69,96,2 514 | 70,15,5 515 | 70,31,6 516 | 70,44,6 517 | 70,77,6 518 | 70,100,3 519 | 71,8,5 520 | 71,11,7 521 | 71,17,6 522 | 71,26,4 523 | 71,42,5 524 | 71,85,6 525 | 71,104,4 526 | 71,105,8 527 | 72,32,8 528 | 72,52,4 529 | 72,87,8 530 | 72,89,2 531 | 72,103,6 532 | 73,27,6 533 | 73,37,5 534 | 73,44,7 535 | 73,45,3 536 | 73,49,2 537 | 73,80,5 538 | 73,93,5 539 | 73,109,5 540 | 74,12,2 541 | 74,43,4 542 | 74,65,4 543 | 74,80,5 544 | 74,90,2 545 | 74,97,2 546 | 74,107,3 547 | 74,110,4 548 | 75,13,5 549 | 75,17,5 550 | 75,39,7 551 | 75,42,7 552 | 75,48,4 553 | 75,59,4 554 | 75,61,2 555 | 76,18,5 556 | 76,21,3 557 | 76,51,4 558 | 76,69,5 559 | 77,15,2 560 | 77,32,7 561 | 77,34,7 562 | 77,70,6 563 | 77,100,5 564 | 77,103,7 565 | 78,5,5 566 | 78,6,5 567 | 78,108,4 568 | 79,1,6 569 | 79,18,3 570 | 79,40,3 571 | 79,66,2 572 | 79,96,4 573 | 80,12,5 574 | 80,37,4 575 | 80,49,5 576 | 80,65,3 577 | 80,73,5 578 | 80,74,5 579 | 80,109,4 580 | 81,1,6 581 | 81,39,3 582 | 81,46,5 583 | 81,56,5 584 | 81,59,5 585 | 81,64,5 586 | 81,88,4 587 | 81,98,4 588 | 82,4,6 589 | 82,7,2 590 | 82,86,3 591 | 82,87,8 592 | 82,95,5 593 | 82,106,5 594 | 83,20,5 595 | 83,24,4 596 | 83,27,5 597 | 83,34,5 598 | 83,45,5 599 | 83,100,5 600 | 84,3,3 601 | 84,4,6 602 | 84,16,2 603 | 84,35,3 604 | 84,36,5 605 | 84,95,5 606 | 84,106,5 607 | 85,8,5 608 | 85,26,4 609 | 85,38,6 610 | 85,71,6 611 | 85,105,3 612 | 86,4,4 613 | 86,7,2 614 | 86,20,6 615 | 86,23,2 616 | 86,25,4 617 | 86,55,2 618 | 86,67,5 619 | 86,82,3 620 | 86,95,6 621 | 87,7,8 622 | 87,22,6 623 | 87,25,8 624 | 87,29,5 625 | 87,47,4 626 | 87,52,5 627 | 87,72,8 628 | 87,82,8 629 | 88,1,4 630 | 88,2,6 631 | 88,39,5 632 | 88,40,5 633 | 88,46,6 634 | 88,56,4 635 | 88,57,3 636 | 88,81,4 637 | 88,98,5 638 | 89,32,7 639 | 89,52,4 640 | 89,72,2 641 | 89,103,5 642 | 90,12,2 643 | 90,43,5 644 | 90,53,5 645 | 90,65,4 646 | 90,74,2 647 | 90,97,3 648 | 90,107,3 649 | 90,110,3 650 | 91,9,3 651 | 91,36,5 652 | 91,50,2 653 | 91,54,5 654 | 91,63,5 655 | 91,92,2 656 | 92,9,5 657 | 92,36,5 658 | 92,50,1 659 | 92,53,5 660 | 92,63,6 661 | 92,91,2 662 | 92,101,6 663 | 93,10,5 664 | 93,19,5 665 | 93,45,5 666 | 93,49,6 667 | 93,65,5 668 | 93,68,5 669 | 93,73,5 670 | 94,4,5 671 | 94,10,6 672 | 94,19,3 673 | 94,35,5 674 | 94,36,5 675 | 94,67,5 676 | 94,68,3 677 | 94,99,3 678 | 94,101,4 679 | 95,3,6 680 | 95,7,6 681 | 95,28,5 682 | 95,82,5 683 | 95,84,5 684 | 95,86,6 685 | 95,102,5 686 | 95,106,1 687 | 96,18,2 688 | 96,21,3 689 | 96,28,5 690 | 96,33,5 691 | 96,51,2 692 | 96,60,4 693 | 96,69,2 694 | 96,79,4 695 | 97,12,2 696 | 97,43,4 697 | 97,65,3 698 | 97,74,2 699 | 97,90,3 700 | 98,1,5 701 | 98,2,6 702 | 98,59,4 703 | 98,81,4 704 | 98,88,5 705 | 99,4,6 706 | 99,19,2 707 | 99,68,1 708 | 99,94,3 709 | 100,15,5 710 | 100,34,5 711 | 100,70,3 712 | 100,77,5 713 | 100,83,5 714 | 101,19,5 715 | 101,53,5 716 | 101,68,5 717 | 101,92,6 718 | 101,94,4 719 | 102,28,4 720 | 102,56,4 721 | 102,95,5 722 | 103,15,8 723 | 103,20,5 724 | 103,25,5 725 | 103,32,3 726 | 103,34,5 727 | 103,52,5 728 | 103,72,6 729 | 103,77,7 730 | 103,89,5 731 | 104,8,7 732 | 104,13,6 733 | 104,17,4 734 | 104,42,4 735 | 104,48,6 736 | 104,63,5 737 | 104,71,4 738 | 105,8,7 739 | 105,11,10 740 | 105,26,5 741 | 105,38,6 742 | 105,41,8 743 | 105,42,11 744 | 105,71,8 745 | 105,85,3 746 | 106,28,5 747 | 106,82,5 748 | 106,84,5 749 | 106,95,1 750 | 107,12,4 751 | 107,43,5 752 | 107,58,5 753 | 107,74,3 754 | 107,90,3 755 | 108,5,5 756 | 108,6,5 757 | 108,37,3 758 | 108,49,6 759 | 108,78,4 760 | 108,109,3 761 | 109,5,7 762 | 109,6,5 763 | 109,37,1 764 | 109,49,5 765 | 109,73,5 766 | 109,80,4 767 | 109,108,3 768 | 110,12,3 769 | 110,65,3 770 | 110,74,4 771 | 110,90,3 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford3/mumford3_links.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,travel_time 2 | 1,8,5 3 | 1,12,3 4 | 1,27,3 5 | 1,49,6 6 | 1,78,4 7 | 1,80,5 8 | 1,98,5 9 | 1,102,5 10 | 1,121,5 11 | 2,12,4 12 | 2,28,4 13 | 2,47,5 14 | 2,68,2 15 | 2,78,3 16 | 2,82,6 17 | 2,119,4 18 | 3,12,6 19 | 3,24,5 20 | 3,38,2 21 | 3,49,6 22 | 3,50,5 23 | 3,75,4 24 | 3,80,3 25 | 3,98,4 26 | 3,115,6 27 | 4,13,2 28 | 4,16,5 29 | 4,57,5 30 | 4,69,7 31 | 4,72,4 32 | 4,79,5 33 | 4,97,4 34 | 4,101,5 35 | 4,108,5 36 | 4,116,6 37 | 5,11,6 38 | 5,19,4 39 | 5,44,5 40 | 5,65,6 41 | 5,70,2 42 | 5,104,3 43 | 5,110,3 44 | 5,112,7 45 | 6,10,5 46 | 6,25,4 47 | 6,30,6 48 | 6,37,1 49 | 6,59,6 50 | 6,64,4 51 | 6,81,4 52 | 7,33,4 53 | 7,46,1 54 | 7,56,5 55 | 7,61,3 56 | 7,74,5 57 | 7,113,6 58 | 8,1,5 59 | 8,12,6 60 | 8,27,3 61 | 8,41,5 62 | 8,66,5 63 | 8,94,3 64 | 8,102,2 65 | 8,121,2 66 | 9,22,5 67 | 9,23,2 68 | 9,31,8 69 | 9,36,9 70 | 9,42,5 71 | 9,58,6 72 | 9,120,5 73 | 10,6,5 74 | 10,30,4 75 | 10,37,5 76 | 10,64,6 77 | 10,67,5 78 | 10,71,4 79 | 10,73,5 80 | 10,81,2 81 | 10,82,6 82 | 10,125,5 83 | 11,5,6 84 | 11,19,4 85 | 11,70,5 86 | 11,87,4 87 | 11,110,4 88 | 11,118,4 89 | 12,1,3 90 | 12,2,4 91 | 12,3,6 92 | 12,8,6 93 | 12,27,5 94 | 12,47,6 95 | 12,68,5 96 | 12,78,2 97 | 12,80,4 98 | 12,98,5 99 | 13,4,2 100 | 13,16,5 101 | 13,57,4 102 | 13,69,6 103 | 13,79,6 104 | 13,101,5 105 | 13,108,5 106 | 14,20,11 107 | 14,51,3 108 | 14,77,5 109 | 14,84,3 110 | 14,93,5 111 | 14,96,6 112 | 15,54,2 113 | 15,62,4 114 | 15,67,4 115 | 15,73,5 116 | 15,101,5 117 | 15,107,5 118 | 15,109,4 119 | 16,4,5 120 | 16,13,5 121 | 16,57,5 122 | 16,108,2 123 | 17,56,4 124 | 17,63,7 125 | 17,113,7 126 | 17,115,4 127 | 18,29,6 128 | 18,43,3 129 | 18,44,5 130 | 18,60,5 131 | 18,65,6 132 | 18,90,6 133 | 18,91,4 134 | 18,99,3 135 | 18,114,3 136 | 19,5,4 137 | 19,11,4 138 | 19,70,3 139 | 19,87,7 140 | 19,104,6 141 | 19,105,7 142 | 19,110,2 143 | 19,118,7 144 | 20,14,11 145 | 20,21,5 146 | 20,33,10 147 | 20,51,11 148 | 20,76,7 149 | 20,77,8 150 | 20,86,4 151 | 20,93,10 152 | 21,20,5 153 | 21,33,7 154 | 21,51,7 155 | 21,76,7 156 | 21,77,4 157 | 21,86,3 158 | 21,93,6 159 | 22,9,5 160 | 22,23,5 161 | 22,36,8 162 | 22,42,9 163 | 22,58,10 164 | 22,120,2 165 | 22,126,10 166 | 23,9,2 167 | 23,22,5 168 | 23,31,7 169 | 23,36,8 170 | 23,42,5 171 | 23,58,7 172 | 23,120,5 173 | 23,126,7 174 | 24,3,5 175 | 24,38,4 176 | 24,50,2 177 | 24,54,4 178 | 24,73,3 179 | 24,75,3 180 | 24,115,6 181 | 24,125,3 182 | 25,6,4 183 | 25,37,4 184 | 25,87,6 185 | 25,88,6 186 | 25,103,4 187 | 25,118,6 188 | 26,31,5 189 | 26,34,5 190 | 26,39,7 191 | 26,40,4 192 | 26,42,5 193 | 26,89,3 194 | 26,92,5 195 | 26,122,5 196 | 27,1,3 197 | 27,8,3 198 | 27,12,5 199 | 27,41,6 200 | 27,49,6 201 | 27,94,5 202 | 27,102,4 203 | 27,121,4 204 | 27,127,6 205 | 28,2,4 206 | 28,30,5 207 | 28,53,7 208 | 28,68,3 209 | 28,82,3 210 | 28,95,4 211 | 28,119,5 212 | 28,123,5 213 | 29,18,6 214 | 29,43,8 215 | 29,44,6 216 | 29,65,2 217 | 29,99,5 218 | 29,104,5 219 | 29,112,6 220 | 30,6,6 221 | 30,10,4 222 | 30,28,5 223 | 30,37,6 224 | 30,81,3 225 | 30,82,3 226 | 30,95,3 227 | 30,123,6 228 | 31,9,8 229 | 31,23,7 230 | 31,26,5 231 | 31,32,8 232 | 31,34,2 233 | 31,39,5 234 | 31,40,5 235 | 31,42,4 236 | 31,55,6 237 | 31,58,6 238 | 31,89,8 239 | 32,31,8 240 | 32,34,6 241 | 32,39,3 242 | 32,40,6 243 | 32,48,7 244 | 32,52,2 245 | 32,53,3 246 | 32,55,6 247 | 32,90,6 248 | 33,7,4 249 | 33,20,10 250 | 33,21,7 251 | 33,46,4 252 | 33,61,2 253 | 33,76,7 254 | 33,113,7 255 | 33,127,6 256 | 34,26,5 257 | 34,31,2 258 | 34,32,6 259 | 34,39,4 260 | 34,40,4 261 | 34,42,5 262 | 34,55,6 263 | 35,57,5 264 | 35,69,4 265 | 36,9,9 266 | 36,22,8 267 | 36,23,8 268 | 36,92,6 269 | 36,124,5 270 | 36,126,5 271 | 37,6,1 272 | 37,10,5 273 | 37,25,4 274 | 37,30,6 275 | 37,59,6 276 | 37,64,4 277 | 37,81,4 278 | 38,3,2 279 | 38,24,4 280 | 38,75,3 281 | 38,80,4 282 | 38,98,5 283 | 39,26,7 284 | 39,31,5 285 | 39,32,3 286 | 39,34,4 287 | 39,40,5 288 | 39,48,7 289 | 39,52,4 290 | 39,53,5 291 | 39,55,5 292 | 40,26,4 293 | 40,31,5 294 | 40,32,6 295 | 40,34,4 296 | 40,39,5 297 | 40,47,5 298 | 40,89,5 299 | 41,8,5 300 | 41,27,6 301 | 41,45,4 302 | 41,51,5 303 | 41,66,2 304 | 41,83,5 305 | 41,93,6 306 | 41,94,5 307 | 41,96,6 308 | 41,117,2 309 | 42,9,5 310 | 42,22,9 311 | 42,23,5 312 | 42,26,5 313 | 42,31,4 314 | 42,34,5 315 | 42,58,6 316 | 43,18,3 317 | 43,29,8 318 | 43,44,5 319 | 43,60,3 320 | 43,90,4 321 | 43,91,4 322 | 43,99,5 323 | 43,105,7 324 | 43,106,7 325 | 43,114,2 326 | 44,5,5 327 | 44,18,5 328 | 44,29,6 329 | 44,43,5 330 | 44,60,5 331 | 44,65,5 332 | 44,70,5 333 | 44,91,2 334 | 44,99,3 335 | 44,104,4 336 | 44,105,5 337 | 44,106,6 338 | 44,110,7 339 | 44,114,4 340 | 45,41,4 341 | 45,66,3 342 | 45,83,2 343 | 45,94,4 344 | 45,96,5 345 | 45,117,3 346 | 45,121,5 347 | 46,7,1 348 | 46,33,4 349 | 46,56,5 350 | 46,61,3 351 | 46,74,5 352 | 46,113,6 353 | 47,2,5 354 | 47,12,6 355 | 47,40,5 356 | 47,68,6 357 | 47,119,4 358 | 48,32,7 359 | 48,39,7 360 | 48,52,7 361 | 48,55,3 362 | 49,1,6 363 | 49,3,6 364 | 49,27,6 365 | 49,74,2 366 | 49,80,5 367 | 49,98,4 368 | 49,100,3 369 | 49,127,5 370 | 50,3,5 371 | 50,24,2 372 | 50,67,3 373 | 50,73,2 374 | 50,75,4 375 | 50,125,2 376 | 51,14,3 377 | 51,20,11 378 | 51,21,7 379 | 51,41,5 380 | 51,66,6 381 | 51,77,4 382 | 51,84,1 383 | 51,93,2 384 | 51,96,8 385 | 51,117,6 386 | 52,32,2 387 | 52,39,4 388 | 52,48,7 389 | 52,53,2 390 | 52,55,6 391 | 52,90,5 392 | 53,28,7 393 | 53,32,3 394 | 53,39,5 395 | 53,52,2 396 | 53,90,5 397 | 53,119,5 398 | 53,123,5 399 | 54,15,2 400 | 54,24,4 401 | 54,62,5 402 | 54,67,3 403 | 55,31,6 404 | 55,32,6 405 | 55,34,6 406 | 55,39,5 407 | 55,48,3 408 | 55,52,6 409 | 56,7,5 410 | 56,17,4 411 | 56,46,5 412 | 56,61,6 413 | 56,100,6 414 | 56,113,5 415 | 57,4,5 416 | 57,13,4 417 | 57,16,5 418 | 57,35,5 419 | 57,69,4 420 | 57,85,7 421 | 57,108,5 422 | 58,9,6 423 | 58,22,10 424 | 58,23,7 425 | 58,31,6 426 | 58,42,6 427 | 59,6,6 428 | 59,37,6 429 | 59,64,3 430 | 59,105,4 431 | 59,106,3 432 | 60,18,5 433 | 60,43,3 434 | 60,44,5 435 | 60,90,4 436 | 60,91,5 437 | 60,105,5 438 | 60,114,3 439 | 61,7,3 440 | 61,33,2 441 | 61,46,3 442 | 61,56,6 443 | 61,74,5 444 | 61,76,7 445 | 61,113,7 446 | 62,15,4 447 | 62,54,5 448 | 62,88,5 449 | 62,103,5 450 | 62,107,2 451 | 62,109,1 452 | 62,116,3 453 | 63,17,7 454 | 63,113,8 455 | 64,6,4 456 | 64,10,6 457 | 64,37,4 458 | 64,59,3 459 | 64,81,5 460 | 64,106,5 461 | 65,5,6 462 | 65,18,6 463 | 65,29,2 464 | 65,44,5 465 | 65,99,5 466 | 65,104,4 467 | 65,112,5 468 | 66,8,5 469 | 66,41,2 470 | 66,45,3 471 | 66,51,6 472 | 66,83,4 473 | 66,94,4 474 | 66,96,6 475 | 66,102,5 476 | 66,117,1 477 | 66,121,4 478 | 67,10,5 479 | 67,15,4 480 | 67,50,3 481 | 67,54,3 482 | 67,71,2 483 | 67,73,2 484 | 67,75,5 485 | 67,81,5 486 | 67,125,2 487 | 68,2,2 488 | 68,12,5 489 | 68,28,3 490 | 68,47,6 491 | 68,78,4 492 | 68,82,5 493 | 68,119,4 494 | 69,4,7 495 | 69,13,6 496 | 69,35,4 497 | 69,57,4 498 | 69,85,5 499 | 69,111,6 500 | 70,5,2 501 | 70,11,5 502 | 70,19,3 503 | 70,44,5 504 | 70,104,4 505 | 70,110,2 506 | 70,112,8 507 | 71,10,4 508 | 71,67,2 509 | 71,73,2 510 | 71,81,5 511 | 71,125,2 512 | 72,4,4 513 | 72,79,2 514 | 72,97,1 515 | 72,101,2 516 | 73,10,5 517 | 73,15,5 518 | 73,24,3 519 | 73,50,2 520 | 73,67,2 521 | 73,71,2 522 | 73,75,5 523 | 73,125,1 524 | 74,7,5 525 | 74,46,5 526 | 74,49,2 527 | 74,61,5 528 | 74,100,3 529 | 74,127,4 530 | 75,3,4 531 | 75,24,3 532 | 75,38,3 533 | 75,50,4 534 | 75,67,5 535 | 75,73,5 536 | 75,115,4 537 | 76,20,7 538 | 76,21,7 539 | 76,33,7 540 | 76,61,7 541 | 76,86,8 542 | 77,14,5 543 | 77,20,8 544 | 77,21,4 545 | 77,51,4 546 | 77,84,4 547 | 77,86,5 548 | 77,93,3 549 | 78,1,4 550 | 78,2,3 551 | 78,12,2 552 | 78,68,4 553 | 79,4,5 554 | 79,13,6 555 | 79,72,2 556 | 79,97,2 557 | 79,101,2 558 | 79,115,5 559 | 80,1,5 560 | 80,3,3 561 | 80,12,4 562 | 80,38,4 563 | 80,49,5 564 | 80,98,2 565 | 81,6,4 566 | 81,10,2 567 | 81,30,3 568 | 81,37,4 569 | 81,64,5 570 | 81,67,5 571 | 81,71,5 572 | 81,82,5 573 | 82,2,6 574 | 82,10,6 575 | 82,28,3 576 | 82,30,3 577 | 82,68,5 578 | 82,81,5 579 | 82,95,2 580 | 82,123,5 581 | 83,41,5 582 | 83,45,2 583 | 83,66,4 584 | 83,89,6 585 | 83,92,6 586 | 83,94,4 587 | 83,96,5 588 | 83,117,4 589 | 84,14,3 590 | 84,51,1 591 | 84,77,4 592 | 84,93,2 593 | 85,57,7 594 | 85,69,5 595 | 85,88,5 596 | 85,111,2 597 | 86,20,4 598 | 86,21,3 599 | 86,76,8 600 | 86,77,5 601 | 86,93,7 602 | 87,11,4 603 | 87,19,7 604 | 87,25,6 605 | 87,110,7 606 | 87,118,1 607 | 88,25,6 608 | 88,62,5 609 | 88,85,5 610 | 88,103,3 611 | 88,107,4 612 | 88,109,5 613 | 88,111,4 614 | 89,26,3 615 | 89,31,8 616 | 89,40,5 617 | 89,83,6 618 | 89,92,4 619 | 89,94,6 620 | 89,102,6 621 | 89,122,2 622 | 89,126,5 623 | 90,18,6 624 | 90,32,6 625 | 90,43,4 626 | 90,52,5 627 | 90,53,5 628 | 90,60,4 629 | 90,114,5 630 | 91,18,4 631 | 91,43,4 632 | 91,44,2 633 | 91,60,5 634 | 91,99,3 635 | 91,104,5 636 | 91,114,3 637 | 92,26,5 638 | 92,36,6 639 | 92,83,6 640 | 92,89,4 641 | 92,122,4 642 | 92,124,5 643 | 92,126,2 644 | 93,14,5 645 | 93,20,10 646 | 93,21,6 647 | 93,41,6 648 | 93,51,2 649 | 93,77,3 650 | 93,84,2 651 | 93,86,7 652 | 93,127,5 653 | 94,8,3 654 | 94,27,5 655 | 94,41,5 656 | 94,45,4 657 | 94,66,4 658 | 94,83,4 659 | 94,89,6 660 | 94,102,3 661 | 94,117,4 662 | 94,121,2 663 | 95,28,4 664 | 95,30,3 665 | 95,82,2 666 | 95,123,4 667 | 96,14,6 668 | 96,41,6 669 | 96,45,5 670 | 96,51,8 671 | 96,66,6 672 | 96,83,5 673 | 96,117,6 674 | 96,124,6 675 | 97,4,4 676 | 97,72,1 677 | 97,79,2 678 | 97,101,2 679 | 98,1,5 680 | 98,3,4 681 | 98,12,5 682 | 98,38,5 683 | 98,49,4 684 | 98,80,2 685 | 99,18,3 686 | 99,29,5 687 | 99,43,5 688 | 99,44,3 689 | 99,65,5 690 | 99,91,3 691 | 99,104,5 692 | 99,114,4 693 | 100,49,3 694 | 100,56,6 695 | 100,74,3 696 | 101,4,5 697 | 101,13,5 698 | 101,15,5 699 | 101,72,2 700 | 101,79,2 701 | 101,97,2 702 | 102,1,5 703 | 102,8,2 704 | 102,27,4 705 | 102,66,5 706 | 102,89,6 707 | 102,94,3 708 | 102,117,5 709 | 102,121,2 710 | 103,25,4 711 | 103,62,5 712 | 103,88,3 713 | 103,107,5 714 | 103,109,5 715 | 104,5,3 716 | 104,19,6 717 | 104,29,5 718 | 104,44,4 719 | 104,65,4 720 | 104,70,4 721 | 104,91,5 722 | 104,99,5 723 | 104,110,5 724 | 104,112,6 725 | 105,19,7 726 | 105,43,7 727 | 105,44,5 728 | 105,59,4 729 | 105,60,5 730 | 105,106,2 731 | 106,43,7 732 | 106,44,6 733 | 106,59,3 734 | 106,64,5 735 | 106,105,2 736 | 107,15,5 737 | 107,62,2 738 | 107,88,4 739 | 107,103,5 740 | 107,109,2 741 | 107,116,3 742 | 108,4,5 743 | 108,13,5 744 | 108,16,2 745 | 108,57,5 746 | 109,15,4 747 | 109,62,1 748 | 109,88,5 749 | 109,103,5 750 | 109,107,2 751 | 109,116,3 752 | 110,5,3 753 | 110,11,4 754 | 110,19,2 755 | 110,44,7 756 | 110,70,2 757 | 110,87,7 758 | 110,104,5 759 | 111,69,6 760 | 111,85,2 761 | 111,88,4 762 | 112,5,7 763 | 112,29,6 764 | 112,65,5 765 | 112,70,8 766 | 112,104,6 767 | 113,7,6 768 | 113,17,7 769 | 113,33,7 770 | 113,46,6 771 | 113,56,5 772 | 113,61,7 773 | 113,63,8 774 | 114,18,3 775 | 114,43,2 776 | 114,44,4 777 | 114,60,3 778 | 114,90,5 779 | 114,91,3 780 | 114,99,4 781 | 115,3,6 782 | 115,17,4 783 | 115,24,6 784 | 115,75,4 785 | 115,79,5 786 | 116,4,6 787 | 116,62,3 788 | 116,107,3 789 | 116,109,3 790 | 117,41,2 791 | 117,45,3 792 | 117,51,6 793 | 117,66,1 794 | 117,83,4 795 | 117,94,4 796 | 117,96,6 797 | 117,102,5 798 | 117,121,4 799 | 118,11,4 800 | 118,19,7 801 | 118,25,6 802 | 118,87,1 803 | 119,2,4 804 | 119,28,5 805 | 119,47,4 806 | 119,53,5 807 | 119,68,4 808 | 119,123,6 809 | 120,9,5 810 | 120,22,2 811 | 120,23,5 812 | 121,1,5 813 | 121,8,2 814 | 121,27,4 815 | 121,45,5 816 | 121,66,4 817 | 121,94,2 818 | 121,102,2 819 | 121,117,4 820 | 122,26,5 821 | 122,89,2 822 | 122,92,4 823 | 122,126,5 824 | 123,28,5 825 | 123,30,6 826 | 123,53,5 827 | 123,82,5 828 | 123,95,4 829 | 123,119,6 830 | 124,36,5 831 | 124,92,5 832 | 124,96,6 833 | 124,126,5 834 | 125,10,5 835 | 125,24,3 836 | 125,50,2 837 | 125,67,2 838 | 125,71,2 839 | 125,73,1 840 | 126,22,10 841 | 126,23,7 842 | 126,36,5 843 | 126,89,5 844 | 126,92,2 845 | 126,122,5 846 | 126,124,5 847 | 127,27,6 848 | 127,33,6 849 | 127,49,5 850 | 127,74,4 851 | 127,93,5 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mumford/Mumford0/mumford0_demand.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | from,to,demand 2 | 1,2,770 3 | 1,3,5 4 | 1,4,620 5 | 1,5,655 6 | 1,6,695 7 | 1,7,70 8 | 1,8,320 9 | 1,9,210 10 | 1,10,645 11 | 1,11,350 12 | 1,12,730 13 | 1,13,150 14 | 1,14,215 15 | 1,15,120 16 | 1,16,110 17 | 1,17,700 18 | 1,18,465 19 | 1,19,440 20 | 1,20,120 21 | 1,21,685 22 | 1,22,500 23 | 1,23,285 24 | 1,24,415 25 | 1,25,325 26 | 1,26,65 27 | 1,27,195 28 | 1,28,100 29 | 1,29,150 30 | 1,30,195 31 | 2,1,770 32 | 2,3,335 33 | 2,4,40 34 | 2,5,725 35 | 2,6,760 36 | 2,7,395 37 | 2,8,395 38 | 2,9,275 39 | 2,10,725 40 | 2,11,300 41 | 2,12,90 42 | 2,13,625 43 | 2,14,315 44 | 2,15,195 45 | 2,16,325 46 | 2,17,80 47 | 2,18,110 48 | 2,19,755 49 | 2,20,765 50 | 2,21,465 51 | 2,22,50 52 | 2,23,190 53 | 2,24,285 54 | 2,25,660 55 | 2,26,15 56 | 2,27,35 57 | 2,28,140 58 | 2,29,520 59 | 2,30,590 60 | 3,1,5 61 | 3,2,335 62 | 3,4,520 63 | 3,5,365 64 | 3,6,440 65 | 3,7,240 66 | 3,8,600 67 | 3,9,155 68 | 3,10,550 69 | 3,11,150 70 | 3,12,295 71 | 3,13,505 72 | 3,14,625 73 | 3,15,65 74 | 3,16,745 75 | 3,17,625 76 | 3,18,390 77 | 3,19,350 78 | 3,20,360 79 | 3,21,250 80 | 3,22,410 81 | 3,23,410 82 | 3,24,655 83 | 3,25,640 84 | 3,26,520 85 | 3,27,305 86 | 3,28,650 87 | 3,29,430 88 | 3,30,285 89 | 4,1,620 90 | 4,2,40 91 | 4,3,520 92 | 4,5,755 93 | 4,6,705 94 | 4,7,445 95 | 4,8,500 96 | 4,9,470 97 | 4,10,170 98 | 4,11,245 99 | 4,12,380 100 | 4,13,185 101 | 4,14,680 102 | 4,15,160 103 | 4,16,185 104 | 4,17,140 105 | 4,18,185 106 | 4,19,350 107 | 4,20,250 108 | 4,21,740 109 | 4,22,345 110 | 4,23,150 111 | 4,24,725 112 | 4,25,785 113 | 4,26,355 114 | 4,27,90 115 | 4,28,210 116 | 4,29,330 117 | 4,30,480 118 | 5,1,655 119 | 5,2,725 120 | 5,3,365 121 | 5,4,755 122 | 5,6,210 123 | 5,7,485 124 | 5,8,570 125 | 5,9,180 126 | 5,10,95 127 | 5,11,240 128 | 5,12,260 129 | 5,13,340 130 | 5,14,410 131 | 5,15,70 132 | 5,16,210 133 | 5,17,645 134 | 5,18,25 135 | 5,19,745 136 | 5,20,585 137 | 5,21,395 138 | 5,22,465 139 | 5,23,190 140 | 5,24,370 141 | 5,25,775 142 | 5,26,440 143 | 5,27,420 144 | 5,28,190 145 | 5,29,395 146 | 5,30,500 147 | 6,1,695 148 | 6,2,760 149 | 6,3,440 150 | 6,4,705 151 | 6,5,210 152 | 6,7,545 153 | 6,8,320 154 | 6,9,295 155 | 6,10,795 156 | 6,11,35 157 | 6,12,710 158 | 6,13,735 159 | 6,14,640 160 | 6,15,80 161 | 6,16,210 162 | 6,17,270 163 | 6,18,545 164 | 6,19,110 165 | 6,20,580 166 | 6,21,90 167 | 6,22,525 168 | 6,23,400 169 | 6,24,625 170 | 6,25,575 171 | 6,26,725 172 | 6,27,715 173 | 6,28,270 174 | 6,29,560 175 | 6,30,160 176 | 7,1,70 177 | 7,2,395 178 | 7,3,240 179 | 7,4,445 180 | 7,5,485 181 | 7,6,545 182 | 7,8,25 183 | 7,9,600 184 | 7,10,405 185 | 7,11,385 186 | 7,12,725 187 | 7,13,490 188 | 7,14,495 189 | 7,15,690 190 | 7,16,645 191 | 7,17,465 192 | 7,18,150 193 | 7,19,195 194 | 7,20,710 195 | 7,21,25 196 | 7,22,395 197 | 7,23,135 198 | 7,24,785 199 | 7,25,575 200 | 7,26,405 201 | 7,27,380 202 | 7,28,50 203 | 7,29,550 204 | 7,30,35 205 | 8,1,320 206 | 8,2,395 207 | 8,3,600 208 | 8,4,500 209 | 8,5,570 210 | 8,6,320 211 | 8,7,25 212 | 8,9,60 213 | 8,10,420 214 | 8,11,80 215 | 8,12,655 216 | 8,13,655 217 | 8,14,580 218 | 8,15,120 219 | 8,16,530 220 | 8,17,415 221 | 8,18,780 222 | 8,19,520 223 | 8,20,645 224 | 8,21,365 225 | 8,22,350 226 | 8,23,665 227 | 8,24,70 228 | 8,25,110 229 | 8,26,140 230 | 8,27,315 231 | 8,28,670 232 | 8,29,645 233 | 8,30,50 234 | 9,1,210 235 | 9,2,275 236 | 9,3,155 237 | 9,4,470 238 | 9,5,180 239 | 9,6,295 240 | 9,7,600 241 | 9,8,60 242 | 9,10,320 243 | 9,11,425 244 | 9,12,335 245 | 9,13,530 246 | 9,14,505 247 | 9,15,235 248 | 9,16,350 249 | 9,17,15 250 | 9,18,790 251 | 9,19,135 252 | 9,20,85 253 | 9,21,300 254 | 9,22,160 255 | 9,23,395 256 | 9,24,275 257 | 9,25,765 258 | 9,26,740 259 | 9,27,45 260 | 9,28,595 261 | 9,29,220 262 | 9,30,340 263 | 10,1,645 264 | 10,2,725 265 | 10,3,550 266 | 10,4,170 267 | 10,5,95 268 | 10,6,795 269 | 10,7,405 270 | 10,8,420 271 | 10,9,320 272 | 10,11,440 273 | 10,12,755 274 | 10,13,335 275 | 10,14,790 276 | 10,15,245 277 | 10,16,565 278 | 10,17,535 279 | 10,18,435 280 | 10,19,560 281 | 10,20,535 282 | 10,21,145 283 | 10,22,105 284 | 10,23,800 285 | 10,24,140 286 | 10,25,30 287 | 10,26,450 288 | 10,27,710 289 | 10,28,540 290 | 10,29,155 291 | 10,30,300 292 | 11,1,350 293 | 11,2,300 294 | 11,3,150 295 | 11,4,245 296 | 11,5,240 297 | 11,6,35 298 | 11,7,385 299 | 11,8,80 300 | 11,9,425 301 | 11,10,440 302 | 11,12,370 303 | 11,13,790 304 | 11,14,130 305 | 11,15,685 306 | 11,16,520 307 | 11,17,305 308 | 11,18,155 309 | 11,19,345 310 | 11,20,390 311 | 11,21,100 312 | 11,22,475 313 | 11,23,185 314 | 11,24,310 315 | 11,25,470 316 | 11,26,205 317 | 11,27,235 318 | 11,28,495 319 | 11,29,215 320 | 11,30,660 321 | 12,1,730 322 | 12,2,90 323 | 12,3,295 324 | 12,4,380 325 | 12,5,260 326 | 12,6,710 327 | 12,7,725 328 | 12,8,655 329 | 12,9,335 330 | 12,10,755 331 | 12,11,370 332 | 12,13,790 333 | 12,14,585 334 | 12,15,280 335 | 12,16,470 336 | 12,17,90 337 | 12,18,730 338 | 12,19,705 339 | 12,20,655 340 | 12,21,210 341 | 12,22,480 342 | 12,23,20 343 | 12,24,345 344 | 12,25,255 345 | 12,26,130 346 | 12,27,145 347 | 12,28,340 348 | 12,29,80 349 | 12,30,480 350 | 13,1,150 351 | 13,2,625 352 | 13,3,505 353 | 13,4,185 354 | 13,5,340 355 | 13,6,735 356 | 13,7,490 357 | 13,8,655 358 | 13,9,530 359 | 13,10,335 360 | 13,11,790 361 | 13,12,790 362 | 13,14,380 363 | 13,15,560 364 | 13,16,560 365 | 13,17,515 366 | 13,18,30 367 | 13,19,60 368 | 13,20,260 369 | 13,21,425 370 | 13,22,525 371 | 13,23,330 372 | 13,24,660 373 | 13,25,575 374 | 13,26,775 375 | 13,27,430 376 | 13,28,265 377 | 13,29,85 378 | 13,30,490 379 | 14,1,215 380 | 14,2,315 381 | 14,3,625 382 | 14,4,680 383 | 14,5,410 384 | 14,6,640 385 | 14,7,495 386 | 14,8,580 387 | 14,9,505 388 | 14,10,790 389 | 14,11,130 390 | 14,12,585 391 | 14,13,380 392 | 14,15,625 393 | 14,16,340 394 | 14,17,75 395 | 14,18,215 396 | 14,19,125 397 | 14,20,225 398 | 14,21,355 399 | 14,22,425 400 | 14,23,370 401 | 14,24,705 402 | 14,25,415 403 | 14,26,755 404 | 14,27,515 405 | 14,28,770 406 | 14,29,195 407 | 14,30,545 408 | 15,1,120 409 | 15,2,195 410 | 15,3,65 411 | 15,4,160 412 | 15,5,70 413 | 15,6,80 414 | 15,7,690 415 | 15,8,120 416 | 15,9,235 417 | 15,10,245 418 | 15,11,685 419 | 15,12,280 420 | 15,13,560 421 | 15,14,625 422 | 15,16,235 423 | 15,17,540 424 | 15,18,560 425 | 15,19,55 426 | 15,20,205 427 | 15,21,180 428 | 15,22,535 429 | 15,23,680 430 | 15,24,280 431 | 15,25,625 432 | 15,26,545 433 | 15,27,10 434 | 15,28,485 435 | 15,29,310 436 | 15,30,735 437 | 16,1,110 438 | 16,2,325 439 | 16,3,745 440 | 16,4,185 441 | 16,5,210 442 | 16,6,210 443 | 16,7,645 444 | 16,8,530 445 | 16,9,350 446 | 16,10,565 447 | 16,11,520 448 | 16,12,470 449 | 16,13,560 450 | 16,14,340 451 | 16,15,235 452 | 16,17,5 453 | 16,18,370 454 | 16,19,340 455 | 16,20,370 456 | 16,21,620 457 | 16,22,260 458 | 16,23,630 459 | 16,24,380 460 | 16,25,30 461 | 16,26,145 462 | 16,27,580 463 | 16,28,380 464 | 16,29,125 465 | 16,30,275 466 | 17,1,700 467 | 17,2,80 468 | 17,3,625 469 | 17,4,140 470 | 17,5,645 471 | 17,6,270 472 | 17,7,465 473 | 17,8,415 474 | 17,9,15 475 | 17,10,535 476 | 17,11,305 477 | 17,12,90 478 | 17,13,515 479 | 17,14,75 480 | 17,15,540 481 | 17,16,5 482 | 17,18,490 483 | 17,19,155 484 | 17,20,595 485 | 17,21,195 486 | 17,22,735 487 | 17,23,220 488 | 17,24,615 489 | 17,25,155 490 | 17,26,230 491 | 17,27,75 492 | 17,28,465 493 | 17,29,550 494 | 17,30,440 495 | 18,1,465 496 | 18,2,110 497 | 18,3,390 498 | 18,4,185 499 | 18,5,25 500 | 18,6,545 501 | 18,7,150 502 | 18,8,780 503 | 18,9,790 504 | 18,10,435 505 | 18,11,155 506 | 18,12,730 507 | 18,13,30 508 | 18,14,215 509 | 18,15,560 510 | 18,16,370 511 | 18,17,490 512 | 18,19,345 513 | 18,20,520 514 | 18,21,520 515 | 18,22,545 516 | 18,23,510 517 | 18,24,760 518 | 18,25,170 519 | 18,26,570 520 | 18,27,190 521 | 18,28,100 522 | 18,29,490 523 | 18,30,365 524 | 19,1,440 525 | 19,2,755 526 | 19,3,350 527 | 19,4,350 528 | 19,5,745 529 | 19,6,110 530 | 19,7,195 531 | 19,8,520 532 | 19,9,135 533 | 19,10,560 534 | 19,11,345 535 | 19,12,705 536 | 19,13,60 537 | 19,14,125 538 | 19,15,55 539 | 19,16,340 540 | 19,17,155 541 | 19,18,345 542 | 19,20,370 543 | 19,21,530 544 | 19,22,620 545 | 19,23,285 546 | 19,24,530 547 | 19,25,335 548 | 19,26,675 549 | 19,27,670 550 | 19,28,210 551 | 19,29,495 552 | 19,30,470 553 | 20,1,120 554 | 20,2,765 555 | 20,3,360 556 | 20,4,250 557 | 20,5,585 558 | 20,6,580 559 | 20,7,710 560 | 20,8,645 561 | 20,9,85 562 | 20,10,535 563 | 20,11,390 564 | 20,12,655 565 | 20,13,260 566 | 20,14,225 567 | 20,15,205 568 | 20,16,370 569 | 20,17,595 570 | 20,18,520 571 | 20,19,370 572 | 20,21,435 573 | 20,22,700 574 | 20,23,215 575 | 20,24,255 576 | 20,25,100 577 | 20,26,755 578 | 20,27,520 579 | 20,28,385 580 | 20,29,515 581 | 20,30,440 582 | 21,1,685 583 | 21,2,465 584 | 21,3,250 585 | 21,4,740 586 | 21,5,395 587 | 21,6,90 588 | 21,7,25 589 | 21,8,365 590 | 21,9,300 591 | 21,10,145 592 | 21,11,100 593 | 21,12,210 594 | 21,13,425 595 | 21,14,355 596 | 21,15,180 597 | 21,16,620 598 | 21,17,195 599 | 21,18,520 600 | 21,19,530 601 | 21,20,435 602 | 21,22,520 603 | 21,23,440 604 | 21,24,580 605 | 21,25,420 606 | 21,26,795 607 | 21,27,175 608 | 21,28,85 609 | 21,29,90 610 | 21,30,55 611 | 22,1,500 612 | 22,2,50 613 | 22,3,410 614 | 22,4,345 615 | 22,5,465 616 | 22,6,525 617 | 22,7,395 618 | 22,8,350 619 | 22,9,160 620 | 22,10,105 621 | 22,11,475 622 | 22,12,480 623 | 22,13,525 624 | 22,14,425 625 | 22,15,535 626 | 22,16,260 627 | 22,17,735 628 | 22,18,545 629 | 22,19,620 630 | 22,20,700 631 | 22,21,520 632 | 22,23,325 633 | 22,24,360 634 | 22,25,295 635 | 22,26,615 636 | 22,27,505 637 | 22,28,620 638 | 22,29,750 639 | 22,30,780 640 | 23,1,285 641 | 23,2,190 642 | 23,3,410 643 | 23,4,150 644 | 23,5,190 645 | 23,6,400 646 | 23,7,135 647 | 23,8,665 648 | 23,9,395 649 | 23,10,800 650 | 23,11,185 651 | 23,12,20 652 | 23,13,330 653 | 23,14,370 654 | 23,15,680 655 | 23,16,630 656 | 23,17,220 657 | 23,18,510 658 | 23,19,285 659 | 23,20,215 660 | 23,21,440 661 | 23,22,325 662 | 23,24,155 663 | 23,25,115 664 | 23,26,560 665 | 23,27,80 666 | 23,28,425 667 | 23,29,425 668 | 23,30,690 669 | 24,1,415 670 | 24,2,285 671 | 24,3,655 672 | 24,4,725 673 | 24,5,370 674 | 24,6,625 675 | 24,7,785 676 | 24,8,70 677 | 24,9,275 678 | 24,10,140 679 | 24,11,310 680 | 24,12,345 681 | 24,13,660 682 | 24,14,705 683 | 24,15,280 684 | 24,16,380 685 | 24,17,615 686 | 24,18,760 687 | 24,19,530 688 | 24,20,255 689 | 24,21,580 690 | 24,22,360 691 | 24,23,155 692 | 24,25,390 693 | 24,26,315 694 | 24,27,540 695 | 24,28,595 696 | 24,29,420 697 | 24,30,280 698 | 25,1,325 699 | 25,2,660 700 | 25,3,640 701 | 25,4,785 702 | 25,5,775 703 | 25,6,575 704 | 25,7,575 705 | 25,8,110 706 | 25,9,765 707 | 25,10,30 708 | 25,11,470 709 | 25,12,255 710 | 25,13,575 711 | 25,14,415 712 | 25,15,625 713 | 25,16,30 714 | 25,17,155 715 | 25,18,170 716 | 25,19,335 717 | 25,20,100 718 | 25,21,420 719 | 25,22,295 720 | 25,23,115 721 | 25,24,390 722 | 25,26,120 723 | 25,27,470 724 | 25,28,210 725 | 25,29,40 726 | 25,30,605 727 | 26,1,65 728 | 26,2,15 729 | 26,3,520 730 | 26,4,355 731 | 26,5,440 732 | 26,6,725 733 | 26,7,405 734 | 26,8,140 735 | 26,9,740 736 | 26,10,450 737 | 26,11,205 738 | 26,12,130 739 | 26,13,775 740 | 26,14,755 741 | 26,15,545 742 | 26,16,145 743 | 26,17,230 744 | 26,18,570 745 | 26,19,675 746 | 26,20,755 747 | 26,21,795 748 | 26,22,615 749 | 26,23,560 750 | 26,24,315 751 | 26,25,120 752 | 26,27,195 753 | 26,28,355 754 | 26,29,555 755 | 26,30,290 756 | 27,1,195 757 | 27,2,35 758 | 27,3,305 759 | 27,4,90 760 | 27,5,420 761 | 27,6,715 762 | 27,7,380 763 | 27,8,315 764 | 27,9,45 765 | 27,10,710 766 | 27,11,235 767 | 27,12,145 768 | 27,13,430 769 | 27,14,515 770 | 27,15,10 771 | 27,16,580 772 | 27,17,75 773 | 27,18,190 774 | 27,19,670 775 | 27,20,520 776 | 27,21,175 777 | 27,22,505 778 | 27,23,80 779 | 27,24,540 780 | 27,25,470 781 | 27,26,195 782 | 27,28,590 783 | 27,29,320 784 | 27,30,550 785 | 28,1,100 786 | 28,2,140 787 | 28,3,650 788 | 28,4,210 789 | 28,5,190 790 | 28,6,270 791 | 28,7,50 792 | 28,8,670 793 | 28,9,595 794 | 28,10,540 795 | 28,11,495 796 | 28,12,340 797 | 28,13,265 798 | 28,14,770 799 | 28,15,485 800 | 28,16,380 801 | 28,17,465 802 | 28,18,100 803 | 28,19,210 804 | 28,20,385 805 | 28,21,85 806 | 28,22,620 807 | 28,23,425 808 | 28,24,595 809 | 28,25,210 810 | 28,26,355 811 | 28,27,590 812 | 28,29,565 813 | 28,30,355 814 | 29,1,150 815 | 29,2,520 816 | 29,3,430 817 | 29,4,330 818 | 29,5,395 819 | 29,6,560 820 | 29,7,550 821 | 29,8,645 822 | 29,9,220 823 | 29,10,155 824 | 29,11,215 825 | 29,12,80 826 | 29,13,85 827 | 29,14,195 828 | 29,15,310 829 | 29,16,125 830 | 29,17,550 831 | 29,18,490 832 | 29,19,495 833 | 29,20,515 834 | 29,21,90 835 | 29,22,750 836 | 29,23,425 837 | 29,24,420 838 | 29,25,40 839 | 29,26,555 840 | 29,27,320 841 | 29,28,565 842 | 29,30,20 843 | 30,1,195 844 | 30,2,590 845 | 30,3,285 846 | 30,4,480 847 | 30,5,500 848 | 30,6,160 849 | 30,7,35 850 | 30,8,50 851 | 30,9,340 852 | 30,10,300 853 | 30,11,660 854 | 30,12,480 855 | 30,13,490 856 | 30,14,545 857 | 30,15,735 858 | 30,16,275 859 | 30,17,440 860 | 30,18,365 861 | 30,19,470 862 | 30,20,440 863 | 30,21,55 864 | 30,22,780 865 | 30,23,690 866 | 30,24,280 867 | 30,25,605 868 | 30,26,290 869 | 30,27,550 870 | 30,28,355 871 | 30,29,20 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /README.md: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | # Transit Network Design Instances 2 | 3 | TransitNetworkDesign is a public transit networks repository for research. Here you will find transit network instances and solution route sets proposed by authors in specialized academic literature and practitioners to benchmark new algorithms. Suggestions, additional instances and proposed new solutions route sets for any instance are always welcome. 4 | 5 | The Transit Network Design Problem (TNDP) involves finding a set of routes to operate in an urban public transport system. This is a hard combinatorial optimization problem, with multiple constraints and conflicting objective functions such as minimizing passenger generalized costs and operator costs. 6 | 7 | User costs generally corresponds to total travel time, including waiting time, in-vehicle travel time and transfer penalties, while operator costs may correspond to total bus routes length or fleet size. The multi-objective transit network design and frequency setting problem (TNDFSP) also includes finding those routes associates frequencies. This problem must also considerer capacity constraints as passenger demand may exceed supply. 8 | 9 | A known issue in this field of Transit Network Design is the lack of instances to apply methodologies, mainly larger instances and real-sized transit networks. The most used benchmark instance is Mandl, which is rather small compared to real-world cities, but nonetheless already brings quite a challenge for new researchers in the field. Larger instances, however, have more operational constraints to tackle, such as limitations on route start and stop locations, existing infrastructure such as terminals, rail lines and a high number of real bus stop locations. This site aims to fill this void and promote transit network design research and algorithms. 10 | 11 | ## How to Download Transit Network Design Instances 12 | 13 | Each instance is stored in a separate folder. In each folder you will find several files containing information on nodes, links and demand. Details on Data format are described in Format section. 14 | 15 | - (For all data) Clone the repository to your computer using the "Clone or Download" button 16 | - (For a single file) Click on a file, click view as Raw, and then save the file 17 | 18 | ## How to Add Instances 19 | 20 | There are several ways to add a network: 21 | - Fork the repository 22 | - Create a GitHub account if needed 23 | - Fork (copy) the repo to your account 24 | - Organize files in the suggested format (below) and create a README file in [Markdown](https://guides.github.com/features/mastering-markdown) for your addition as well. Take a look at some of the existing README files in the existing network folders to see what is expected. 25 | - Make changes such as adding a new folder and committing your data 26 | - Issue a pull request for us to review the changes and to merge your changes into the master 27 | - Create an issue, which will notify us (me). We will then reply to coordinate adding your instance/solutions to the site. 28 | 29 | - Or Email me: renatoarbex@usp.br 30 | 31 | ## How to Add Solution Route Sets and Objective Functions 32 | 33 | Solution route sets are proposed solutions for the network with some other necessary data. Route sets contain the number of routes proposed and their sequence of nodes. 34 | - Prepare your route sets using the same format described in Formats below. 35 | - Upload the data to the repository in the folder of that instance using instructions above 36 | 37 | *Objective functions*: several objective functions are proposed for this problem. You can either add just your solution route sets and/or additional files with complementary data. Suggested objective functions based on recent literature: 38 | - Total network user generalized cost 39 | - Fleet size required to operate solution with vehicle sizes 40 | - Average in-vehicle travel time 41 | - Total number of transfers in the network 42 | - Percentage of demand served with zero, one, two and two or more transfers 43 | - Empty seat hours 44 | - Accessibility to opportunities enabled by solution 45 | 46 | While several objective functions are suggested in the literature, total network user generalized cost and fleet size are already a good measure to compare algorithm solution route sets. 47 | 48 | *Complementary data suggested*: 49 | - Objective functions results 50 | - Routes frequencies 51 | - Vehicle(s) size used 52 | - Assignment procedure used 53 | - Transfer penalty adopted, as well as waiting time and access time perception factors 54 | 55 | # Formats 56 | 57 | To facilitate automation on reading/comparing solutions and inputting data for algorithms, a data format is suggested. For now, only file format for instances and solution route sets is encouraged. Other files should contain necessary information on objective functions and above complementary data, but no fixed format is enforced. 58 | 59 | ## Instance 60 | 61 | Instances are composed of *three main files: Nodes, Links and Demand*. While complex larger instances will need additional information, those 3 files already define the basic information for designing routes: 62 | 63 | ### Nodes 64 | Nodes are points that represent a possible location for vehicles to board/alight. They may also represent an aggregation of real-world bus stops, representing a traffic zone, for example. 65 | 66 | Format: 67 | A CSV file with node ID, latitude, longitude and an indication if the node is also a bus/transit terminal. The last "terminal" column accepts 0 or 1 values. If 0, only passing through routes are allowed in that node. This is necessary to represent real-world conditions of existing possible terminal locations and/or nodes which may not be able to serve as a route terminal, such as a highway node. 68 | 69 | Authors are encouraged to use node location in latitude and longitudes (EPSG 4326). If the instance does not represent a real-world location, location may be somewhere in the ocean. The will help further visualization tools that aim to provide insights over the proposed solution, such as routes and transit assignment visualizations. 70 | 71 | Node file should start from 1 and continue with unique continuous +1 ID until last node, as some graph libraries implementations might not work well if a number is missing. 72 | 73 | Example (Rivera instance): 74 | ``` 75 | id,lat,lon,terminal 76 | 1,-30.875393,-55.60165,1 77 | 2,-30.876683,-55.591102,1 78 | 3,-30.889253,-55.586219,1 79 | 4,-30.885728,-55.577737,1 80 | (...) 81 | ``` 82 | 83 | ### Links 84 | Links are connection between nodes in the network. 85 | 86 | Format: 87 | A CSV file with i node ID, j node ID and travel time in minutes. 88 | 89 | Example (Rivera instance): 90 | ``` 91 | from,to,travel_time 92 | 1,2,10.384615 93 | 2,1,10.384615 94 | 2,3,4.5 95 | 2,7,5.893847 96 | 2,11,7.901538 97 | 3,2,4.5 98 | 3,4,2.833846 99 | (...) 100 | ``` 101 | 102 | ### Demand 103 | Demand file represents the number of users that wants to travel between two nodes. Demand represents travel in a *1 hour period* (unless otherwise mentioned). While the value is encouraged be an integer, real values are accepted as this depends on how trip data was collected and expanded. 104 | 105 | Example 106 | ``` 107 | from,to,demand 108 | 1,3,4.90908 109 | 1,8,1.63638 110 | 1,18,1.27272 111 | 1,23,4.09092 112 | 1,31,2.8182 113 | 1,38,1.63638 114 | 1,39,3.2727 115 | (...) 116 | ``` 117 | 118 | ## Solution Route Sets 119 | Route sets should be presented as Solution Title, number of routes and, for each route, the sequence of nodes. 120 | Authors may include frequency information below, but it is not mandatory, as some papers don't deal with frequency setting. 121 | References to published paper will appear in README.ml inside each instance folder. 122 | 123 | Example (Mandl solution): 124 | ``` 125 | Arbex (2015) Best Compromising 10 routes 126 | 10 127 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 128 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 129 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 130 | 2-4-6-8-10-11-13-14 131 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4 132 | 1-2-5-4-12 133 | 11-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 134 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 135 | 13-11-12-4-5-2-1 136 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 137 | ``` 138 | 139 | Example (Mandl solution, with frequencies (trips per hour) for each line): 140 | ``` 141 | Arbex (2015) Best Compromising 10 routes 142 | 10 143 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 144 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 145 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 146 | 2-4-6-8-10-11-13-14 147 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4 148 | 1-2-5-4-12 149 | 11-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 150 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 151 | 13-11-12-4-5-2-1 152 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 153 | 10.91 154 | 8.44 155 | 6.67 156 | 9.31 157 | 8.57 158 | 3.21 159 | 13.00 160 | 11.74 161 | 3.49 162 | 4.00 163 | ``` 164 | 165 | File names: 166 | Files should be named as to include Instance Name, Number of Solutions and/or if it comprises multiple Pareto Solutions. It is encouraged to include multiple solutions in a single file if this represents a Pareto solution set and/or the same methodology/algorithm route sets. Different methodologies applied to the same instance from the same paper/author can be presented in two different files. If frequencies are available, it should be clear in file name txt for automation purposes. 167 | 168 | Examples: 169 | ``` 170 | instance_author_4to8_routes_solutions_route_sets.txt 171 | Mandl_Arbex(2015)_compromising_route_sets_frequencies.txt 172 | Mandl_Arbex(2014)_67_pareto_solutions_route_sets.txt 173 | Mumford0_Mumford(2013)_4to8_best_passenger_route_sets.txt 174 | Mumford1_Mumford(2013)_55_pareto_solutions_route_sets.txt 175 | ``` 176 | 177 | This is an initial suggestion for file formats, thus we can further adapt from here if needed. 178 | 179 | ## Objective Functions and Additional Data 180 | 181 | This will vary depending on whether you are also calculating frequencies or dealing with large scale instances that require additional information. Authors are strongly encouraged to submit information described above in "How to Add Solution Route Sets and Objective Functions" to ease comparisons of results. 182 | 183 | # Summary of Instances 184 | 185 | As of October 2018, instances in TransitNetworkDesign repository are: 186 | 187 | | Network | Source | Nodes | Links | Terminal Nodes | 188 | |---------- |------------------------- |------- |------- |---------------- | 189 | | Ceder1 | Ceder (2016) Chapter 15 | 4 | 4 | 1 | 190 | | Ceder2 | Ceder (2016) Chapter 15 | 8 | 14 | 2 | 191 | | Mandl1 | Mandl (1979) | 15 | 21 | All | 192 | | Mandl2 | Mandl (1979) adapted | 15 | 21 | 10 | 193 | | Mumford0 | Mumford (2013) | 30 | 90 | All | 194 | | Mumford1 | Mumford (2013) | 70 | 210 | All | 195 | | Mumford2 | Mumford (2013) | 110 | 385 | All | 196 | | Mumford3 | Mumford (2013) | 127 | 425 | All | 197 | | Rivera1 | Mautonne (2005) | 84 | 143 | All | 198 | | Rivera2 | Mautonne (2005) adapted | 84 | 143 | 12 | 199 | 200 | Instances general comments: 201 | 202 | *Ceder1/2*: small networks for researchers starting with this problem. While Ceder1 may be solved by hand, Ceder2 already has millions of possible solutions. Those networks are used by Avishai Ceder in Chapter 15 (Network Design) of his well-known Public Transit Planning and Operation book. 203 | 204 | *Mandl*: the most solved instance in the literature. Usually solved with 4-12 routes. 205 | 206 | *Mumford0,1,2,3*: instances proposed by Mumford(2013) to bridge the gap of instances scarcity. Generated randomly based on real sized networks. 207 | 208 | *Rivera*: instance proposed by Mautonne (2005) using data from Rivera city in Uruguay. 209 | 210 | More details for instances are available within each folder. 211 | 212 | ## Instances References 213 | 214 | [Ceder(2016)](https://www.crcpress.com/Public-Transit-Planning-and-Operation-Modeling-Practice-and-Behavior/Ceder/p/book/9781466563919) 215 | [Mandl(1979)](https://books.google.com.br/books/about/Applied_network_optimization.html?id=xGJRAAAAMAAJ&redir_esc=y) 216 | [Mumford(2013)](https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/6557668) 217 | [Mautonne(2005)](http://www.fing.edu.uy/inco/pedeciba/bibliote/tesis/tesis-mauttone.pdf) 218 | 219 | # Transit Assignment 220 | 221 | To evaluate solution route sets calculating total generalized costs and fleet size, a transit assignment procedure should be applied to assign demand to the network. This a crucial step which opens several possibilities and challenges for evaluation. The aim of this step is to represent users' choices in real-world scenarios so that the maximum passenger load per route can be calculated, which enables calculation of frequencies. But as user choices depends on route frequencies, this assignment procedure should be done until convergence. Also, whenever multiple lines serve an OD pair, demand is split between routes depending on their travel time to the destination and their frequencies, a problem known as the Common Lines Problem. 222 | 223 | Ideally, a complex assignment procedure should be used; however, simplifications are made to enable a fast objective function calculation. Care should be taken for this not affect quality of final results, as the best solutions are those that aim to realistically represent passenger behaviors when choosing routes. 224 | 225 | ## License 226 | 227 | - Data sets are for academic research purposes only and all data is donated from contributors. 228 | - Users of this repository are fully responsible for any results or conclusions obtained by using these data sets. 229 | - Users must indicate the source of any dataset they are using in any publication that relies on any of the datasets provided in this web site. Users may indicate the original location of instances if they are available elsewhere. 230 | - The organizer of this repository is not responsible for the content of the data sets. 231 | - Agencies, organizations, institutions and individuals acknowledged in this web site for their contribution to the datasets are not responsible for the content or the correctness of the datasets. 232 | 233 | ## How to Cite 234 | 235 | [![DOI](https://zenodo.org/badge/DOI/10.5281/zenodo.1473545.svg)](https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1473545) 236 | 237 | Public Transit Networks for Research. *Transit Network Design Instances for Research*. https://github.com/RenatoArbex/TransitNetworkDesign. Accessed Month, Day, Year. 238 | 239 | ## Team 240 | This repository is currently maintained by Public Transit Networks for Research. The current members are: 241 | - Renato Arbex, PhD Candidate at University of São Paulo. [GitHub](https://github.com/RenatoArbex) [Scholar](https://scholar.google.com.br/citations?user=Y3cAEhYAAAAJ&hl=en-US) 242 | 243 | This initiative also aims to be help researchers organize input data and route sets in a similar format for aid for further research. 244 | 245 | This repository was inspired by a similar compendium for Traffic Assignment Problem by the [Transportation Networks for Research Core Team](https://github.com/bstabler/TransportationNetworks). The author congratulates the Transportation Networks for Research Core Team for this great initiative and inspiration. 246 | 247 | ## Other Related Projects 248 | 249 | Transit Network Design research sites 250 | - Research on the Urban Transit Routing Problem (Bus Routing) Christine Mumford (https://users.cs.cf.ac.uk/C.L.Mumford/Research%20Topics/UTRP/Outline.html) 251 | - Antonio Mauttone research group on Transit Network Design Problem (https://www.fing.edu.uy/~mauttone/tndp/) 252 | 253 | Traffic Assignment 254 | - [Transportation Networks for Research Core Team](https://github.com/bstabler/TransportationNetworks) Transportation Networks is a networks repository for transportation research. Aims to congregate network instances for the traffic assignment problem. 255 | 256 | ## Roadmap 257 | 258 | - Proposing in this site a methodology to evaluate route sets using the same assignment algorithm and objective functions using multiple languages such as Python, C++, Java (for comparison purposes) 259 | - Publishing a large instance of São Paulo main trunk transit network (~300 nodes/600 links) once ready 260 | - Organizing results with visualization tools 261 | - Incorporating GTFS as possible instances for transit network design and discussing the differences when dealing with real stop locations 262 | 263 | This site aims to bring together transit network design researchers and practitioners interested in exchanging instances, methodologies and results. Contact me if you would like to contribute more! Help to continue this effort will be greatly appreciated! 264 | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- /Mandl/Mandl1/literature_solutions_for_mandl1_20181025.txt: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 | Nikolic (2013) 4 routes 2 | 4 3 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 4 | 2-5-4-6-8-10-13-11 5 | 9-15-7-10-8-6-4-12 6 | 4-2-3-6-15-7-10-14 7 | 8 | Nikolic (2013) 6 routes 9 | 6 10 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 11 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 12 | 9-15-7-10-14-13-11-12 13 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11 14 | 15-8-10-11-12-4-2-1 15 | 9-15-6-3-2-5-4-12 16 | 17 | Nikolic (2013) 7 routes 18 | 7 19 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 20 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 21 | 9-15-7-10-14-13-11-12 22 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11 23 | 6-8-10-11-12-4-2-1 24 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 25 | 7-15-8-6-4-12-11-13 26 | 27 | Nikolic (2013) 8 routes 28 | 8 29 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 30 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-15-7 31 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-6 32 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14 33 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-12 34 | 1-2-4-12-11-13-14-10 35 | 2-5-4-6-8-10-11-13 36 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13-14 37 | 38 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 4 best passengers 39 | 4 40 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 41 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-14-13 42 | 9-15-7-10-11-13-14 43 | 7-15-6-3-2-4-12-11-13 44 | 45 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 6 best passengers 46 | 6 47 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 48 | 12-11-10-8-6-4 49 | 9-15-7-10-11 50 | 1-2-3-6-15-7 51 | 11-10-8-6-4-5-2-3 52 | 1-2-4-12-11-13-14-10 53 | 54 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 7 best passengers 55 | 7 56 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 57 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 58 | 9-15-7-10-11 59 | 1-2-3-6-15-7 60 | 2-4-6-8-10-14 61 | 11-10-7-15-9 62 | 1-2-4-12-11-13-14-10-8-6 63 | 64 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 8 best passengers 65 | 8 66 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 67 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-10-11-12 68 | 11-10-8-6-4-5-2-1 69 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 70 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11 71 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 72 | 12-11-13-14-10-8-15-6-3-2-5 73 | 13-11-10-7-15-9 74 | 75 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 12 best passengers 76 | 12 77 | 11-10-8 78 | 6-8-10-11 79 | 14-13-11-10-7-15-9 80 | 1-2-3-6-15-7 81 | 10-11-12-4-6-8 82 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 83 | 6-3-2-4-12 84 | 8-15-6-4-5 85 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 86 | 10-8-6-4-5-2-3 87 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-10-11-12 88 | 6-8-10 89 | 90 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 4 best operator 91 | 4 92 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 93 | 5-4-6-8-10 94 | 9-15-7-10-14-13 95 | 4-2-3-6-15-7-10-11-12 96 | 97 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 6 best operator 98 | 6 99 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 100 | 5-4-6-8-10 101 | 9-15-7-10-14-13 102 | 4-2-3-6-15-7 103 | 7-10-11-12 104 | 9-15-6-4 105 | 106 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 7 best operator 107 | 7 108 | 2-3-6-8-10-11 109 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 110 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 111 | 1-2-3-6-15-7 112 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-1 113 | 1-2-4-12-11-13-14-10-8-15 114 | 11-10-8-6 115 | 116 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 8 best operator 117 | 8 118 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11 119 | 1-2-5 120 | 9-15-7-10 121 | 5-2-3-6-15-7-10 122 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-2 123 | 11-12-4-6-15-9 124 | 12-11-13-14 125 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11 126 | 127 | Nikolic and Teodorovic (2014) 12 best operator 128 | 12 129 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11 130 | 5-4-6-15-9 131 | 9-15-7-10 132 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 133 | 12-11-13 134 | 2-4-12 135 | 12-11-13 136 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 137 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 138 | 4-6-15-7-10 139 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 140 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-13-14 141 | 142 | Buba and Lee (2018) 4 routes 143 | 4 144 | 12-11-10-8-6-4-5-2 145 | 14-10-13-11-12-4-2-1 146 | 9-15-7-10-8-6 147 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 148 | 149 | Buba and Lee (2018) 6 routes 150 | 6 151 | 5-4-6-3-2-1 152 | 12-11-13-14-10-7-15-9 153 | 5-4-6-8-10-11-12 154 | 1-2-4-12-11-10-14-13 155 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-13-11 156 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-8 157 | 158 | Buba and Lee (2018) 7 routes 159 | 7 160 | 9-15-7-10-8-6-3-2 161 | 1-2-4-12-11-10-14-13 162 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 163 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-13 164 | 9-15-7-10-8-6-4-5 165 | 9-15-8-10-14-13-11-12 166 | 13-11-12-4-5-2-1 167 | 168 | Buba and Lee (2018) 8 routes 169 | 8 170 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-13 171 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13-10 172 | 9-15-8-6-4-12 173 | 1-2-3-6-15-9 174 | 6-3-2-4-12-11-10 175 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-14 176 | 11-13-14-10-7-15-9 177 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 178 | 179 | Buba and Lee (2018) 12 routes 180 | 12 181 | 1-2-5-4 182 | 5-2-3 183 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 184 | 5-4-12-11-13-14-10-8 185 | 1-2-5-4-12-11 186 | 1-2-4-12 187 | 4-6-8-10-13 188 | 2-3-6-15-7-10-11-12 189 | 10-13-11-12-4-6-3-2 190 | 12-4-6-8-10-14 191 | 9-15-8-6-4-5-2 192 | 9-15-7-10-8-6-4 193 | 194 | Mandl (1980) 4 routes 195 | 4 196 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 197 | 5-4-6-8-15-7 198 | 12-4-6-15-9 199 | 13-14-10 200 | 201 | Baaj and Mahmassani (1991) 6 lines 202 | 6 203 | 7-15-8-10-11-12 204 | 7-15-6-8-10-14-13 205 | 1-2-3-6-8 206 | 9-15-7-10 207 | 5-4-6-8-10 208 | 1-2-3-6-15-9 209 | 210 | Baaj and Mahmassani (1991) 7 lines 211 | 7 212 | 10-13 213 | 10-11-12 214 | 10-14 215 | 1-2-3-6-8-10 216 | 9-15-7-10 217 | 5-4-6-8-10 218 | 1-2-4-5 219 | 220 | Baaj and Mahmassani (1991) 8 lines 221 | 8 222 | 1-2-4-12-11-13-14 223 | 3-6-8-15-7-10 224 | 10-11-13 225 | 10-11-12 226 | 8-10-14 227 | 1-2-4-6 228 | 9-15-6-8-10 229 | 5-2-3-6-15-7-10 230 | 231 | Chakroborty (2002) 4 lines 232 | 4 233 | 6-8-10-7-15 234 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-3-2-5-4-12 235 | 9-15-6-4-2 236 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-13-11-12 237 | 238 | Chakroborty (2002) 6 lines 239 | 6 240 | 13-11-12-4 241 | 10-14-13-11-10-7-15-8-6-4-2-1 242 | 14-13-11-10-7-15-8-6-4 243 | 12-11-10-8-6-3-2-5 244 | 1-2-5-4-6-8 245 | 10-11-12-4-6-15-9 246 | 247 | Chakroborty (2002) 7 lines 248 | 7 249 | 13-11-10-7 250 | 10-7-15-8-6-4 251 | 5-2-3-6-8-10-11-13-14 252 | 11-10-14-13-11-12-4 253 | 9-15-6-4-12-11-10 254 | 6-4-5-2-1 255 | 13-11-10-7-15-8-6-3-2-1 256 | 257 | Chakroborty (2002) 8 lines 258 | 8 259 | 4-6-3-6-15-9 260 | 6-8-10-7 261 | 7-10-11-13-14 262 | 3-6-8-10-11-13-14 263 | 5-2-3-6-4-2-1 264 | 7-10-8-6-3-2-1 265 | 12-11-10-13 266 | 1-2-3 267 | 268 | Bagloee and Ceder (2011) 12 routes 269 | 12 270 | 10-8-6-3-2-1 271 | 10-7-15-9 272 | 7-15-6-3-2 273 | 7-15-6-4-5 274 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-14 275 | 13-10-8-6-3-2-1 276 | 12-11-10-7 277 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-1 278 | 9-15-7-10-13 279 | 4-6-8-10-11 280 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 281 | 10-11-12 282 | 283 | Arbex (2015) Best Compromising 10 routes 284 | 10 285 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 286 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 287 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 288 | 2-4-6-8-10-11-13-14 289 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4 290 | 1-2-5-4-12 291 | 11-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 292 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 293 | 13-11-12-4-5-2-1 294 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 295 | 296 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 1C1 297 | 8 298 | 1-2-3-6-8-10 299 | 9-15-8 300 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 301 | 12-4-2-3 302 | 7-10-11-13 303 | 10-11-12 304 | 2-3-6-8-10-14-13 305 | 1-2-3-6-15-7 306 | 307 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 2C1 308 | 8 309 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 310 | 9-15-7-10-11 311 | 11-10-8-6-4 312 | 12-11-10 313 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-12 314 | 5-4-6-8-15-7-10 315 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 316 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 317 | 318 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 3C1 319 | 9 320 | 1-2-4-6-8-10 321 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 322 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 323 | 10-11-12 324 | 5-2-3-6-8-10 325 | 10-7-15-9 326 | 2-3-6-8-10-14-13 327 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11-13 328 | 2-4-6-15-7-10-14-13 329 | 330 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 4C1 331 | 8 332 | 1-2-4-6-8-15-7 333 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 334 | 3-6-8-10-11 335 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 336 | 13-14-10-8-6-4 337 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 338 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-1 339 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-5 340 | 341 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 5C1 342 | 10 343 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 344 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 345 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 346 | 12-11-10 347 | 10-8-6-4-2 348 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 349 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-5 350 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 351 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 352 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 353 | 354 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 6C1 355 | 9 356 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 357 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 358 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 359 | 12-11-10-7 360 | 10-8-6-4-5 361 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-1 362 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-15-9 363 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4 364 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-5 365 | 366 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 7C1 367 | 10 368 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 369 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 370 | 12-11-10-7 371 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4 372 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-1 373 | 1-2-5-4-12 374 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 375 | 1-2-4-6-8-15-7 376 | 7-15-6-3-2-4-5 377 | 5-2-3-6-8-10 378 | 379 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 8C1 380 | 8 381 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 382 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 383 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 384 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-5 385 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 386 | 13-11-12-4-2-1 387 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 388 | 7-15-8-6-4-2-1 389 | 390 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 9C1 391 | 8 392 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 393 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 394 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 395 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 396 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 397 | 13-11-12-4-2-1 398 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 399 | 7-15-8-6-4-2-1 400 | 401 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 10C1 402 | 10 403 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 404 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 405 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 406 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4 407 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-1 408 | 1-2-5-4-12 409 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 410 | 1-2-4-6-15-7 411 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 412 | 5-4-6-8-10 413 | 414 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 11C1 415 | 10 416 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 417 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 418 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 419 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4 420 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-1 421 | 1-2-5-4-12 422 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 423 | 1-2-4-6-8-15-7 424 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 425 | 10-8-6-4-5 426 | 427 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 1C2 428 | 9 429 | 1-2-4-6-8-10 430 | 9-15-7-10 431 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-5 432 | 13-11-12-4-2-1 433 | 9-15-8-10-11 434 | 11-10-8-6-3-2 435 | 12-11-10 436 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-1 437 | 12-4-6-8-15-7 438 | 439 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 2C2 440 | 9 441 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11-13 442 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 443 | 3-6-15-7-10-14-13 444 | 7-15-8-6-4-12 445 | 10-8-6-4-5 446 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 447 | 2-3-6-8-10-14 448 | 10-8-6-4-2-1 449 | 12-11-10 450 | 451 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 3C2 452 | 11 453 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-9 454 | 9-15-7-10-11 455 | 7-15-8-6-4-5 456 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 457 | 6-8-10-11 458 | 2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13 459 | 1-2-4-6-8-10-14-13 460 | 12-11-10 461 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 462 | 2-3-6-8-10 463 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 464 | 465 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 4C2 466 | 8 467 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 468 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 469 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 470 | 12-11-10 471 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-5 472 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 473 | 4-6-15-7-10-11-13 474 | 4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 475 | 476 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 5C2 477 | 9 478 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 479 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 480 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11 481 | 12-11-10 482 | 13-11-10-7-15-6-4-5 483 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-3-2 484 | 5-4-2-1 485 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 486 | 2-4-6-8-10-14-13 487 | 488 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 6C2 489 | 11 490 | 1-2-4-5 491 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 492 | 12-11-10 493 | 4-6-8-10-11-13-14 494 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 495 | 10-7-15-8-6-3-2-1 496 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-2 497 | 10-7-15-6-4-5 498 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 499 | 9-15-7-10-11 500 | 5-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 501 | 502 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 7C2 503 | 10 504 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-9 505 | 9-15-7-10-11 506 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 507 | 12-11-10 508 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 509 | 12-4-6-8-15-7 510 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 511 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 512 | 1-2-4-5 513 | 2-3-6-15-7-10-11-13 514 | 515 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 8C2 516 | 12 517 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 518 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-5 519 | 4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13-14 520 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 521 | 6-8-10-11-13 522 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-3-2 523 | 12-11-10 524 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 525 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 526 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 527 | 5-4-6-8-10-11-13 528 | 1-2-4-5 529 | 530 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 9C2 531 | 8 532 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 533 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 534 | 5-4-6-8-10-14-13 535 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-15-9 536 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 537 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13 538 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 539 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4 540 | 541 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 10C2 542 | 11 543 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11 544 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 545 | 5-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 546 | 5-4-2-3-6-15-7 547 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13 548 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 549 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11 550 | 4-6-8-10-11-13-14 551 | 9-15-8-6-4-2-1 552 | 5-4-6-8-10 553 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 554 | 555 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 11C2 556 | 10 557 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 558 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 559 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 560 | 2-4-6-8-10-11-13-14 561 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4 562 | 1-2-5-4-12 563 | 11-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 564 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 565 | 13-11-12-4-5-2-1 566 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 567 | 568 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 12C2 569 | 12 570 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13 571 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 572 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 573 | 10-11-12 574 | 7-15-6-3-2-4-5 575 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11 576 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 577 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13 578 | 1-2-3-6-8-10 579 | 1-2-4-6-8-10-14-13 580 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 581 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-2-3 582 | 583 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 1C3 584 | 5 585 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 586 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 587 | 12-11-10 588 | 5-4-6-8-10-14-13 589 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 590 | 591 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 2C3 592 | 8 593 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 594 | 9-15-7-10-11 595 | 4-6-8-10-14-13 596 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 597 | 12-11-10 598 | 4-6-8-10-11 599 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 600 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-9 601 | 602 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 3C3 603 | 6 604 | 9-15-6-8-10-11-12 605 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11-13 606 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 607 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 608 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4 609 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-4-5 610 | 611 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 4C3 612 | 9 613 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 614 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 615 | 12-11-10-7 616 | 12-11-10 617 | 5-2-3-6-15-7-10-11-13 618 | 13-11-12-4-2-1 619 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-4 620 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11 621 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4 622 | 623 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 5C3 624 | 11 625 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11 626 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 627 | 7-10-11-12 628 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 629 | 10-11-12 630 | 10-8-6 631 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 632 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-5 633 | 13-14-10-8-6-4 634 | 5-4-6-15-7-10 635 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-5 636 | 637 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 6C3 638 | 9 639 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11-13 640 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 641 | 10-11-12 642 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 643 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-9 644 | 10-7-15-6-4-5 645 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 646 | 13-14-10-8-6-4 647 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 648 | 649 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 7C3 650 | 8 651 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11-13 652 | 9-15-6-8-10-11-12 653 | 12-4-2-3-6-15-7 654 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 655 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 656 | 2-4-6-8-10-14-13 657 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 658 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 659 | 660 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 8C3 661 | 9 662 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 663 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11-13 664 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4 665 | 5-4-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13 666 | 10-11-12 667 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 668 | 5-2-4-6-8-10 669 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 670 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 671 | 672 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 9C3 673 | 12 674 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 675 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11-13 676 | 7-15-8-6-3 677 | 4-6-8-10-11-13-14 678 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 679 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 680 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 681 | 14-10-8-6-4-2 682 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-5 683 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11 684 | 10-8-6-4 685 | 10-11-12 686 | 687 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 10C3 688 | 12 689 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 690 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11-13 691 | 7-15-6-3 692 | 4-6-8-10-11-13-14 693 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 694 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 695 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 696 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4-2 697 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-5 698 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11 699 | 10-8-6-4 700 | 10-11-12 701 | 702 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 11C3 703 | 11 704 | 9-15-6-8-10-11-12 705 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11-13 706 | 11-10-8-6-4 707 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-15-9 708 | 14-10-8-6-4-2-3 709 | 12-11-10-8 710 | 5-4-6-15-7-10-14-13 711 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 712 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 713 | 5-4-6-8-10-14-13 714 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 715 | 716 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 1C4 717 | 6 718 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 719 | 9-15-8-10 720 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 721 | 12-11-10 722 | 2-4-6-8-10-14-13 723 | 2-3-6-8-10-11-13 724 | 725 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 2C4 726 | 7 727 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 728 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 729 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-5 730 | 11-13-14 731 | 12-11-10 732 | 13-14-10-8-6 733 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-4 734 | 735 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 3C4 736 | 9 737 | 1-2-4-6-8-10 738 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 739 | 11-10-7-15-6-4-5 740 | 12-11-10 741 | 13-11-10-7-15-6-3-2 742 | 10-7-15-8-6-3-2-1 743 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 744 | 2-3-6-8-10-11-13 745 | 13-11-12-4-2-1 746 | 747 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 4C4 748 | 8 749 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11 750 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 751 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 752 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-4-5 753 | 10-7-15-6-3-2 754 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 755 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 756 | 12-11-10 757 | 758 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 5C4 759 | 8 760 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 761 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 762 | 12-11-10 763 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 764 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 765 | 12-11-10-7 766 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-4-5 767 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-2 768 | 769 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 6C4 770 | 10 771 | 1-2-4-5 772 | 9-15-6-8-10-11 773 | 12-11-10 774 | 12-11-10-7 775 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 776 | 13-11-10-7-15-6-3-2 777 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 778 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-2 779 | 5-4-6-8-15-7-10-14-13 780 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 781 | 782 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 7C4 783 | 6 784 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11 785 | 9-15-6-8-10-11-12 786 | 11-10-8-6-4 787 | 5-4-6-15-7-10-11-13 788 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 789 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 790 | 791 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 8C4 792 | 8 793 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 794 | 9-15-6-8-10-11-12 795 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 796 | 5-4-6-15-7-10 797 | 11-10-7-15-8-6-3-2-1 798 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-3-2-4 799 | 5-4-6-8-10-14-13 800 | 1-2-5-4-12 801 | 802 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 9C4 803 | 8 804 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13 805 | 9-15-6-8-10-11-12 806 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-3-2-4-5 807 | 5-4-6-8-10 808 | 11-10-7-15-8-6-3-2-1 809 | 13-14-10-8-6-4 810 | 5-4-6-8-10-11-13 811 | 1-2-5-4-12 812 | 813 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 10C4 814 | 11 815 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 816 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 817 | 5-4-6-8-10-11-13 818 | 5-4-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13 819 | 13-11-12-4-2-1 820 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4-2 821 | 5-4-6-15-7-10-11 822 | 2-4-6-8-10-11 823 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11 824 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 825 | 5-4-2-1 826 | 827 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 11C4 828 | 11 829 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 830 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 831 | 5-4-6-8-10-11-13 832 | 5-4-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13 833 | 13-11-12-4-2-1 834 | 14-13-11-10-8-6-4-2 835 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 836 | 2-3-6-8-10-11 837 | 4-6-15-7-10-14-13 838 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 839 | 5-4-2-1 840 | 841 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 12C4 842 | 12 843 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11 844 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 845 | 5-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 846 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 847 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-4-5 848 | 10-11-12 849 | 6-8-10-14 850 | 2-3-6-8-10-11-13-14 851 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 852 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 853 | 10-8-6-3-2-4-5 854 | 2-4-6-8-10-11-13-14 855 | 856 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 13C4 857 | 12 858 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 859 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-1 860 | 5-4-6-8-15-7-10-14-13 861 | 13-11-12-4-5-2-1 862 | 12-11-10-8-6-15-9 863 | 14-13-11-10-7-15-6-3-2-4 864 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 865 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11 866 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11-13 867 | 4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 868 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 869 | 1-2-4-6-8-10-14-13 870 | 871 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 14C4 872 | 12 873 | 1-2-3-6-8-10 874 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-1 875 | 5-4-6-8-15-7-10-14-13 876 | 13-11-12-4-5-2-1 877 | 12-11-10-8-6-15-9 878 | 14-13-11-10-7-15-6-3-2-4 879 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 880 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10-11 881 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11-13 882 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-1 883 | 11-10-8-6-3-2-4-5 884 | 1-2-4-6-8-10-14-13 885 | 886 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 1C5 887 | 6 888 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 889 | 9-15-6-4-12 890 | 5-4-6-8-10-14-13 891 | 11-10-8-6-3-2 892 | 12-11-10 893 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-2 894 | 895 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 2C5 896 | 8 897 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 898 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-12 899 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 900 | 2-4-6-8-10-11-13 901 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-3 902 | 10-11-12 903 | 13-14-10-7 904 | 9-15-6-4-5 905 | 906 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 3C5 907 | 8 908 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 909 | 9-15-7-10-11 910 | 3-6-8-15-7 911 | 10-11-12 912 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-12 913 | 5-4-6-8-10-11-13 914 | 13-11-10-8-6-4 915 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 916 | 917 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 4C5 918 | 9 919 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13 920 | 9-15-6-8-10-11-12 921 | 12-4-2-3-6-15-8 922 | 12-11-10 923 | 10-7-15-6-4-2 924 | 5-2-3-6-8-10-11 925 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-5 926 | 10-8-6-4-5 927 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 928 | 929 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 5C5 930 | 10 931 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 932 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 933 | 10-11-12 934 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-5 935 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 936 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 937 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-1 938 | 11-10-7-15-6-4-2 939 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 940 | 9-15-7-10 941 | 942 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 6C5 943 | 10 944 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 945 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 946 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 947 | 12-11-10-8-15-9 948 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 949 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-1 950 | 2-4-6-8-10-11-13-14 951 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 952 | 7-10-11-12 953 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 954 | 955 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 7C5 956 | 8 957 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 958 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 959 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 960 | 5-4-2-3-6-15-7 961 | 10-7-15-6-4-5 962 | 5-4-6-8-10 963 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 964 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-2 965 | 966 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 8C5 967 | 8 968 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 969 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 970 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 971 | 10-8-6-4-5 972 | 5-4-6-15-7-10-14-13 973 | 7-15-6-3-2 974 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 975 | 6-15-7-10-14-13 976 | 977 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 9C5 978 | 8 979 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 980 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 981 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 982 | 5-2-3-6-8-15-7 983 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-4-5 984 | 11-10-8-6-4-5 985 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 986 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-2 987 | 988 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 10C5 989 | 11 990 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10 991 | 9-15-8-10-11-12 992 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 993 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 994 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 995 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-1 996 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 997 | 4-6-8-10-14 998 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-5 999 | 9-15-8 1000 | 5-4-6-8-10-14-13 1001 | 1002 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 11C5 1003 | 9 1004 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1005 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 1006 | 7-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 1007 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 1008 | 5-4-6-8-10-14-13 1009 | 3-6-15-7-10-14-13 1010 | 5-4-6-8-10-11 1011 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-4-2 1012 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-5 1013 | 1014 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 12C5 1015 | 11 1016 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1017 | 9-15-8-10-11-12 1018 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-15-7 1019 | 10-7-15-8-6-3 1020 | 9-15-7-10-11-12 1021 | 13-11-10-8-6-4-5 1022 | 5-2-3-6-15-7-10-11 1023 | 2-4-6-15-7-10 1024 | 5-2-4-6-8-10 1025 | 5-4-2-3-6-15-7-10 1026 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-5 1027 | 1028 | Arbex (2014) Pareto 13C5 1029 | 7 1030 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12 1031 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1032 | 7-15-6-3-2-5 1033 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 1034 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-4-5 1035 | 13-14-10-8-6-4-5 1036 | 10-7-15-6-3-2-4-5 1037 | 1038 | Mumford (2013) 4 best passenger 1039 | 4 1040 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1041 | 9-15-6-4-12-11-13-14 1042 | 14-10-7-15-6-4-2-1 1043 | 12-11-10-8-6-4-5-2 1044 | 1045 | Mumford (2013) 6 best passenger 1046 | 6 1047 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-11 1048 | 12-11-13-14-10-7-15-9 1049 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 1050 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-13-11 1051 | 1-2-4-12-11-10-14-13 1052 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-15-7 1053 | 1054 | Mumford (2013) 7 best passenger 1055 | 7 1056 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-10-13 1057 | 9-15-7-10-14-13-11-12 1058 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-10-14 1059 | 8-10-11-12-4-2-3-6 1060 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1061 | 14-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 1062 | 10-7-15-8-6-4-2-1 1063 | 1064 | Mumford (2013) 8 best passenger 1065 | 8 1066 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-13 1067 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-5-4 1068 | 15-7-10-14-13-11-12-4 1069 | 1-2-4-6-8-15-7-10 1070 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-1 1071 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13-14 1072 | 11-13-14-10-8-6-4-5 1073 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-5 1074 | 1075 | Mumford (2013) 4 best operator 1076 | 4 1077 | 9-15 1078 | 1-2-4-5 1079 | 11-10-7-15-8-6-3-2 1080 | 14-13-11-12 1081 | 1082 | Mumford (2013) 6 best operator 1083 | 6 1084 | 10-11-13 1085 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 1086 | 5-4-2 1087 | 14-13 1088 | 12-11 1089 | 9-15 1090 | 1091 | Mumford (2013) 7 best operator 1092 | 7 1093 | 12-11-13 1094 | 14-13 1095 | 5-4 1096 | 11-10 1097 | 10-7-15-8-6-3-2-1 1098 | 4-2 1099 | 9-15 1100 | 1101 | Mumford (2013) 8 best operator 1102 | 8 1103 | 12-11 1104 | 5-4 1105 | 13-14 1106 | 9-15 1107 | 1-2 1108 | 11-13 1109 | 2-4 1110 | 11-10-7-15-8-6-3-2 1111 | 1112 | Chew and Lee (2013) 4 routes passenger 1113 | 4 1114 | 13-14-10-8-6-3-2-1 1115 | 9-15-8-10-11-12-4-2 1116 | 11-10-7-15-6-3-2-5 1117 | 12-11-13-10-8-6-4-5 1118 | 1119 | Chew and Lee (2013) 6 routes passenger 1120 | 6 1121 | 13-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 1122 | 11-10-8-6-4-5-2-1 1123 | 5-4-12-11-10-7-15-9 1124 | 10-14-13-11-12-4-2-1 1125 | 7-15-8-6-4-5-2-3 1126 | 12-11-10-8-6-3-2-1 1127 | 1128 | Chew and Lee (2013) 7 routes passenger 1129 | 7 1130 | 13-10-7-15-8-6-4-5 1131 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 1132 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-2 1133 | 14-13-11-12-4-5-2-1 1134 | 5-4-6-8-10-11-13 1135 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14 1136 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1137 | 1138 | Chew and Lee (2013) 8 routes passenger 1139 | 8 1140 | 14-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 1141 | 11-10-8-6-4-5-2 1142 | 13-11-10-8-6-3-2-1 1143 | 11-12-4-2-1 1144 | 14-13-11-12-4-5-2-1 1145 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-5 1146 | 14-10-7-15-8-6-4-5 1147 | 12-11-10-7-15-9 1148 | 1149 | Chew and Lee (2013) 4 routes operator 1150 | 4 1151 | 5-4-2-1 1152 | 11-10-7-15-8-6-3-2 1153 | 9-15 1154 | 12-11-13-14 1155 | 1156 | Chew and Lee (2013) 6 routes operator 1157 | 6 1158 | 10-7-15-8-6-3-2-1 1159 | 11-12 1160 | 5-4-2 1161 | 14-13 1162 | 13-11-10 1163 | 9-15 1164 | 1165 | Chew and Lee (2013) 7 routes operator 1166 | 7 1167 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 1168 | 4-2 1169 | 12-11 1170 | 13-11-10 1171 | 5-4 1172 | 9-15 1173 | 14-13 1174 | 1175 | Chew and Lee (2013) 8 routes operator 1176 | 8 1177 | 10-7-15-8-6-3-2-4 1178 | 12-11 1179 | 13-11 1180 | 2-1 1181 | 9-15 1182 | 4-5 1183 | 11-10 1184 | 14-13 1185 | 1186 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 4 routes 1187 | 4 1188 | 14-10-7-15-6-4-2-1 1189 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-2 1190 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 1191 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1192 | 1193 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 6 routes 1194 | 6 1195 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1196 | 9-15-7-10-11-13 1197 | 14-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 1198 | 10-11-12-4-6-8-15-7 1199 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 1200 | 14-13-11-12-4-2-1 1201 | 1202 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 7 routes 1203 | 7 1204 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-12 1205 | 3-2-5-4-6-15-7-10 1206 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1207 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 1208 | 9-15-7-10-14-13-11-12 1209 | 11-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 1210 | 10-11-12-4-6-8-15-7 1211 | 1212 | Kechagiopoulus (2014) Best 8 routes 1213 | 8 1214 | 9-15-6-4-12-11-13-14 1215 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1216 | 1-2-4-12-11-10 1217 | 1-2-5-4-6-15-7-10 1218 | 14-10-7-15-8-6-4-5 1219 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-2 1220 | 14-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 1221 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 1222 | 1223 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 4 Lines HC 1224 | 4 1225 | 9-15-7-10-8-6-4-5 1226 | 1-2-4-12-11-13-14-10 1227 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 1228 | 1-2-3-6-15-7 1229 | 1230 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 6 Lines HC 1231 | 6 1232 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1233 | 7-15-8-6-4-12-11-10 1234 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14 1235 | 12-11-13-14-10-8-15-9 1236 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-11 1237 | 3-2-4-12 1238 | 1239 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 7 Lines HC 1240 | 7 1241 | 3-2-5-4-12-11-13 1242 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1243 | 12-11-13-14-10-8-6-4 1244 | 5-4-6-8-15-7-10-14 1245 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-13 1246 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-2 1247 | 1-2-5 1248 | 1249 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 8 Lines HC 1250 | 8 1251 | 12-4-2-3-6-8-10-14 1252 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1253 | 1-2-4-12-11-13 1254 | 12-4-6-8-10-14-13-11 1255 | 1-2-3-6-15-7 1256 | 2-5-4-6-8-15-7-10 1257 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-5 1258 | 1-2-5-4-12 1259 | 1260 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 4 Lines TS 1261 | 4 1262 | 12-11-13-14-10-7-15-9 1263 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12 1264 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-13 1265 | 7-15-8-6-4-12 1266 | 1267 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 6 Lines TS 1268 | 6 1269 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-12-11 1270 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-14 1271 | 5-4-12-11-13-14 1272 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-6 1273 | 4-5-2-3-6-15-7-10 1274 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1275 | 1276 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 7 Lines TS 1277 | 7 1278 | 10-11-12-4-6-3-2-5 1279 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-5 1280 | 11-10-8-6-4-5-2-1 1281 | 14-13-10-11-12-4-2-1 1282 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 1283 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-14-13 1284 | 7-15-6-4-12-11-13-10 1285 | 1286 | Kilic and Gok (2014) 8 Lines TS 1287 | 8 1288 | 2-5-4-6-8-10-13-11 1289 | 5-4-2-3-6-8-10-14 1290 | 10-13-11-12-4-6-15-7 1291 | 1-2-3-6-8-15-7-10 1292 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1293 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-2 1294 | 1-2-5-4-12-11-13-14 1295 | 9-15-8-6-4-12-11 1296 | 1297 | Nayeem et al (2014) 4 routes 1298 | 4 1299 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-12-4-5 1300 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-13-14 1301 | 9-15-7-10-14-13-11-12-4-2-1 1302 | 13-14-10-7-15-6-3-2-1 1303 | 1304 | Nayeem et al (2014) 6 routes 1305 | 6 1306 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1307 | 1-2-5-4-6-8-10-13-14 1308 | 5-2-3-6-4-12-11-10-7-15-9 1309 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13-11-12-4-5 1310 | 9-15-6-3-2-1 1311 | 1-2-4-12-11-13-14-10-8-15-7 1312 | 1313 | Nayeem et al (2014) 7 routes 1314 | 7 1315 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13-14 1316 | 11-13-14-10-8-6-4-5-2-3 1317 | 14-13-11-10-7-15-8-6-4-5-2-1 1318 | 9-15-6-3-2-1 1319 | 9-15-6-3-2-4-12-11-13-14-10 1320 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13-11-12-4-5 1321 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-2-1 1322 | 1323 | Nayeem et al (2014) 8 routes 1324 | 8 1325 | 1-2-3-6-8-10-11-13 1326 | 3-2-5-4-6-8-10-11-13 1327 | 9-15-6-3-2-1 1328 | 9-15-8-6-3-2-4-12-11-10-14-13 1329 | 12-11-13-14-10-7-15-8-6-4-5-2-1 1330 | 1-2-3-6-15-7-10-14-13-11-12-4-5 1331 | 9-15-6-4-12-11-13-14-10-8 1332 | 9-15-7-10-11-12-4-2-1 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------